Salam
The Quran endorses Musa, Haroun... Isa.. in Bani-Israel. So how can it say Judaism and Christianity is false?
Surah Baqara shows from the start, the people are not reliable means, because they took a golden statue as a God.
And it was not their only crime in that generation, and per Quran, they didn't support the Prophets and denied some of them and some were left to be killed by government of their time like Yahya.
Now when it comes to deniers of Ahlulbayt (a), for sure to be me they are a false religion. Now leaves the followers, but they are too are condemned similarly the way bani-Israel are and hence can't be seen as a reliable means.
(1) We didn't support our Imams (a) through out time, and hence can't claim to represent them properly.
(2) We mixed falsehood with truth and commanded people to what we didn't do ourselves.
(3) We didn't hold our scholars and their leadership accountable to Quran similarly how Christians followed their scholars without holding them accountable.
This shows, we aren't the true religion, even if Mohammad, Ali.... the Mahdi... (Ahlubayt) are true the same way it shows Judaism and Christianity are not truth even if Musa and Isa are true.
I'm arguing the same reasoning that shows neither Jews or Christians can be relied on for the truth of the divine books the same is true of us with respect to Quran.
Where does that leave Islam and truth?
Hadiths are minefield, some of the treasures that give insights to Quran, and some of them don't.
Scholars offer a lot of insights to hadiths and Quran, but they also make you think in false ways and bring you to error.
The best thing to say, is Quran and it's true interpretation is HIDDEN. The Quran is among the people and it's people among the people but unknown and hidden.
Slowly, if we acknowledge, this, we can begin to remove falsehood in our religion, and build up back truth.
Lastly Quran says you can be informed by revelation or knowledge, and Sunnah often refers to Quran, but often it shows by knowledge, the latter is always found in Quran someway. Despite Quran saying knowledge is a way to know and reasoning works, Ahlulbayt (a) emphasized Quran contains explanation to all things.
Some people underestimate the Quran, and so say "where is this in Quran?", the problem is they take their lack of reflection and understanding as proof something is not in Quran.
Quran contains all guidance and Sunnah of Ahlulbayt (a) has explained it all.
But we have to rethink the approach we taken for attributing things to God and his religion. Ilmel Rijaal doesn't work, Tawatur is not a guarantee something has not been fabricated.
The Quran endorses Musa, Haroun... Isa.. in Bani-Israel. So how can it say Judaism and Christianity is false?
Surah Baqara shows from the start, the people are not reliable means, because they took a golden statue as a God.
And it was not their only crime in that generation, and per Quran, they didn't support the Prophets and denied some of them and some were left to be killed by government of their time like Yahya.
Now when it comes to deniers of Ahlulbayt (a), for sure to be me they are a false religion. Now leaves the followers, but they are too are condemned similarly the way bani-Israel are and hence can't be seen as a reliable means.
(1) We didn't support our Imams (a) through out time, and hence can't claim to represent them properly.
(2) We mixed falsehood with truth and commanded people to what we didn't do ourselves.
(3) We didn't hold our scholars and their leadership accountable to Quran similarly how Christians followed their scholars without holding them accountable.
This shows, we aren't the true religion, even if Mohammad, Ali.... the Mahdi... (Ahlubayt) are true the same way it shows Judaism and Christianity are not truth even if Musa and Isa are true.
I'm arguing the same reasoning that shows neither Jews or Christians can be relied on for the truth of the divine books the same is true of us with respect to Quran.
Where does that leave Islam and truth?
Hadiths are minefield, some of the treasures that give insights to Quran, and some of them don't.
Scholars offer a lot of insights to hadiths and Quran, but they also make you think in false ways and bring you to error.
The best thing to say, is Quran and it's true interpretation is HIDDEN. The Quran is among the people and it's people among the people but unknown and hidden.
Slowly, if we acknowledge, this, we can begin to remove falsehood in our religion, and build up back truth.
Lastly Quran says you can be informed by revelation or knowledge, and Sunnah often refers to Quran, but often it shows by knowledge, the latter is always found in Quran someway. Despite Quran saying knowledge is a way to know and reasoning works, Ahlulbayt (a) emphasized Quran contains explanation to all things.
Some people underestimate the Quran, and so say "where is this in Quran?", the problem is they take their lack of reflection and understanding as proof something is not in Quran.
Quran contains all guidance and Sunnah of Ahlulbayt (a) has explained it all.
But we have to rethink the approach we taken for attributing things to God and his religion. Ilmel Rijaal doesn't work, Tawatur is not a guarantee something has not been fabricated.