"I liked the reasoning, in its context, up until this part. If randomization (which I assume you meant for "chaos") creates homogenization of heterogeneous bits, surely there's a 'law' about that? Doesn't that describe, oh say, entropy?"
Sure, why not? Chaos is definitely a law in itself. Which is also fascinating, but I wont get into that.
I'm not sure what you don't like about it, I can think of a couple of things.
I did contradict myself, though. If all the laws existed and the universe always existed and always will then it's possible, though unlikely, that there is no conscious force underlying the basic functions of the universe. It's possible that the universe expands, creating new things, and then contracts, destroying everything, and then repeats this process over and over again. *always has and always will* perpetually.
The largest flaw, and the reason I avoid this theory, is that the universe would have to be perfect, as in completely stable and, since nothing inside the universe is completely stable I find it unlikely that the universe itself is completely stable.
Again, it *is* possible, as far as I know, just unlikely.
In response to Papersock
1. Yes I have, yet it doesn't explain many, many things about the universe. And I understand that it's not suppose to.
2. Agreed
3. Perhaps, but unlikely.
4. No, actually, I find it's still very open to debate on both sides.
"Evolution, no matter how you see it should do more to prove God than not."
Generally speaking, yes. Though only at the absolute basis of Evolution. If you say what I think your going to say then not really.
"To evolve and not just exist shows we had a beginning. To have a beginning means we were created."
You said it... The second part is true, as far as I know, but just because you have a beginning just means you were created by your parents, and so on and so forth. However, it doesn't necessarily mean a "god" started it. Like I stated before, there's only two theories that seem to work. One, that the universe was created by some sort of sentience or, two, the universe always existed.
The question that would almost definitely prove the existence or non-existence of "god" would be if the universe is mortal or immortal. However, it seems impossible to truly know the answer.
Jeremiah has a good point.
It is possible, but it seems unlikely.