Would you date an underweight woman or man?

[Alceste]

I don't see much difference between the size 8 and 12, to be honest, are these women a bit photoshopped?

Yeah they all look unusually curvy to me, maybe tucked in a bit at the waist? I live by a beach and none of the bodies I see look like those bodies.

 

[Horrorble]

Yeah they all look unusually curvy to me, maybe tucked in a bit at the waist? I live by a beach and none of the bodies I see look like those bodies.

Yeah, it also depends how tall you are as well, some tall people have to wear bigger sizes just so it fits their length. The size 14 looks more like a 10 or 12 to me.

 

[Kilgore Trout]

I can't help but notice the size 12 example has the biggest boobs. Are you sure it was just the dress size they were voting on?

Also, a size 8 in one store or by one manufacturer may be equal to a size 12 in another store or by another manufacturer. Women's clothing sizes are hardly standardized or universal, and when you take into account the widely varying shapes of women, categorizing women by their "size" seems rather arbitrary and meaningless. I'm pretty sure that, just on appearance, one's particular body shape and composition is far more important than a size or even a weight. Multiple studies have shown that men prefer a particular waist to hip ratio over a particular size or weight.

 

[Draka]

Also, a size 8 in one store or by one manufacturer may be equal to a size 12 in another store or by another manufacturer. Women's clothing sizes are hardly standardized or universal, and when you take into account the widely varying shapes of women, categorizing women by their "size" seems rather arbitrary and meaningless. I'm pretty sure that, just on appearance, one's particular body shape and composition is far more important than a size or even a weight. Multiple studies have shown that men prefer a particular waist to hip ratio over a particular size or weight.

The difference in brands and cuts making a difference in size is quite true when it comes to women's clothing. It sucks and makes trying on stuff practically a requirement. I have 3 pairs of size 10 jeans that all fit differently, 2 quite baggier than one. And a size 8 pair that fits like my one size 10. There is no real uniformity. How is anyone really to know what size they really are for sure when the clothing companies cant figure out what those sizes supposedly even are?

 

[Me Myself]

Also, a size 8 in one store or by one manufacturer may be equal to a size 12 in another store or by another manufacturer. Women's clothing sizes are hardly standardized or universal, and when you take into account the widely varying shapes of women, categorizing women by their "size" seems rather arbitrary and meaningless. I'm pretty sure that, just on appearance, one's particular body shape and composition is far more important than a size or even a weight. Multiple studies have shown that men prefer a particular waist to hip ratio over a particular size or weight.

absolutely.

waist to hip ratio is what makes sense to me.

 

[DallasApple]

No, I mean if they were just more on even keel with each other is all. So there wouldn't be any mistaking why a certain general size was chosen. The same general build. Like all B or all C cups across the board. Trying to get as close as possible to same waist to hip ratio. That sort of thing.

Again, it may have been nothing, it was just an observation.

Yes I agree..One of the women is obviously more of a "pear" shape than any of the rest.(the size 14)And then of course the different boob sizes.

 

[Me Myself]

Yes I agree..One of the women is obviously more of a "pear" shape than any of the rest.(the size 14)And then of course the different boob sizes.

I must say, I totally like a lot of pear shape bodies

 

[DallasApple]

I must say, I totally like a lot of pear shape bodies

Well there are pears and apples.Pears have wider thighs and will tend to collect more fat in that area.Apples have more in the belly.

 

[Penumbra]

I don't see much difference between the size 8 and 12, to be honest, are these women a bit photoshopped?

Looking at the women who are size 8 and size 12, I can see a difference in the thighs and the collar-bone area, plus the breasts.

I don't know if they're Photoshopped or not. I put that picture up there to show what a survey result was, but people used it as the reference guide to answering the poll question. The reference guide I had in the OP was for both sexes and didn't show actual people.

 

[ignition]

If you don't mind me asking, I know this is completely off-topic but you spent quite a lot of time arguing one time that breasts aren't anything sexual and don't need to be covered. Yet you put up this picture with the guy bare-chested but the girl wearing a bra. Are you reinforcing this double standard by any chance? Heehee

For the record, please don't put up an actual picture of a woman with open breasts, we view that as flat out porn here. That's for the chavs on page 3.

Aaaanyway. Size don't really matter, unless it's excessively skinny or gross overweight. A bit of maccy or running couldn't do any harm really for these extremes.

 

[Me Myself]

Well there are pears and apples.Pears have wider thighs and will tend to collect more fat in that area.Apples have more in the belly.

apples are the ones I am personally not attracted to sexually.

 

[Me Myself]

For the record, please don't put up an actual picture of a woman with open breasts, we view that as flat out porn here.

I wonder... if we put an aborigin women with boobs out I think it has ben done and also n problem utside of eros room, but if we put a conventionally sexy woman in the beach with boobs out, I wonder if it would be considered porn by the site.

I would also wonder if the commercial sexynnes of the woman's breasts would be part of what would bejudged to say if the picture is porn and not just the pose of the woman.

 

[DallasApple]

Yet you put up this picture with the guy bare-chested but the girl wearing a bra. Are you reinforcing this double standard by any chance? Heehee

Because its probably illegal even if its a cartoon because MORONS "cant control themselves" because they think its "stupid" .

 

[Draka]

Actually, I don't think there's anything that specifically says that topless women are really considered "porn" on this site. Upon looking at the rules it really doesn't specifically seem so. The rules say "sexually extreme, vulgar, pornographic or illegal items, as well as profane language and images are all prohibited everywhere on RF". As breasts are not sexually extreme, vulgar, pornographic, nor illegal, then the images of such, technically, shouldn't be disallowed. At least, going strictly by the wording of the rule there.

 

[Titanic]

Actually, I don't think there's anything that specifically says that topless women are really considered "porn" on this site. Upon looking at the rules it really doesn't specifically seem so. The rules say "sexually extreme, vulgar, pornographic or illegal items, as well as profane language and images are all prohibited everywhere on RF". As breasts are not sexually extreme, vulgar, pornographic, nor illegal, then the images of such, technically, shouldn't be disallowed. At least, going strictly by the wording of the rule there.

Well why are they not more breasts pics on here?

 

[Draka]

Well why are they not more breasts pics on here?

It's a religious forum. Do there need to be lots of pics of breasts for some reason? Must we demand pics of elbows and ankles as well?

 

[Titanic]

It's a religious forum. Do there need to be lots of pics of breasts for some reason?

There is a eros room, why not?

 

[DallasApple]

There is a eros room, why not?

Then start asking people to post pictures of boobs.Or you do.See how far you get.

 

[Draka]

There is a eros room, why not?

What does one have to do with the other?

My point was just that I didn't think it was technically truly all that against the rules, nor is it viewed truly as "porn". Though the staff is free to disagree with me as it is their final say.

 

[Titanic]

Then start asking people to post pictures of boobs.Or you do.See how far you get.

I guess I would be banned.