I wouldn't rule that out though.
actually, I have no timeline. But I don't need to, I think. May I remind you, you were the one making a positive claim that there was a contradiction, so the onus is not on me to provide timelines and stuff...
Hello again....
Thanks for your post and interest.
But I have provided evidence in the form of Gospel verses, right after each description of a contradiction. I've done that.
Apostle John's timeline is totally different from Apostle Mark's and attempts to give a (nearly) three year calendar of events, compared to Mark's 11-12 month calendar.
Let me show it to you........ very odd, with lots of sudden forays up and down Palestine, and the scheming Priesthood becomes the scheming Jews. Quite wicked, imo.
JOHN
1 Bethabara
3 Cana..... a wedding
4/5 A stay at Capernaum with family (not many days)
8/9 Passover.... Jerusalem. Criminal damage, ABH...
--------------------------------------------------------
11/12 Judea ( Aenon near to Salim) with discilpes and John B
-- Samaria via Sychar (a 2 day stay)
-- Galilee and >>>>> to
-- Cana
-- To the Temple, Jerusalem. A Feast.
-- Up to Galilee and over the Lake.
----------------------------------------------------------
-- Year 2. Passover, but Jesus stayed on the Lake.
-- Jesus feeds a multitude
-- The mountain trip, alone
-- Walks to the disciple's ship, and thence to Capernaum.
-- Jesus stays in Galilee, because its unsafe in Judea.
-- Feast of Tebernacles (Booths?) Goes in disguise.
-- Stays on Mount of Olives
-- Back to Temple (Treasury)
<<<<<<<<<<<<>>>>>>>
-- Feast of Dedication (Winter)
-- Escaped to Bethabara
-- Bethany (Lazarus)
-- Ephraim.... safety
-- 6 days to Passover.... Bethany.
-----------------------------------------------------
year 3-- Passover week
-- Jerusalem. Last supper
-- Over Cedron Brook to the garden.
--Arrest.
-- Execution.
-- Meeting place near or in Jerusalem.
-- The Lake, Galilee