Not being able to wear red, or hear sound, or to fly does not take away your free will. So to your question: No, as long as you can transgress moral laws, you have free will.
As I suspected. You define 'free will' as 'can sin' and nothing else. No other choices have any bearing on 'free will'.
So, if I intend to steal a loaf of bread, I am intending to sin and this is an exercise of free will. But during the actual theft, if I stop to consider whether I should steal rye bread or white bread this has nothing at all to do with free will? Or does it speak to free will because it relates to the sin I'm committing?
It's futile as heaven will be populated with either robots ( if sin is not allowed) or will be empty ( if sin is allowed and then everyone banned). Now assuming that God knows it all, then why create the universe? He might as well create those robots in the first and skip altogether the creation of this universe.
Ummm, what? First of all, you didn't answer my questions. Secondly, why do you think 'fast-tracking' robot creation is non-futile and doing it 'the slow way' is futile?
We can put all deeds into two distinct categories: sins and non-sins. Therefore, every moment you exist in heaven, you are then confront with those two choices.
Wow, really? So, when I look at my drawer full of shirts I am really choosing whether or not to murder my family. Never quite saw it that way, myself. I think I'll call my mother and tell her the good news. She isn't going to be murdered. I've selected the black shirt instead. Whew!
Yes, that's exactly the story of Adam and Eve. Given they had a choice to sin or not to sin, it was just a question of time before they would sin.
M'kay, I can see that clever phrasing is lost on you so I'll go ahead and spell it out for you:
You are on one hand saying that free will itself is DEFINED by the ability to CHOOSE to sin and then you are saying that sinning is inevitable. That means you DON'T HAVE A CHOICE ABOUT IT. That is a blatant contradiction.
Irrelevant, it does not invalid my calculation.
Actually it does completely shred your calculation to bits, but that isn't really important since the flipping of a coin is in no way, shape, or form a suitable parallel to sin/not-sin since it is not a free-will-determining choice as you've arbitrarily decided. In other words, if you wish to maintain that sin is the only measure of free will, then you CANNOT then compare it to something that has no bearing on free will and insist that it works the same way.
In that particular scenario, provision would have to exist for one to make that choice, that is, there are hospitals and plastic surgeons. Suppose that heaven is a magical place, and anything can happen, then yes, given an infinite amount of times, then everything will happen, including your scenario.
So they would also eventually get plastic surgery to look like everyone else as well. And then they'd all get tattoos of each other. And then they'd all paint watercolors of each other. And then they'd all make pop-sickle-stick murals of the South China Sea. And then they'd all make the largest ball of rubber bands in existence... oh wait they can't ALL do that... it would just keep... getting... infinitely... bigger.... OH NO THEY HAVE NO TIME FOR SIN LEFT THEY ARE TOO BUSY 1-UPPING EACH OTHER'S RUBBER BAND BALLS FOR ETERNITY!!!!!
:dust hands:
[youtube]X8PyTo6NyXA[/youtube]
All Too Easy - YouTube