• Welcome to Religious Forums, a friendly forum to discuss all religions in a friendly surrounding.

    Your voice is missing! You will need to register to get access to the following site features:
    • Reply to discussions and create your own threads.
    • Our modern chat room. No add-ons or extensions required, just login and start chatting!
    • Access to private conversations with other members.

    We hope to see you as a part of our community soon!

Is It Sin?

Gargovic Malkav

Well-Known Member
Another thread with the same title asks if watching pornography is a sin. This isn't really about that.

What I found curious was the author did not type out the word (allowing for some fun interpretation on my part), and instead typed p-graphy.

The word "pornography" isn't a profanity, and certainly isn't in our language filter. It's just a word to describe a thing.

Which leads my to my question. Is typing out a word that suggests something you consider morally or ethically questionable a sin?

When one believes something to be morally bad, I think one makes things unnecessarily complicated when using all kinds of censorship or roundabout ways of saying something in an attempt to sound... morally righteous?
But maybe it's just me.
Yet, I try to keep cultural standards into account when I speak. Especially when dealing with people I don't know well and people who don't know me well.

I wonder if you asked the guy who gave you the idea of posting this thread.
 

Nimos

Well-Known Member
Another thread with the same title asks if watching pornography is a sin. This isn't really about that.

What I found curious was the author did not type out the word (allowing for some fun interpretation on my part), and instead typed p-graphy.

The word "pornography" isn't a profanity, and certainly isn't in our language filter. It's just a word to describe a thing.

Which leads my to my question. Is typing out a word that suggests something you consider morally or ethically questionable a sin?
Given that I don't believe in sin, I can't answer that question.

But personally I don't care about it all or what words I or others use. To me, they are used to make a more precise description of what is meant. I try to avoid using words that offend others within limits, but at this time and age almost all words seems to offend someone so its not always easy to figure out, especially when you yourself don't care to much about it :)
 

anna.

but mostly it's the same
What I found curious was the author did not type out the word (allowing for some fun interpretation on my part), and instead typed p-graphy.

Perhaps it was a subconscious marker of the author's discomfort with the idea of pornography itself?
 

Fallen Prophet

Well-Known Member
Another thread with the same title asks if watching pornography is a sin. This isn't really about that.

What I found curious was the author did not type out the word (allowing for some fun interpretation on my part), and instead typed p-graphy.

The word "pornography" isn't a profanity, and certainly isn't in our language filter. It's just a word to describe a thing.

Which leads my to my question. Is typing out a word that suggests something you consider morally or ethically questionable a sin?
It's possible that they believed it would flag moderators.

I've been flagged on this site for words that I have never considered profanity.
 

Clara Tea

Well-Known Member
Given that I don't believe in sin, I can't answer that question.

But personally I don't care about it all or what words I or others use. To me, they are used to make a more precise description of what is meant. I try to avoid using words that offend others within limits, but at this time and age almost all words seems to offend someone so its not always easy to figure out, especially when you yourself don't care to much about it :)

Thank goodness doctors use 18 syllable words for exactly the same body parts. To them, these parts are like biological machines that have to be tested and fixed...and are not porn at all.
 

Clara Tea

Well-Known Member
You mean when I type T'ump or the Rep'party because they are ev'l tr'tors and crim'nals?

It is my sin when I focus on the negative rather than the positive.

To many artists, the human form is art. It has beautiful curves and texture. Isn't it odd that something so beautiful can be thought of in such unflattering terms. Perhaps art is in the eye of the beholder?
 

anna.

but mostly it's the same
Since they didn't spell out the word, maybe they are complaining about photography? Proton-tomography?

The possibilities are endless. I vote for Pluto-graphy, because size matters for poor Pluto.

The debate came to a head in August 2006, with an IAU resolution that created an official definition for the term "planet". According to this resolution, there are three conditions for an object in the Solar System to be considered a planet:​

  1. The object must be in orbit around the Sun.
  2. The object must be massive enough to be rounded by its own gravity. More specifically, its own gravity should pull it into a shape defined by hydrostatic equilibrium.
  3. It must have cleared the neighborhood around its orbit.[53][54]
Pluto fails to meet the third condition.[55] Its mass is substantially less than the combined mass of the other objects in its orbit: 0.07 times, in contrast to Earth, which is 1.7 million times the remaining mass in its orbit (excluding the moon).[56][54] The IAU further decided that bodies that, like Pluto, meet criteria 1 and 2, but do not meet criterion 3 would be called dwarf planets.​
 

DNB

Christian
Another thread with the same title asks if watching pornography is a sin. This isn't really about that.

What I found curious was the author did not type out the word (allowing for some fun interpretation on my part), and instead typed p-graphy.

The word "pornography" isn't a profanity, and certainly isn't in our language filter. It's just a word to describe a thing.

Which leads my to my question. Is typing out a word that suggests something you consider morally or ethically questionable a sin?
It's clearly not a sin if it's merely used in either a descriptive or referential manner. But, if it's meant to incite or arouse, or stimulate thoughts, then a euphemism is more appropriate. And, thus, euphemisms have their place, which is entirely why such a grammatical device came into existence.
If there are vulnerable or impressionable people around, then it's wiser to censor one's vocabulary as to not offend or compromise one's innocence. In the presence of a rape victim, the best policy would be to avoid any allusions to the word, but rather to find an expression that humiliates the culprit and not the victim. As in, referring to it as an act of frustration, desperation or depravity, as opposed to violate, control, abuse or overwhelm.

As much as reverence is perceived when one capitalizes the word God, or other sacred entities, it's as purposeful to debase things of a nefarious nature by not dignifying the spelling of the practice.
 

firedragon

Veteran Member
Another thread with the same title asks if watching pornography is a sin. This isn't really about that.

What I found curious was the author did not type out the word (allowing for some fun interpretation on my part), and instead typed p-graphy.

The word "pornography" isn't a profanity, and certainly isn't in our language filter. It's just a word to describe a thing.

Which leads my to my question. Is typing out a word that suggests something you consider morally or ethically questionable a sin?

Well. The word Kaafir was a filtered word in the forum. Is mentioning that a sin?

I dont know if that is allowed now though. ;)
 

SalixIncendium

अग्निविलोवनन्दः
Staff member
Premium Member
Such as "murder"? Or are you referring to things of a sexual nature?

I'm referring to anything anyone chooses not to spell out because they find the action the word represents to be offensive in nature.
 

SalixIncendium

अग्निविलोवनन्दः
Staff member
Premium Member
It's possible that they believed it would flag moderators.

I've been flagged on this site for words that I have never considered profanity.

The filter catches just about everything unless one is trying to circumvent the filter intentionally. If "pornography" was a flagged word, it would appear as "***********" when typed.
 

SalixIncendium

अग्निविलोवनन्दः
Staff member
Premium Member
If there are vulnerable or impressionable people around, then it's wiser to censor one's vocabulary as to not offend or compromise one's innocence. In the presence of a rape victim, the best policy would be to avoid any allusions to the word, but rather to find an expression that humiliates the culprit and not the victim. As in, referring to it as an act of frustration, desperation or depravity, as opposed to violate, control, abuse or overwhelm.

Sorry, but I'm not buying that "r-pe" would somehow be less offensive or humiliating to a rape victim than "rape."

Regarding euphemisms, I share George's sentiments:

 

Kenny

Face to face with my Father
Premium Member
Another thread with the same title asks if watching pornography is a sin. This isn't really about that.

What I found curious was the author did not type out the word (allowing for some fun interpretation on my part), and instead typed p-graphy.

The word "pornography" isn't a profanity, and certainly isn't in our language filter. It's just a word to describe a thing.

Which leads my to my question. Is typing out a word that suggests something you consider morally or ethically questionable a sin?
I think that there are cases where, for one person, it would be a sin but for another it may not be. If a person laces his communication with profound profanity, I would call it a sin whereas the other person, because of his a lack of communication skills and has to lace it with profanity, thinks it is quite normal and acceptable.

That being said, I have no problem with saying and writing out p30f@n!ty. :D
 

Brian2

Veteran Member
I'm referring to anything anyone chooses not to spell out because they find the action the word represents to be offensive in nature.

It is good to consider the feeling of others when speaking/ typing words. It is hard to know at times which actions and their related descriptive words are going to offend. No doubt the RF filter and moderators try to do that for us.
How a word is used is also important. A descriptive word can be used as a profanity at times or as just a descriptive word.
This morality stuff is so complicated but boils down to love for our neighbour.
For me there is no word that typing per se would be sinful. The intent would determine whether it was sinful imo.
Things are get blurry when others are offended as something we see as not offensive.
Political Correctness is a contentious issue.
 
  • Like
Reactions: DNB

lewisnotmiller

Grand Hat
Staff member
Premium Member
Bingo!

I have to say, I do not use "naughty" words very often -- when you have a decent vocabulary, you really don't need to. But there are times when one of those words that are routinely bleeped out are, in fact, exactly the right word to use. And at such times (rare though they are) I really hate having them bleeped out.

Hmm...funny.
I use naughty words somewhat regularly, and I don't think many people would describe me as having a poor vocabulary. It's more a shift in language mode for me, based on audience.

None of this is important, just sprang to mind when I read your post.
 

Evangelicalhumanist

"Truth" isn't a thing...
Premium Member
Hmm...funny.
I use naughty words somewhat regularly, and I don't think many people would describe me as having a poor vocabulary. It's more a shift in language mode for me, based on audience.

None of this is important, just sprang to mind when I read your post.
I don't know why it is, but I just don't tend to swear very much. If I do, every friend I have reacts with huge shock, because coming from me, it's just completely surprising.

And maybe, I haven't really thought about it, that might be one of the reasons I actually don't swear -- so that if I do, you know without further clues that I'm really angry.
 
Top