Tough call. I think the answer is neither.
I think I've been on my own path for my whole life. Part of it began under a specific religion, and I think it was some of those teachings of that religion (that I should follow truth as I understand it to be) that lead me to honor and follow what I believed to be so -- which also resulted in me leaving that church. That's my way of "following God's guidance". I used to refer to myself as "Catholic", and now I just don't see the point in a label, or going through the motions of certain things I think are unnecessary.
I don't experience it now as a slamming the door on that part of my past, or rejecting it as part of new and completely different approach -- just simply having that religion as a foundation, and then continuing on down the road of life -- and when I look back, occasionally agreeing and occasionally disagreeing with what I remember, or what I see happening there now.
I don't expect some other religion to have "the answers" to the certain questions that really only come from within.