• Welcome to Religious Forums, a friendly forum to discuss all religions in a friendly surrounding.

    Your voice is missing! You will need to register to get access to the following site features:
    • Reply to discussions and create your own threads.
    • Our modern chat room. No add-ons or extensions required, just login and start chatting!
    • Access to private conversations with other members.

    We hope to see you as a part of our community soon!

Transgender people cannot be godparents, says Vatican

Saint Frankenstein

Wanderer From Afar
Premium Member
Haha you're making having good ratings and "a lot of posts" as a base for legitimacy? Well with that logic I guess Bill O'Reily is the wisest and most Intelligent man on the planet, anyways this argument has degraded. It's too bad.. You could've gained some insight. I heard tapatalk hadn't been taken over by the regressives yet, like Reddit, apparently I'm too late.
The argument has degraded because of you. You brought up a point about reproduction, I responded to your point and asked you a question. Then you get rude with me. I answered all your questions. You call me a "troll", when I answer your damn question. Now you're going on about some other nonsense. Go fly a kite, for all I care. You're just trolling and derailing the thread. Goodbye.
 
The argument has degraded because of you. You brought up a point about reproduction, I responded to your point and asked you a question. Then you get rude with me. I answered all your questions. You call me a "troll", when I answer your damn question. Now you're going on about some other nonsense. Go fly a kite, for all I care. You're just trolling and derailing the thread. Goodbye.
You sent me a link of a news article written by John Shammas, in which he left no scientific citations, a wikedpia link (really Wikipedia? The sources they listed were junk and lead me no where) and some random google pics... I'm degrading the conversation?
 

lovesong

:D
Premium Member
there is no reason why a transsexual should feel suicidal just for perceiving they have the wrong gender. That's very silly.
Who are you to tell someone that their reason for being suicidal is silly? If the person is genuinely depressed, for any reason, there is no reason to tell them they're silly. Not feeling comfortable in your skin, whether it be for gender or any other reasons, can lead to self esteem issues. Self esteem issues, when they get really bad, can lead to pretty bad depression. That level of depression can lead to suicidal thoughts. Add some bullying for being different in there and you have yourself a real recipe for disaster. Until you've been in such a low place because of body image and self esteem problems, you have no place to talk.
 

Acim

Revelation all the time
I would provide you with references to the science (neither "liberal" nor "pseudo-scientific") behind what I said, but you've just demonstrated that you either will not or could not actually read and comprehend it, and therefore I'd rather not waste me energy.

I'd like to see whatever studies you wish to put forth that say it (sexual orientation) is mostly to all innate.

What follows is not directed at you, Shadow Wolf, just meant to provide some substantiation (and a tiny bit of the science I mentioned earlier):

A study called "Brain response to putative pheromones in homosexual men" by Ivanka Savic, Hans Berglund, Per Lindstrom, circa 2005.

I shall translate: since pheromones operate directly on the olfactory>nervous>response mechanisms at the physical/brain (and below the conscious) level, then the brains of some people are wired differently than those of others -- and this has zero to do with consciousness or choice.

It certainly is not saying that people wired differently, when they engage in actions (or even attractions) it has zero to do with consciousness or choice. It is, at most saying: "our brain reacts differently to the two putative pheromones compared with common odors, and suggest a link between sexual orientation and hypothalamic neuronal processes."

"Suggests a link" doesn't equal zero to do with consciousness in choice. But if you have other things which back up such a position, I'd be most interested in reading about it. Personally, I don't think you do.
 

Aštra’el

Aštara, Blade of Aštoreth
Self esteem issues, when they get really bad, can lead to pretty bad depression. That level of depression can lead to suicidal thoughts.

I like to encourage people not to underestimate the strength of their own willpower, resolve and fortitude. Self esteem issues arise in the mind of the individual. The individual always has a choice to overcome these issues, or to let them consume him/ her.



 

lovesong

:D
Premium Member
I like to encourage people not to underestimate the strength of their own willpower, resolve and fortitude. Self esteem issues arise in the mind of the individual. The individual always has a choice to overcome these issues, or to let them consume him/ her.
Sometimes they can't without help. For those who's self esteem issues derive from others' hate, the ideas can be so engrained in them that they cannot be overcome without some kind of positive influence working to reshape their psyche.
 

MountainPine

Deuteronomy 30:16
Your disability is natural. Once again, natural does not mean normal, the normal progression, the normal status quo. It means occurs in nature. And diseases and disorders which are not genetic or inherited, including disorders due to damages to the womb, are still part of nature.

I suppose you believe that nature encompasses all? If so, then tell me, is sociopathy / psychopathy natural? Is pedophilia natural? What about zoophilia? Is murder natural?
 
I suppose you believe that nature encompasses all? If so, then tell me, is sociopathy / psychopathy natural? Is pedophilia natural? What about zoophilia? Is murder natural?
Anything within this realm, the natural world (physical realm) IS natural. There are different variations that could be, subjectivley, considered natural or unatural within a moral or social norm but when speaking overall the only thing "unatural" is metaphysical.
 

Koldo

Outstanding Member
I must confess I haven't read the entire topic so excuse me if this has been brought up before...
However, If the church was to accept transsexual individuals as godparents, how would they be labeled by the church? Would a trans man be regarded as a godfather or as a godmother ?
Damned if you do, damned if you don't.
 

ADigitalArtist

Veteran Member
Staff member
Premium Member
I suppose you believe that nature encompasses all? If so, then tell me, is sociopathy / psychopathy natural? Is pedophilia natural? What about zoophilia? Is murder natural?
Yes to all of those. As, again, they all occur in nature. Natural doesn't mean good or bad, doesn't mean positive or negative, doesn't mean moral or amoral, doesn't mean normal or abnormal. It just means occurs in nature.
 

ADigitalArtist

Veteran Member
Staff member
Premium Member
I must confess I haven't read the entire topic so excuse me if this has been brought up before...
However, If the church was to accept transsexual individuals as godparents, how would they be labeled by the church? Would a trans man be regarded as a godfather or as a godmother ?
Damned if you do, damned if you don't.
Probably by the gender they identify with, like the rest of us.
 

ADigitalArtist

Veteran Member
Staff member
Premium Member
I don't assign myself to your cis gender generalizing definitions!
Body dysphoria isn't limited to a discussion of gender at all, let alone CIS gender or gender binaries. But it has to be backed up by some clinical science. There's a handful of Tumblr kids and Reddit kids I don't know why people give so much attention to using dysphoria as a substitute for a groan-worthy "soul of a [blank]." But neither they nor the edgelords intent on being the anti-snowflakes (and man they all act the same) bother to do the actual research into clinical dysphoria and why it exists and how it applies to real psychology.
 
Body dysphoria isn't limited to a discussion of gender at all, let alone CIS gender or gender binaries. But it has to be backed up by some clinical science. There's a handful of Tumblr kids and Reddit kids I don't know why people give so much attention to using dysphoria as a substitute for a groan-worthy "soul of a [blank]." But neither they nor the edgelords intent on being the anti-snowflakes (and man they all act the same) bother to do the actual research into clinical dysphoria and why it exists and how it applies to real psychology.
Why are you so intent on shaming me and my ability to be a helicopter?!
 
Top