Yes, indeed.
But, wait, I said the same thing and you disagreed with me. I thought you said Israel (northern kingdom of 10 tribes) would not rise as a distinct people in their tribes again?
No, I meant Israel when it rose from the stem of Abraham, Isaac and Jacob. Therefore, many years before the time when Jacob expressed his prophesy of Shiloh. That is, before the split of the Tribes.
The only way they can stand up as a light to the world on Day 1 of a creation is to do so on Day 1 of the new Creation that is imminently pending. The reasoning here is that we are in the "latter days" of the current creation which means by implication we are on the cusp of a new beginning. Thus, the timing for Israel to rise is now.
Wake up jbug, we have risen as a nation, one People since the return from exile in Babylon.
Day 4 is when Israel initially was brought to be which is indeed when the "greater light to (who should in the future) rule the day" was created, but it wouldn't actually do its job until Day 1 of the new Creation to follow. Thus, by implication, the blueprint says a greater light to do something wouldn't do so until later. Thus, you are confronted with the challenge of explaining how this all links together and how it plays out.
There is no play out. You are trying to be literal, while I am interpreting Creation in a metaphorical manner.
It plays out on an individual level as a Messiah figure as well as the societal bodies they are the head of.
There is no such a thing as an individual Messiah. The Messiah is collective in Israel, the Jewish People. According to the consensus that the Suffering Servant is the Messiah, Isaah identifies him with Israel by name. (Isa. 41:8,9; 44:1,2,21)
Thus, Messiah the individual has an initial advent as the Son of God on Day 4 and then Messiah the individual has a subsequent advent as the Father on Day 1 of the new Creation that follows to do what He was born to do, which is to rule.
If you are referring to Jesus, I have told you already that the dead do not return to life again. It is against the Scriptures. (Eccl. 9:5,6; 12:7)
Surely you will agree the source of that light on Day 1 comes from that which was created for that purpose on Day 4 of the previous creation. Yes? No? Why?
Definitely NOT! The light on the first day was only a prophesy for the rise of Israel. The light on day 4 was metaphorically the one from the sun on the sky. And all metaphorically, since the whole Genesis account of creation is an allegory.