gnostic
The Lost One
There was an interesting reply (post 244) from Dirty Penguin to MarkyMark, in another thread Muslims: The testimony of a man who said he heard an angel while alone in a cave, which I would like to address and ask some questions.
Do prophet require to perform miracle in order for be a "prophet"?
And there are some prophets mentioned in the Tanakh or the (OT) Bible, who seemingly have performed no miracle. One that come to mind, was Nathan, who advised David, and was involved in coronation of Solomon.
So if prophet don't need to perform miracle, then what make a prophet "prophet"?
markymark said:personally i believe Mohammed was a false prophet as he did not preform one recorded miracle
dirty penguin said:Performing "miracles" is not a prerequisite for being a prophet/prophetess.
Do prophet require to perform miracle in order for be a "prophet"?
- But in order to ask or answer such question, I'd suppose that we need TO DEFINE what is a "miracle"?
- As well as which miracle do we accept and which we wouldn't accept?
And there are some prophets mentioned in the Tanakh or the (OT) Bible, who seemingly have performed no miracle. One that come to mind, was Nathan, who advised David, and was involved in coronation of Solomon.
So if prophet don't need to perform miracle, then what make a prophet "prophet"?