Welcome to Religious Forums, a friendly forum to discuss all religions in a friendly surrounding.
Your voice is missing! You will need to register to get access to the following site features:We hope to see you as a part of our community soon!
Maize said:The Shield of Islam said:We are not talking about the formation of the moon maize, we are talking about splitting the moon ( one of prophet Muhammad(pbuh ) mircales.
Then why the NASA article on the moon being formed from the Earth? :?
Runt said:No, he has posted a NASA article in an attempt to show evidence the moon was split. The article has nothing to do with his belief. He is therefore trying to deceive rather than back up his belief.
Or he's simply misunderstanding that it was the EARTH splitting that created the moon, rather than the moon itself splitting. And if he wants to attribute what others may call a "natural phenomonen" to his God, then so be it. Also understand that his first language is not English... there could be misunderstandings based on that too... I know I sound illogical and misunderstand things all the time when I try to go from English to Spanish... *shrugs* Too bad we're not telepathic...
(Q) said:No Q, you're getting the impression that he believes differently than you do, and you don't like it.
No, he has posted a NASA article in an attempt to show evidence the moon was split. The article has nothing to do with his belief. He is therefore trying to deceive rather than back up his belief.
The Shield of Islam said:The article seems to suggest that the moon was split at one time in its history, you know, the full article was removed from NASA site for some strange reason...I cant find the whole article !!
Maize said:Sheild, your historical proof is still not enough for me. If the moon had split in two during the lifetime of the Prophet Muhammad, there would be accounts from all over the Earth of this phenomenon happening, wouldn't you say? Your historical proof is full of names, places and words I am not familiar with and really can't comment on their validity. Why is it so important that you convince others this happened?
Maize said:Give it a rest, Shield. Calling someone pathetic is not a good way to make friends.
I wanted the Japanese "proof" because it would supposedly be a non-Islamic source.
A non-baised source, if you will. But if you don't know to show me that's fine... I'm sure it won't convince me of the "miracle" either, but I'm curious about all things in a histortical context. I just wanted to see it out of curiousity.
best friend said:in God's complete authority over destiny, be it good or bad; and in life after death.
The Shield of Islam said:We only believe those whom their lives witness their greatness, those who performed divine miracles( like prophet Jesus raising the dead and prophet muhammad splitting the moon ) and indeed changed the course of history.
The Ocelot said:The Shield of Islam said:We only believe those whom their lives witness their greatness, those who performed divine miracles( like prophet Jesus raising the dead and prophet muhammad splitting the moon ) and indeed changed the course of history.
How can you hold Jesus as a prophet without being a Christian? To believe there is deity in what he says is to be Christian if he says that he is the way, the truth, and the life.
The Ocelot
Runt said:Ocelot, I think (and Shield, correct me if I am wrong) that Muslims believe that Jesus spoke truth, but then his words were corrupted by history and were lost, making his words as they are found in the Bible (and as they are read by Christians) false.