Scott1
Well-Known Member
He he he..... don't try and direct me back to the illogical question until you answer mine.Mr. Sprinkles said:Scott-- I'm not making a statement of fact. This is completely hypothetical, because we don't even know if A is true. This is what I'm saying: IF A is true, THEN B cannot be true. Illogical? How? I think you theists should lay off the question for a bit and get cracking on the answer instead.
I hope your quote from my last thread shows that you ARE using these questions as a means to determine fact. Why else would you come to the conclusion :"This leads us to the conclusion that saying God is omnipotent is unreasonable, and the theists only hope is to then disparage our use of reason altogether."..............
How can you come to a conclusion on a hypothetical, illogical question????
Explain that to me please.
Look at what you are writing for one minute and explain to me logic.... I apparently don't know what the word means.This is completely hypothetical, because we don't even know if A is true. This is what I'm saying: IF A is true, THEN B cannot be true. Illogical? How?
"This is completely hypothetical......" Ok, I follow so far.... but then you say:
"IF A is true, THEN B cannot be true." Cannot be true. Can not. A statement of fact. Explain to me using your reason and logic how you can make a statment of FACT with a hypothetical question. PLEASE!
Smile!
Scott