• Welcome to Religious Forums, a friendly forum to discuss all religions in a friendly surrounding.

    Your voice is missing! You will need to register to get access to the following site features:
    • Reply to discussions and create your own threads.
    • Our modern chat room. No add-ons or extensions required, just login and start chatting!
    • Access to private conversations with other members.

    We hope to see you as a part of our community soon!

The Best of All Beliefs

Twilight Hue

Twilight, not bright nor dark, good nor bad.
Out of curiosity, IOW, not that you need to answer, but what is it about evolution that keeps us from peace and happiness?
I think its preservation. The survival instinct and the instinct that gives rise to tribalism and not trusting anything that is strange and unknown.
 

It Aint Necessarily So

Veteran Member
Premium Member
Lets say you had to opportunity to take the best aspect from each religious belief in the world.

What would you have?

One all-encompassing rule?
A set of rules?
Rituals to perform?
Would you need an entire book to contain the wisdom?
Or just a few concise words?

It's an odd question to me. I haven't taken any ideas from any religions. Nor from any other source - not in the sense of thinking that this guy probably knows what he's talking about and I should conform to his advice on that basis. So I decided that honesty was the best policy not because somebody told me to be honest, but because I discovered the problems lies cause and how they harm me and others, and discovered that there really was no reason to lie - no benefit in general (there might be specific instances where that is not true). The same argument can be made for all other virtues - life is better by embodying them than not if one can do it. Be kind. It pays dividends that one can experience. Be responsible. Obey the law. Don't betray people. Be true to one's conscience. Be of service. None of these come from a book in my case. They're lessons that life teaches the interested.

Thus, the collection of ideas that comprise my worldview all came from experience and reflection - from me deciding experientially that a given idea was useful for helping me live a more desirable life - not a holy book. I had already assembled a secular humanist worldview before I learned what they advocated. One day, while reading the Affirmations of Humanism, I said to myself, hey, that's me. I guess that's what people call my metaphysics, ethics, and epistemology. It was also an affirmation that I was on the right track coming to similar conclusions independently.

Also, one day after I had come to a rough idea on what constituted wisdom, I read Buddha and the Eightfold Path, and noticed that it was consistent with my own conclusions. Was I a Buddhist? Not in my mind. I just agreed with many of Buddha's thoughts once I saw them.
 

Spirit of Light

Be who ever you want
Lets say you had to opportunity to take the best aspect from each religious belief in the world.

What would you have?

One all-encompassing rule?
A set of rules?
Rituals to perform?
Would you need an entire book to contain the wisdom?
Or just a few concise words?
I would honestly not change my belief the way it is presented in Sufism :)
 

RestlessSoul

Well-Known Member
Philosophically, I find Buddhism and Taoism, plus The Upanishads and Bhagavad Gita from Hinduism, collectively appealing. Zen Buddhism is especially elegant. They’re all a bit esoteric though; I can incline towards navel gazing, a tendency I need to guard against.

Christ I think was the greatest of all moral teachers, not too closely followed by some of the institutions which subsequently bore his name. If I live what’s left of my life according to his teaching, that would be a life well lived; of course I fall well short, every day.

I have some pagan instincts; I observe both solstice and equinox, and Stonehenge is my favourite English Cathedral.
 
Last edited:

firedragon

Veteran Member
Lets say you had to opportunity to take the best aspect from each religious belief in the world.

What would you have?

One all-encompassing rule?
A set of rules?
Rituals to perform?
Would you need an entire book to contain the wisdom?
Or just a few concise words?

An entire book.
 

Clara Tea

Well-Known Member
Lets say you had to opportunity to take the best aspect from each religious belief in the world.

What would you have?

One all-encompassing rule?
A set of rules?
Rituals to perform?
Would you need an entire book to contain the wisdom?
Or just a few concise words?

Bris (Jewish). But can't look at nudity. So, bris with eyes closed (fast moving samurai sword).

Can't eat pork (Jewish), cows (Buddhist), and with further restrictions from other religions, one would be on a weight loss diet. Instead of sucking on a mint toothpick, try one without mint for dinner.

Translating every language on earth to each ceremony, one would have to spend days performing them. Marriages would be very long events.

You would need many books to encompass the wisdom of each religion.

You'd have to train people to accept others ideas and beliefs (that would be very hard).
 

Clara Tea

Well-Known Member
Philosophically, I find Buddhism and Taoism, and The Upanishads and Bhagavad Gita from Hinduism, collectively make considers appeal. They’re all a bit esoteric though; I can incline towards navel gazing, a tendency I need to guard against.

Christ I think was the greatest of all moral teachers, not too closely followed by some of the institutions which subsequently bore his name. If I live what’s left of my life according to his teaching, that would be a life well lived; of course I fall well short, every day.

I have some pagan instincts; I observe both solstice and equinox, and Stonehenge is my favourite English Cathedral.

Contemplation of the navel, as it turns out, is a matter of balance....physical balance is but one aspect. Other aspects should also be balanced. Of course it is amazing that the exercise instructor is so well versed, and the people walking by are so fit. Then the exercise instructor says...."your own navel, please."

The navy has naval surgeons (my goodness... how doctors specialize).
 

Sand Dancer

Crazy Cat Lady
Lets say you had to opportunity to take the best aspect from each religious belief in the world.

What would you have?

One all-encompassing rule?
A set of rules?
Rituals to perform?
Would you need an entire book to contain the wisdom?
Or just a few concise words?

One all-encompassing rule, like the Golden Rule, which exists in almost every religion, and let people make it their own. I like rituals, like meditation or celebrating the seasons. I don't think a book is needed because then the authors or the subjects the books are about get made into gods after their deaths. That ruins the original message, IMO.
 

amorphous_constellation

Well-Known Member
Lets say you had to opportunity to take the best aspect from each religious belief in the world.

What would you have?

One all-encompassing rule?
A set of rules?
Rituals to perform?
Would you need an entire book to contain the wisdom?
Or just a few concise words?

Probably a lot of dialectic discussion. Getting the reader to decide for themselves more, building their brain, or soul, so that they can perceive for themselves what they think is right. And of course that would involve putting all the ideas from every religion on the table, for analysis. So at least then they would be very aware, before making decisions. Or as aware as they could be.
 

Muffled

Jesus in me
Lets say you had to opportunity to take the best aspect from each religious belief in the world.

What would you have?

One all-encompassing rule?
A set of rules?
Rituals to perform?
Would you need an entire book to contain the wisdom?
Or just a few concise words?

A few words:

Christianity: Eternal life - I hate dying
Islam: 72 virgins - I need a good laugh
Judaism - Mitzvahs - I suppose a quinceanera would do but it isn't religious.
Hinduism - Reincarnation except they don't get it right
Buddhism - The Wheel of Time - makes alpha and omega sense
Baha'i - A concept that Christianity and Islam can be reconciled - Neither party agreed with the B man.
Sikh - the Langar - who doesn't like pot luck suppers?
Norse gods - Hel - not a god but for the Hel she lives in
Greek gods - genetic engineering - how else do you get perfect looks and bodies?
Tao - I Ching - lots of fun thinking about the future
 
Top