Ah, Gaga does indeed have talent. It's understandable to say that it isn't your taste, but it isn't when there is a lack of talent involved.
If that's the case, then anyone ought to be able to carry a tune, do the exact steps in time to the song, and to perform on cue. Go ahead....find 10 people off the street who can perform the exact same way. It can't be done.
I see it all the time when people audition for me who think that if shaking their thang is so easy that they should get in my show. Fuh-get it...they have to shake their thang with proper alignment and with stage presence at the very very least.
That doesn't make Gaga a great dancer. Don't get me wrong. But no talent? That's disingenuous.
It's my job to recognize where performers have their strengths and where they are weak according to their goals. I'd be a horrible teacher if I waved off performers telling them they have absolutely no talent, don't even try, give it up, etc.
Anyway, just a little clarification here on how I work in show business.