• Welcome to Religious Forums, a friendly forum to discuss all religions in a friendly surrounding.

    Your voice is missing! You will need to register to get access to the following site features:
    • Reply to discussions and create your own threads.
    • Our modern chat room. No add-ons or extensions required, just login and start chatting!
    • Access to private conversations with other members.

    We hope to see you as a part of our community soon!

Trump and "s***hole" countries.

Epic Beard Man

Bearded Philosopher
Hillbilly is definitely a racial slur and though many folks might get away with using it, just like people get away with other racial slurs depending on their ethnicity, it’s racist if used in an insulting manner. Same as redneck and cracker. Some people may not mind it but coukd depend on intent. I personally, wouldn’t get away with calling someone those terms in real life. Besides the word hillbilly in itself is often derogatory , and in the context as described would most certainly be deemed derogatory. I avoid terms like that as a general rule as I avoid using all other racial slurs one can come up with. I respect your opinion if you don’t find it offensive, I personally wouldn’t go there in real life as mentioned.

Can you show me some readings where hillbilly is historically and presently a derogatory term? If what you say is true then this shouldn't have been on television:

 

Epic Beard Man

Bearded Philosopher
Making a comment about Haiti being a s******* is not intrinsically racist in itself... It's a comment about the miserable conditions , poverty, pollution, disease, disasters, and poor sanitation. Haiti is not made up of only one race.

Most black people are not Haitian, so making a comment about Haiti or some other poor country is not a comment about an entire race.

But I do apologize for calling Haiti a s*******. Id rather be euthanized than live there..however, I'm sure there are many beautiful people who live there, and it was wrong for me to make a comment that would suggest something negative about them.

Apology accepted?

I don't know why you are compelled to apologize. I am not Haitian. However in context of Trump's words, Trump was mainly talking about black African countries and Latin American countries.

Forget the sh*****e remark, hasn't anyone seen Trump is drawing a pattern targeting blacks and latinos?
 

Revoltingest

Pragmatic Libertarian
Premium Member
According to basic logic, all whites are not hillbillies because whites comprise many metropolitan areas as well as big city areas.
To be correct, it should read...
"....logic, not all whites are hillbillies...."
This is because "all" is being negated, not "whites".
 

Orbit

I'm a planet
"Hillbillies" is a class-based insult, not a racially based one. It's internecine semantic warfare between different classes of white. Same with white trash, redneck, and cracker.
 

idav

Being
Premium Member
"Hillbillies" is a class-based insult, not a racially based one. It's internecine semantic warfare between different classes of white. Same with white trash, redneck, and cracker.
If it had nothing to do with race or ethnicity, “white” would not be in the description.
 

idav

Being
Premium Member
I do see your point @Orbit though since the term might come from someone of the same race, in which case context is king.
 

Phil25

Active Member
Norwegians don't seem to want to come to the US:

https://www.rawstory.com/2018/01/thanks-but-no-thanks-norwegians-reject-trumps-immigration-offer/

Quote:
“Of course people from #Norway would love to move to a country where people are far more likely to be shot, live in poverty, get no healthcare because they’re poor, get no paid parental leave or subsidized daycare and see fewer women in political power."

It seems they are very clear about which country is the ******** country.

Now, how great is America?
About 4000 Norwegians did apply for US Green card under the diversity lottery system in 2012.
 
Last edited:

garden47

Member
BBGMtfP.img

Trump and "s***hole" countries

With Trump as President, many of those highly educated potential students and immigrants from "s***hole" countries will be having second thoughts about making the US their first choice!

Given America's current opioid epidemic, inner city blight/crime, rural poverty, Puerto Rico and a Republican Congress' failure to renew the healthcare insurance coverage for 9 million of the nation's poorest children, large sements of the US population are also living under "s***hole" conditions!
 
Last edited:

idav

Being
Premium Member
I am not concerned about the urban dictionary just correcting you on the correct usage of the word racism on certwin words.
Sure well it’s how people use the term I’m concerned with. As mentioned context matters.

Edit: BTW what trump said wasn’t particularly racist but does show his true colors as usual with his bigotry xenophobia and racist attitudes towards many peoples.
 

Mister Emu

Emu Extraordinaire
Staff member
Premium Member
I’m a little surprised at the lack of empathy here.
I do empathise with them. If I were in a comparable utopia I wouldn't want to leave either.

You're crafting false realities. From 60% to 70% of asylum seekers are from stable countries and they are just seeking better economic circumstances*. They don't want to go back to their former lives, they came to stay.

*Most migrants to Europe 'are not refugees'
http://www.altaiconsulting.com/wp-c...igration-Trends-in-Libya-Final-Report-Web.pdf

Why deny if it was appropriate?
Who said it was appropriate? It wasn't at all. As for the denial in general, I'm somewhat surprised, it sounded like something he'd say, and he generally acknowledges his statements that others deem out of bounds.
 

Falvlun

Earthbending Lemur
Premium Member
I do empathise with them. If I were in a comparable utopia I wouldn't want to leave either.
I don’t think you’re really considering the hardship and loss that would entail. Empathisizing is about considering how people who aren’t you would feel about it.

You're crafting false realities. From 60% to 70% of asylum seekers are from stable countries and they are just seeking better economic circumstances*. They don't want to go back to their former lives, they came to stay.

*Most migrants to Europe 'are not refugees'
http://www.altaiconsulting.com/wp-c...igration-Trends-in-Libya-Final-Report-Web.pdf
This is a 162 pg report. Could you quote the relevant portion and where to find it?

Even assuming your number above is correct that still leaves 30-40%. What, those people don’t count? Furthermore, it’s possible that those who came seeking a better life may have found they’d prefer home.

Regardless, it really doesn’t matter to my argument. My point was that offering people money is a humanitarian solution to getting a portion of refugees to return home. It’s a hell of a lot better than just forcing them out, and you can’t argue that some migrants would want to return home. Nothing you or Epic Beard Man have said changes that.

IWho said it was appropriate? It wasn't at all. As for the denial in general, I'm somewhat surprised, it sounded like something he'd say, and he generally acknowledges his statements that others deem out of bounds.
Excusing what Trump said as “the truth” lends a veneer of acceptability to his statement.

And I included other reasons people use to excuse Trump’s behavior (like, “it was the truth” or “it doesn’t really matter”) in that post because different supporters will employ different apologetics. Feel free to address those if you don’t feel “it was appropriate” fits you.
 

Stanyon

WWMRD?
Can you show me some readings where hillbilly is historically and presently a derogatory term? If what you say is true then this shouldn't have been on television:


Haha! Those weren't real hillbillies and it would be no different than a show called "The New York N*****s"
 

Stanyon

WWMRD?
I don't know why you are compelled to apologize. I am not Haitian. However in context of Trump's words, Trump was mainly talking about black African countries and Latin American countries.

Forget the sh*****e remark, hasn't anyone seen Trump is drawing a pattern targeting blacks and latinos?

There are many countries that are s********, it's not Trumps fault many of them have blacks and Latinos in them. A s******* is a s******* regardless of the color of the peoples skin.
 

Stanyon

WWMRD?
BBGMtfP.img

Trump and "s***hole" countries

With Trump as President, many of those highly educated potential students and immigrants from "s***hole" countries will be having second thoughts about making the US their first choice!

Given America's current opioid epidemic, inner city blight/crime, rural poverty, Puerto Rico and a Republican Congress' failure to renew the healthcare insurance coverage for 9 million of the nation's poorest children, large sements of the US population are also living under "s***hole" conditions!
What a joke, we saw how that narrative worked out in Europe. No matter how you try to play it, the vast majority are not families or highly skilled professionals and more than a few are/were country shopping. If I were an immigrant with little to no skills and probably no chance of getting citizenship I'd travel to Germany. in Germany not only will they feed and house me for a while but send me back with several thousand Euros in my pocket after they reject my request.
 

Falvlun

Earthbending Lemur
Premium Member
There are many countries that are s********, it's not Trumps fault many of them have blacks and Latinos in them. A s******* is a s******* regardless of the color of the peoples skin.
The “racism” aspect isn’t really about calling the countries ****holes. (That’s just a problem with crudeness, a lack of diplomacy and tact.)

The racism aspect comes into play with the context. Donald is asking why we accept people from ****hole countries. This clearly indicates that he finds such people to be undesirable immigrants. This is simplistic and offensive and untrue on many planes.

I personally don’t consider it racist per se. That argument doesn’t particularly resonate with me.

However, I do ultimately see it as a negative, simplistic stereotyping of entire swaths of people, and I don’t want that message to get lost.
 
Top