Does present exists ?

[chinu]

Yes.
The past and future are in your mind, the present is where you live though you may not see it or feel it or hear it until it is past.

You went to see thyself in the mirror.

Who came first ? Outer one, or the inner one ?

 

[chinu]

The PRESENT is the only thing that exists...
The PAST is gone and the FUTURE is not here yet.

PAST is gone.
And, I cannot reply to your FUTURE posts.

What is your PRESENT question ?

 

[ChristineM]

You went to see thyself in the mirror.

Who came first ? Outer one, or the inner one ?

Even seeing yourself in the mirror is history, light travels at a finite speed.

 

[chinu]

It's all that exists the past and future are creations of the mind.

This means it’s useless to respond to your past posts ?

 

[chinu]

Even seeing yourself in the mirror is history, light travels at a finite speed.

Who came first ? Outer one, or the inner one ?

Please answer my question

 

[Trailblazer]

PAST is gone.
And, I cannot reply to your FUTURE posts.

What is your PRESENT question ?

PRESENTLY I do not have a question.
If I have a question in the FUTURE, which will then be the PRESENT, I will ask it.

 

[ChristineM]

Who came first ? Outer one, or the inner one ?

Please answer my question

What are you talking about... Outer... Inner what?

 

[PearlSeeker]

This means it’s useless to respond to your past posts ?

Why is it useless?

 

[Trailblazer]

This means it’s useless to respond to your past posts ?

No, because what is in his past posts was written when the past was the present, so it was in his mind in the present.
He might have changed his mind since he wrote those posts but not necessarily.

 

[chinu]

What are you talking about... Outer... Inner what?

Inner image in the mirror, or your real body which is outside the mirror.
Which came first ?

 

[chinu]

PRESENTLY I do not have a question.
If I have a question in the FUTURE, which will then be the PRESENT, I will ask it.

Is there any other option you have, until then ?

I think I made you option-less ?

 

[chinu]

Why is it useless?

Because that was not YOUR post/question ?

 

[chinu]

No, because what is in his past posts was written when the past was the present, so it was in his mind in the present.
He might have changed his mind since he wrote those posts but not necessarily.

Let’s wait and watch

 

[ChristineM]

Inner image in the mirror, or your real body which is outside the mirror.
Which came first ?

Outer came first, light travels from outer to mirror causing reflection in the mirrored surface. That light spent time travelling from outer to the mirrored surface and time travelling back to outer.

So outer see image of outer in the past

 

[bobhikes]

This means it’s useless to respond to your past posts ?

Only if you don't have a brain.

 

[Eddi]

Does PRESENT exists ?

Only very fleetingly

It soon turns into the past

 

[PearlSeeker]

Because that was not YOUR post/question ?

Is this your question or answer?

You don't have to answer. I didn't mean to be rude. I just thought it's a convention in forums to interfere in dialogue.

 

[chinu]

Outer came first, light travels from outer to mirror causing reflection in the mirrored surface. That light spent time travelling from outer to the mirrored surface and time travelling back to outer.

So outer see image of outer in the past

Okay,

Outer is — past
Outer see image is — present, or future ?

And also answer:

Can future come before present ?

 

[chinu]

Only very fleetingly

Can it be — so fleeting — will lose its existence ?

 

[chinu]

Only if you don't have a brain.

What do you think — do I have brain, or not ?