Are you saying that God is indistinguishable from a god that doesn't exist?
-
Welcome to Religious Forums, a friendly forum to discuss all religions in a friendly surrounding.
Your voice is missing! You will need to register to get access to the following site features:- Reply to discussions and create your own threads.
- Our modern chat room. No add-ons or extensions required, just login and start chatting!
- Access to private conversations with other members.
We hope to see you as a part of our community soon!
What do you think God's reasons are for hiding himself?
- Thread starter Spiderman
- Start date
Evidence is that which helps one qualified to interpret it decide between competing hypotheses. The world around us has competing explanatory hypotheses, both naturalistic and supernaturalistic. There is nothing about the oceans and sunsets or the human capacity for love that allows us to distinguish between them.
A test of what, and how do we benefit from such a test?
Life is an opportunity, not a test.
And that would be worse how?
Faith causes you to believe that you need salvation. Like cigarettes, religions often create needs that only they can fulfill.
Not all intoxicants are harmful, and not all harmful agents (toxins) are intoxicating. Faith in ancient dietary proscriptions is a poor method for navigating that aspect of life. It doesn't mention heavy metal poisoning or radiation exposure, for example, but recommends avoiding shellfish and pork.
There is no reason to believe that fasting removes harmful toxins. What it does is to cause weight loss and induce a euphoric state via a starvation ketoacidosis: Feeling euphoric on a low-carb diet? The effect on your brain is similar to an illicit drug
There is no reason to believe that a god would communicate to us using writing and human languages. Evolution chose instincts, emotions, proclivities, and faculties such as reason and the conscience. That's a better method. Instructions should be nonverbal and endogenous in origin. Written language can't compete with that.
You can see the failure of that method in a site like RF, where believers in the same text come to wildly varying conclusions about what the words mean.
Spiderman
Veteran Member
For some people yes... in my personal experience that has not been the case. But I do understand where people are coming from when they say they don't believe because of lack of evidence
If he isn't, I will:
- "There's no reason, in theory, why god's presence couldn't be measured or detected in some way. The only reason that believers claim that god "can't" be detected in this way is because god *isn't* detected, and so a vast and intricate rationale has to be devised to explain this vast, loving, eternal, all-powerful "something" which is, in every external, objective respect, indistinguishable from nothing." - anon.
- "If there is a God, his plan is very similar to someone not having a plan." - Eddie Izzard"
- When inventing a god the most important thing is to claim it is invisible, inaudible and imperceptible in every way. Otherwise, people will become skeptical when it appears to no one, is silent and does nothing." – anon
Test of faith in the unseen, belief in the day we return to our Creator etc
You can have faith and still make the most out of opportunities this life affords you. Many religious people have thriving businesses and the means to enjoy life and what it has to offer.
Not worse, but would remove the test, a even Atheists as yourself on seeing the Hell Fire would want to obey God, even though it may fill your heart with loathing and resentment.
Not true as I already explained, the guidance is beneficial for my well being, so even if there was nothing after death, I'd have no regrets.
Why have the word 'toxic' to label such things if they're good for one's body? GOD says there is some benefit in alcohol, but the harm it can lead to is far greater, therefore stay away from it.
Here we are told small amounts is fine, but who knows when a small drink is enough? Most alcoholics for example never set out to become so.
Islam has no problem with shelfish, but yes pork is forbidden and various studies have shown it's not good for you:
"No matter how you think about it, pigs are rather dirty animals. They’re considered the garbage and waste eliminators of the farm, often eating literally anything they can find. This includes not only bugs, insects and whatever leftover scraps they find laying around, but also their own feces, as well as the dead carcasses of sick animals, including their own young. At least one farmer has gone out to feed his pigs and never returned. On that morning in 2012, he literally became the pig’s breakfast."
Tapeworms, Toxins and More: The Truth about Your Pork
There is no reason to believe that fasting removes harmful toxins. What it does is to cause weight loss and induce a euphoric state via a starvation ketoacidosis: Feeling euphoric on a low-carb diet? The effect on your brain is similar to an illicit drug[/QUOTE]
Can't say I've ever met a Muslim who felt euphoria from fasting. Yes we feel healthier and there is weight loss for some who don't stay up all night eating.
- A number of studies have suggested intermittent fasting has numerous health benefits, including weight loss, lower blood pressure and reduced cholesterol.
- When the body has used up glucose stores during fasting, it burns fat for energy, resulting in weight loss.
Artificial euphoria leads to the hell fire, whilst a natural sense of happiness and well being from coming closer to GOD is permissible
Give an example of something man has created and not given any instructions on its use, unless it be a place of shelter, or bicycle, and even then they start with stabilisers until one learns how to ride without them.
On another thread I explained Evolution does not explain where consciousnesses comes from and can't explain why humans want answers, want to explore, what to push boundaries of learning and understanding etc
Far from it, what this site does is allows people to give their interpretation and understanding, but ultimately it's the use of our GOD given faculties of reasoning and logic which can determine which position is on the truth.
There are atheists that come down to Speakers Corner at Hyde Park, and some seem very knowledgeable, like the following guy who explains origin of man's reasoning and logic:
Well spoken and seemingly intelligent in his discussion with a couple of Christians.
Last edited:
QuestioningMind
Well-Known Member
For so many people, it just seems like God isn't there. What do you think God's reasons are for hiding himself and demanding that people have faith, rather than just give everybody proof, and speak so that the ears can hear?
Nobody knows exactly, but you might have some helpful insights from your opinion about the matter.
I think it all comes down to the scripture, "without faith it is impossible to please God"... If we had proof and could hear him clearly, that would deprive us of the ability to have faith... And without it we can't please God.
Then the question is, why is it so important to have faith?
I guess I have to accept that that's just the way God is... Even if it does drive me nuts
Have you ever received a clear message from God?
"For so many people, it just seems like God isn't there. What do you think God's reasons are for hiding himself and demanding that people have faith, rather than just give everybody proof, and speak so that the ears can hear?"
In my opinion if there was an all powerful creator god there would be no reason for it to hide itself and demand that it be worshiped via blind faith, instead of giving proof. That's why I highly doubt that any creator god exists.
"I guess I have to accept that that's just the way God is..."
I beg to differ. You don't have to accept anything that you don't have verifiable evidence for, regardless of what other people may tell you. I'd never be so arrogant as to claim that there absolutely is not a creator god. I can only go by what I have sufficient evidence to believe is true. IF there is a creator god, I'm confident that it wants me to use my logical rational thinking brain to the best of my ability. And that suggests that it doesn't want me to believe in claims without sufficient evidence.
God is not ready to come collect the subjects until God's house is ready to receive them.
Ashley Mathura
New Member
Divinity most of the time has little logical and scientific reasoning - yet if you really think about it, it was divinity that created science and reasoning...
A Vestigial Mote
Well-Known Member
Why call what you are referring to "God"? Why bother anthropomorphizing such a thing? Why give this "God" thing all of the credit when there may well be nothing there? Humility? I could just as easily give all the credit for my survival to a magical, invisible jellyfish and it would have just as much meaning as throwing the label "God" on it.
WalterTrull
Godfella
I used to try not using the word "God". That got silly. I actually don't anthropomorphize God. Many do and I think it just confuses those folks.
This too is why I personally believe in God. To me everything in nature points to a creator.
I agree. Otherwise very little makes sense regarding our life experiences both good and mad. Is this life, like I read it described in a book, a kind of boot camp preparing and maturing us for what comes after? Interesting to contemplate.
Cant really add anything to that, and I couldn't find the thumbs up emoji, so I'll just say "well said".
ThePainefulTruth
Romantic-Cynic
For so many people, it just seems like God isn't there. What do you think God's reasons are for hiding himself and demanding that people have faith, rather than just give everybody proof, and speak so that the ears can hear?
Nobody knows exactly, but you might have some helpful insights from your opinion about the matter.
I think it all comes down to the scripture, "without faith it is impossible to please God"... If we had proof and could hear him clearly, that would deprive us of the ability to have faith... And without it we can't please God.
Then the question is, why is it so important to have faith?
I guess I have to accept that that's just the way God is... Even if it does drive me nuts
Have you ever received a clear message from God?
God, if It exists, doesn't hide and demand faith. That would teach us to be irrational, which we do a fine job of anyway. God hides so as not to influence our moral choices. If God exists, I assume this is a test for the choices we make.
In Noah's day only Noah and family were considered as righteous ones.
At the soon coming ' time of separation' to take place on Earth at Matthew 25:31-33,37 only humble ' sheep'-like people will be counted as righteous ones. So, quantity of religions is Not necessarily quality in God's eyes.
The international scope of the Bible being translated into people's mother tongues, or native languages, far surpasses any other books religious or secular just as Matthew 24:14 and Acts of the Apostles 1:8 mentions the grand scope.
As far as stars, planets, constellations being named by humans, please notice who named Earth at Genesis 1:10.
Also of interest are the verses at Job 38:31-33; Amos 5:8.
In a physical sense I find we all require constant REFRESH.....and that is also true in a spiritual sense.
As 2 Corinthians 4:16 mentions we can be REFRESHED or RENEWED day by day.
Refreshed or renewed through daily prayer (Luke 11:13B), the pages of the Bible (Psalms 119:105), and through good associations with others.
Even the polluted Earth when left alone bounces back or renews and refreshes itself.
What is Not refreshing about Daniel 2:44 that through God's kingdom government mankind will be refreshed.
Jesus, as Prince of Peace, will usher in global Peace on Earth among people of goodwill - Isaiah 11:3-4.
What is Not refreshing about Psalms 72:8; Psalms 72:12-14 that Jesus will relieve mankind of distresses.
Then, refreshed Earth will be as described at Isaiah 35.
Good point as Psalms 119:105 shows Scripture is God's instruction manual or guide book for mankind.
Scripture I find is a 'light' (flashlight) to our immediate steps and a 'lamp' (high beams) to our roadway ahead of us.
A Vestigial Mote
Well-Known Member
What is not refreshing about those things is that there are absolutely no guarantees. As a form of evidence I would offer all of the predictions about the end of the world that have come and gone, or all of the times people were so sure that all of these sorts of prophecies would be brought to culmination during their life-times... but, of course, they died. The pattern of non-completion (or else "completion" only by means of amazing stretches of the imagination) of these kinds of wild prophecies is so ridiculously compelling that it is a bafflement why anyone would keep rehashing these things with even an ounce of confidence. And yet here you are...