• Welcome to Religious Forums, a friendly forum to discuss all religions in a friendly surrounding.

    Your voice is missing! You will need to register to get access to the following site features:
    • Reply to discussions and create your own threads.
    • Our modern chat room. No add-ons or extensions required, just login and start chatting!
    • Access to private conversations with other members.

    We hope to see you as a part of our community soon!

Why religion?

ChristineM

"Be strong", I whispered to my coffee.
Premium Member
You know you really should consider being pagan. We love music, dancing, sex, alcohol and have really fun rituals. There are more than enough gods and goddesses to identify with and you can absolutely accept science.

No pressure just and idea.


I cannot dance and don't do alcohol, and most definitely don't do gods.

Other than that... i just don't see me doing any kind of religious ritual.
 

Bear Wild

Well-Known Member
I cannot dance and don't do alcohol, and most definitely don't do gods.

Other than that... i just don't see me doing any kind of religious ritual.

We treat women and men as equals. Maybe a goddess or two? Think about it. They do not even have to look like humans. My cat even thinks he is a god.
 

Vinayaka

devotee
Premium Member
Is religion important? Why do people follow it?
Generally, unless people are indoctrinated by family, or because of a psychological need for friends, world views come about because of experiences. Since all people on this planet have individual sets of experiences, we all have different world views. To think otherwise, or hold the idea that we should all think the same way, is folly.
 

ChristineM

"Be strong", I whispered to my coffee.
Premium Member
I don't do alcohol either. Alcohol does me.

age 18 i had my first and last drunk, home brewed poiten at a Hogmanay party in Glasgow. I woke up 80 miles away without my car and no way to get back to it, without my virginity and no way to get it back. Every drink of water i had hit me like a sledgehammer leaving me drunk and serious hung over at the same time for 3 days.

I promised then, never again, to a pretty large extent ive kept that promise. I will join in a toast and have a glass at celebration's but that's it, never been drunk since.

But i use a hell of a lot of loopy juice in cooking.
 

Vinayaka

devotee
Premium Member
age 18 i had my first and last drunk, home brewed poiten at a Hogmanay party in Glasgow. I woke up 80 miles away without my car and no way to get back to it, without my virginity and no way to get it back. Every drink of water i had hit me like a sledgehammer leaving me drunk and serious hung over at the same time for 3 days.

I promised then, never again, to a pretty large extent ive kept that promise. I will join in a toast and have a glass at celebration's but that's it, never been drunk since.

But i use a hell of a lot of loopy juice in cooking.

Sounds like we have similar constitutions. I can have half a light beer ... maybe. Last time I got hammered was about 40 years ago ... wine and cheese on a Friday after work. I was still puking Sunday afternoon, but did manage to get back to work Monday. So yeah, same here.

My teenage oft repeated parenting advice that they got sick of ... "Bad things happen when you drink."
Sorry that happened to you. But hey you learned.
 

ChristineM

"Be strong", I whispered to my coffee.
Premium Member
Sounds like we have similar constitutions. I can have half a light beer ... maybe. Last time I got hammered was about 40 years ago ... wine and cheese on a Friday after work. I was still puking Sunday afternoon, but did manage to get back to work Monday. So yeah, same here.

My teenage oft repeated parenting advice that they got sick of ... "Bad things happen when you drink."
Sorry that happened to you. But hey you learned.


Its what life is all about.
 

Unveiled Artist

Veteran Member
Thank You. :). Question, how do i 'mention' a particular user?

You use @ and the person's name like this: @TSTS

Do you think religion can do that? Is understanding of one’s nature of their being and the purpose of their existence dependent on following a religion?

It's not. When I was a short term catholic, I felt it helped to an extent. I had a community of followers. So, ideally, we'd all be on similar lines of thinking with the basics. It gives people a sense of continuity-as they are the ones carrying on the tradition so others may benefit. In Catholicism, what I do like, is emphasis on individual prayers and time with god. So, people aren't just being "religious" but taking the time to connect with the group or alone with god.

Outside things are compilations to worship just as a chair helps one sit and the bible helps one know christ and other comparisons. Its not meant to replace one's spirituality but to enhance it.

I didn't say it's wasteful. But the question to ponder is, can the unknown/unknowable be structured? If it can then does it still remain the unknowbale?

Its the practice that's structured not the relationship with the unknown. Many religions outside abrahamic as well have traditions and things they do that help enhance their belief, practice, and/or relationship. I think it's very common in most religions.

For example, if you don't know about, say, driving a car you may read the manual to find the rules on what to do and not do. You may also find a teacher to help you with the driving test. Of course you need to watch for other drivers "and" they are driving with you just as you with them. So, it's one unit but each person has their own car.

Each person has their own personal experience in their cars and they have to follow the rules to drive. Some religions they find the instruction and teacher useful until they can drive on their own while others consult with the Manuel. But it doesn't devalue the experience, just ways to obtain it.

Just because your destination is unknown, for some people, that doesn't mean a manual is not needed to at least drive the car to get there.
 
Last edited:

TSTS

Member
LOL. Do you do stand up comedy by any chance. Your humor just blows the roof off the house. LOL
Humor is a great quality @SalixIncendium
[
Yes. Even for those who identify as agnostic or atheist because it is something that affects the world in which we live (in terms of laws, culture et al).
I would have thought who/what we are is what affects the world.

Other than that, I would say that it can provide a basis for developing our awareness of reality,
There is the belief of what reality is, and there is the actuality of what reality is. There is a difference between religiosity and a religious mind. In both cases the latter deals with actual reality, imho.
I will agree that there is a primal force behind reality. And also intellect is apart of nature. Intellect is eternal. I hold that as true.
Can you say more on this?

Religion offers a goal and a purpose greater than any one individual. Religion says I'm important to existence eternal. It infuses one with higher hopes and motivations. It changes one's attitude toward living.
Please see the distinction i have made above.
1. help us with dealing with death
2. help with social behavior
3. create a framework to see our connection with the rest of the world.
Seems to have failed in all three. Does my above distinction explain why?
 

TSTS

Member
Its the practice that's structured not the relationship with the unknown.
A practice is a mechanical action isn't it? Any enhancements is also mechanical isn't it?
So from the seeds of mechanistic activity we hope to capture the unnameable...hope sure is strange isn't it?
 

TSTS

Member
There's 3 pages, have a post/point in mind?

I merely wanted to answer your OP, and did.
By previous i meant the one immediately above which would have been #50. Thank you for your answer to op. No further contribution is necessary unless you feel like it.
 

Unveiled Artist

Veteran Member
A practice is a mechanical action isn't it? Any enhancements is also mechanical isn't it?
So from the seeds of mechanistic activity we hope to capture the unnameable...hope sure is strange isn't it?

I don't believe so. From someone looking outside it, it definitely does. However, I believe each person has their personal relationship or experience with or in the unknown and whether they chant, do the rosary, or dance, when you're fully involved its spirituality in itself. For example, if you have a passion-say painting-one doesn't ask why do you keep painting the same thing or paint every other hour of the day. We see it as that person's passion and he's improving and making things congruent with maybe his thoughts, creativity, and just like to paint. It's the same with religion. It's really an individual person's decision whether ritual works for them or not. Regardless, though, I don't see either as right or wrong.

I mean, take someone who reads the bible everyday, have conventions about the bible, spend two hours studying the bible, and quote nothing but the bible. It's ritualistic and does have spiritual value to the people involved just as much so as someone without those means and show spirituality by their actions without needing to speak a word of scripture.

I think they each have their place.
 

osgart

Nothing my eye, Something for sure
Humor is a great quality @SalixIncendium
[

I would have thought who/what we are is what affects the world.


There is the belief of what reality is, and there is the actuality of what reality is. There is a difference between religiosity and a religious mind. In both cases the latter deals with actual reality, imho.

Can you say more on this?


Please see the distinction i have made above.

Seems to have failed in all three. Does my above distinction explain why?


Whatever and whomever made us is not something or someone with all the answers. They may have vast knowledge of existence. However we are in an early stage of development. Existence made us to learn and discover itself. I would say the force that created us struggles mightily. Nothing in existence is perfectly done.

I think there's enough in nature to know that we are not merely the product of brute physical forces. To me the world of meaning, values, and ideas has a very real dimension to it. If meaning were not important we wouldn't have the capacity for it. We are built to discover, and to learn, and to do things exquisitely well. Existence is more like a verb than a noun.
 

The Hammer

[REDACTED]
Premium Member
I was talking about observable reality of the human world in general. Wasn't talking about unverifiable personal claims.

If personal claims weren't a part of observable reality, psychology wouldn't be around as a science. :)
 

TSTS

Member
If personal claims weren't a part of observable reality, psychology wouldn't be around as a science. :)

Psychology is around to tell us that unverifiable personal claims are part of schizoid disorders, divorced from reality. But perhaps more so it exists as a cash cow.

But perhaps for the seekers of truth it is necessary to put aside all kinds of acquired authority, so an unbiased exploration into reality can take place.

I am glad you decided to continue with your 'contributions'. It's funny how these things work isn't it? :)
 
Top