We are look at the signs of eloquence in Quran in this thread:
Signs of eloquence in Quran | Religious Forums
Let me know if I'm being objective so far in pointing to some eloquence or if it's subjective.
Don't link me to a thread where I'm supposed to go hunt for the answer the my question which may or may not exist in the thread. That is very disrespectful. And incredibly lazy.
As I said before: your question of if the challenge is fair, CAN NOT BE ANSWERED
until you list the objective criteria by which this is to be measured. It is the criteria that will determine if it is "fair" or not.
So you should list those criteria here.
In fact, this is so crucial to your OP question that these criteria should have been listed in the OP right from the start.
So please, list the objective criteria.
Or alternatively, admit that these criteria don't exist.