I think this is because they imagine good and evil from an atheistic perspective ignoring the nature of it from Islamic perspective and don't understand how it has explained this in terms of belief and disbelief.
If you watch Starwars, you have to pretend to believe in the force, right?
BTW: I forgot to add the link in my last post. I added it after you quoted it.
It sounds like you're acknowledging that the Islamic God can't be considered moral without accepting a bunch of tenets of Islam.
From the viewpoint of how Islamic God and faith and disbelief relates to him in terms of good and evil, why is it wrong per your view to be intolerant towards evil and disbelief?
You have to understand the metaphysics of Quran and suspend disbelief for a bit. Play the scenario like a fiction book and tell me why is it wrong if the cursed tree and blessed tree are what they are, to punish the dirty tree and it's people?
For one thing, if God is the ultimate designer and creator of everything, then any fault in the universe ultimately reflects on God. Our shortcomings as "creation" are God's shortcomings as "creator." Ultimately, God punishing his "creations" for not living up to his standards is punishing others for
his own mistakes.
Apart from that, there are all the "Problem of Evil"-type implications of omnipotence and omniscience. For instance:
When I was 5, one of my teammates on my baseball team was killed. We heard later that he ran out into the street and was hit by a garbage truck.
I don't fault my friend - he was 5. I also don't necessarily fault the driver - he may not have been able to stop in time.
... but if God were real, then he recognized what was about to happen and could have warned the driver or stopped the kid, but chose not to. If your God is real, he
chose a violent, painful death for that child... as well as for countless children through history. That's pretty monstrous.