osgart
Nothing my eye, Something for sure
In regards to the OP question, in Catholicism we are taught not to judge as that's God's domain, but we do have the right and obligation to evaluate.
Not to judge in what sense?
How is evaluation not a judgment?
When I think of evaluate that means to assess the value of someone, or something.
So perhaps a Catholic can not judge a person's ultimate fate or destiny, but they can evaluate behavior and actions and take precautions. Is that right?