Would you date an underweight woman or man?

[Me Myself]

According to a UK survey, size 12 is about the ideal size for women from the perspective of men. The least-liked size was the skinniest.

Source.

from 12 to 16 do it for me.

You see now this look way better and clearer than the ilustration graph

Then again, if any there is underweight I assume it would have fooled me. (except for size 6, up to size 8 looks reasonable/well for me)

 

[Penumbra]

Also, a woman who looks at herself in the mirror and thinks she is fat when she is underweight scares me. I admit this sound like extreme associations with the simple word "underweight", but what can I do? I do have em.

I would suspect in almost all circumstances being underweight whie having the money to feed oneself well would be mostly the cause of some form of anorexia nd that === just truly honestly scares me.

There's a misconception out there that skinny women are necessarily skinny on purpose, or have eating issues. That's why I specified about a BMI of 18 or 19, not like 16 or 17.

Just like some men are naturally very thin, there are women that are naturally very thin despite doing nothing to be that thin, and eating all that they want.

 

[Badran]

I think all six of them are very attractive women. The size 14 woman seems a bit cheated due to the bland pose compared to the others; I suspect that would have cost her some votes.

I agree. Though 16 is the least attractive for me, i agree that she was both still very attractive and cheated with the pose.

I'm kind of surprised at how wide of a margin the size 12 woman won by. There's barely any bell curve, just a huge spike in the middle for her.

Me too. Her body seems almost identical to 8, only with bigger breasts. I'd expect that to make a difference on the general scale for many people, but that is an astonishing difference.

 

[Draka]

The thing I notice about the women in that pic are that from size 12 and up the ladies seem to have larger breasts as well. I wonder if that played into the voting at all. If the smaller sized ladies had larger breasts or the larger sized ladies smaller ones, I wonder if the results would have differed at all. Just wondering.

 

[Me Myself]

The thing I notice about the women in that pic are that from size 12 and up the ladies seem to have larger breasts as well. I wonder if that played into the voting at all. If the smaller sized ladies had larger breasts or the larger sized ladies smaller ones, I wonder if the results would have differed at all. Just wondering.

2 considerations

1- while its true that you can have big breasts while not having that much fat, you know way better than I do than unless you have terrible fat istribution, the bigger your size the more chances the bigger your breasts

2-I personally was looking solely at the hips and waist . Mostly cause the angle was terrilble to properly adresses everyone's breasts . I was looking at hips and tighs and even some arms. All of them had decent sized breasts, and different sizes there work for me

 

[Me Myself]

There's a misconception out there that skinny women are necessarily skinny on purpose, or have eating issues. That's why I specified about a BMI of 18 or 19, not like 16 or 17.

Just like some men are naturally very thin, there are women that are naturally very thin despite doing nothing to be that thin, and eating all that they want.

BMI honestly confuses me and I dont trust it anyways. I totally get what you say about body types too. As I said, I am aware it is a silly bias, but emotional things are emotional things and sexual attraction has in itself emotional considerations. If she gives me an image of "not well fed" I am turned off. Similarly as how I am turned off by a woman with no butt or no breasts.

 

[Draka]

2 considerations

1- while its true that you can have big breasts while not having that much fat, you know way better than I do than unless you have terrible fat istribution, the bigger your size the more chances the bigger your breasts

2-I personally was looking solely at the hips and waist . Mostly cause the angle was terrilble to properly adresses everyone's breasts . I was looking at hips and tighs and even some arms. All of them had decent sized breasts, and different sizes there work for me

I guess I must have "terrible fat distribution" then, because I'm a size 10 and I'm a 36D I also have friends that are larger than me in body size but have smaller breasts. Bigger body does not always mean bigger breasts and smaller body does not always mean smaller breasts. Quite a bit of it is just genetics.

And it was just something I noticed is all. Some men are "breast men". I just wondered if it perchance was a factor in the voting is all.

 

[Me Myself]

I guess I must have "terrible fat distribution" then, because I'm a size 10 and I'm a 36D I also have friends that are larger than me in body size but have smaller breasts. Bigger body does not always mean bigger breasts and smaller body does not always mean smaller breasts. Quite a bit of it is just genetics.

And it was just something I noticed is all. Some men are "breast men". I just wondered if it perchance was a factor in the voting is all.

Yeah but I mean still even with small breasts they get bigger with more fat.

I mean Expecting to find 5 identical twins with different eating ranges was a bit of a stretch

beyond weight, their body forms were different too. All bodies are different. Numbers narrow down some barriers, but for the most "objetive" testing we would need 5 identical twins.

 

[DallasApple]

And it was just something I noticed is all. Some men are "breast men". I just wondered if it perchance was a factor in the voting is all.

right..you mean like if she was the "skinniest" one but with big fat DD breast they all wouldn't pick that one?Sorry the porn stars are not size 8 or 10.They are size 2 or 4 with breast implants and those are considered the fantasy girls.

 

[Badran]

The thing I notice about the women in that pic are that from size 12 and up the ladies seem to have larger breasts as well. I wonder if that played into the voting at all. If the smaller sized ladies had larger breasts or the larger sized ladies smaller ones, I wonder if the results would have differed at all. Just wondering.

I agree that breast size likely had a considerable effect on at least some votes.

It had an effect on me, but a bit differently than what would normally happen with most people. Sizes 8, 10 and 12 are generally very close to each other, with just a little bit of difference in regards to how much fat they had. The bigger difference is their breasts sizes.

In my case, i generally lean more to like a balanced body. Sizes 8 and 10 stroke me as having a perfect balance, while 12's breasts were kind of 'sticking out' to me. I know that sounds crazy.

But i actually prefer the way 8 and 10's breasts are, in respect to their bodies, in comparison to 12's in respect to hers. All three are generally extremely close though, but i almost immediately leaned towards 8 and 10. I suspect that a lot of people had the exact opposite reaction.

 

[DallasApple]

also the woman that is a size 6????Sorry she is a 4 .Or even a 2.

 

[Shadow Wolf]

Much like overweight, it depends. If someone is too thin because of an eating disorder, or more importantly drug abuse, then there is a reason to proceed with caution. Maybe this person is just made to be that way, maybe they are damaged goods, or maybe they will blow a fuse over something being out of place.

 

[Draka]

right..you mean like if she was the "skinniest" one but with big fat DD breast they all wouldn't pick that one?Sorry the porn stars are not size 8 or 10.They are size 2 or 4 with breast implants and those are considered the fantasy girls.

No, I mean if they were just more on even keel with each other is all. So there wouldn't be any mistaking why a certain general size was chosen. The same general build. Like all B or all C cups across the board. Trying to get as close as possible to same waist to hip ratio. That sort of thing.

Again, it may have been nothing, it was just an observation.

 

[Aquitaine]

For people that say they only care about the mind and not the body, are you entirely bisexual then? Or does the person's sex matter?

Because I'd personally never say that looks don't matter to me, since I prefer dudes, and tend to only date dudes, so already I'm judging half of the population based on appearance.

Ha! That's a really good point.

If one claims to place all the emphasis on personality, and not let weight or appearance get in the way, then why let genitals get in the way?

 

[DreadFish]

According to a UK survey, size 12 is about the ideal size for women from the perspective of men. The least-liked size was the skinniest.

Moderator cut: image removed​

Source.

I would go for a woman at any of those sizes, though the size 6 is a bit small, it just depends on the individual. I guess, for me, I go for a woman as a whole person. You've got a woman's body, her face, and her personality/mind. If they all sort of synergize with each other, then I find her attractive. I wouldn't really go for a woman with a hot body but a face that im not attracted to, and never mind the hot mean *****, I dont care what she looks like, she's an ugly person. The face is what I would be looking at the most anyway, so that's the most important part of appearance to me. That doesn't discount the importance placed on the attractiveness of her body, but it holds more weight (no pun intended ). Anyway, personality literally makes a woman more or less physically attractive to me. If I like her mind, I will like her body more.

As far as their breasts go, im more of a hips and a** guy, so I didnt really pay as much attention to them but, from personal experience, I have been attracted to girls with small breasts and large ones.

 

[crossfire]

also the woman that is a size 6????Sorry she is a 4 .Or even a 2.

UK sizes are different from US sizes. The US sizes have also been changing. Back when I was a 19 BMI I wore a size 4 Levi jean (like 20+ years ago.) I'm now about 25 BMI and these new size 4 Levi jeans I'm wearing are way too big from the waist to the hip. There is no way I could squeeze into the old size 4 Levi jeans now.

 

[Alceste]

According to a UK survey, size 12 is about the ideal size for women from the perspective of men. The least-liked size was the skinniest.

Moderator cut: image removed​

Source.

I can't help but notice the size 12 example has the biggest boobs. Are you sure it was just the dress size they were voting on?

 

[Alceste]

For people that say they only care about the mind and not the body, are you entirely bisexual then? Or does the person's sex matter?

Because I'd personally never say that looks don't matter to me, since I prefer dudes, and tend to only date dudes, so already I'm judging half of the population based on appearance.

I'm somewhat bisexual. I've had crushes on a few women before and fooled around with them, but I've never been in a relationship with a woman. It's not rational at all, something about certain people just "gets" me.

Probably the main reason I tend to go for men despite my attraction to certain women is social conditioning. I also find men a less intimidating and complicated than women.

I guess I must have "terrible fat distribution" then, because I'm a size 10 and I'm a 36D I also have friends that are larger than me in body size but have smaller breasts. Bigger body does not always mean bigger breasts and smaller body does not always mean smaller breasts. Quite a bit of it is just genetics.

And it was just something I noticed is all. Some men are "breast men". I just wondered if it perchance was a factor in the voting is all.

Yeah, that's what I thought. The woman in the size 12 photo has the most prominent breasts in that particular photo. Badran noticed it too!

 

[Horrorble]

I don't see much difference between the size 8 and 12, to be honest, are these women a bit photoshopped?

 

[Reverend Rick]

They all look good to me. One looks a little too skinny but she could be fattened up.