• Welcome to Religious Forums, a friendly forum to discuss all religions in a friendly surrounding.

    Your voice is missing! You will need to register to get access to the following site features:
    • Reply to discussions and create your own threads.
    • Our modern chat room. No add-ons or extensions required, just login and start chatting!
    • Access to private conversations with other members.

    We hope to see you as a part of our community soon!

There is no Sin...

Nakosis

Non-Binary Physicalist
Premium Member
Outside of religion.

If sin is breaking or disobeying God's rules. Then it depends on what God you follow as different Gods have different rules for their followers. Whereas one action maybe a sin for the follower of one God. It may not be a sin for one who follows a different God.

One cannot "sin" if the action is not breaking the rules of the God they follow.

So to be sinless, free of sin, one must simply not follow any God.
 

mikkel_the_dane

My own religion
Outside of religion.

If sin is breaking or disobeying God's rules. Then it depends on what God you follow as different Gods have different rules for their followers. Whereas one action maybe a sin for the follower of one God. It may not be a sin for one who follows a different God.

One cannot "sin" if the action is not breaking the rules of the God they follow.

So to be sinless, free of sin, one must simply not follow any God.

Yes, correct.

And then we start about other words including harm and what that is.
 
Outside of religion.

If sin is breaking or disobeying God's rules. Then it depends on what God you follow as different Gods have different rules for their followers. Whereas one action maybe a sin for the follower of one God. It may not be a sin for one who follows a different God.

One cannot "sin" if the action is not breaking the rules of the God they follow.

So to be sinless, free of sin, one must simply not follow any God.

Yes and I want to add that there is no good or evil. Life is a cruel war and in order to survive we have to be cruel too. It isn't a luxury it is a necessity.
 

ChristineM

"Be strong", I whispered to my coffee.
Premium Member
Outside of religion.

If sin is breaking or disobeying God's rules. Then it depends on what God you follow as different Gods have different rules for their followers. Whereas one action maybe a sin for the follower of one God. It may not be a sin for one who follows a different God.

One cannot "sin" if the action is not breaking the rules of the God they follow.

So to be sinless, free of sin, one must simply not follow any God.

Yes, godless people may be good guys or real ******** committing all sorts of crime but they cannot sin.
 
  • Like
Reactions: ppp
Yes, but not your religion. You are conflating to different versions of "we".

It doesn't matter which religion we all share the same nature within and without. Nature itself is evolution and evolution made us predators so we all have a will to power. That's why when people are given power they do horrible things. It isn't because power corrupts it is because when we get powerful the fears and limitations the society put on us are removed and our true nature is revealed. That's why the basis of morality is fear. They need to twist and weaken our nature so that our will to power is broken.
 
Last edited:

mikkel_the_dane

My own religion
It doesn't matter which religion we all share the same nature within and without. Nature itself is evolution and evolution made us predators so we all have a will to power. That's why when people are given power they do horrible things. It isn't because power corrupts it is because when we get powerful the fears and limitations the society put on us are removed and our true nature is revealed.

Yeah, I still view it differently.
 

mikkel_the_dane

My own religion
Don't get me wrong though I do not claim to be an apex predator. I am like most of us are: broken. They twisted and weakened my nature so that my will to power is broken but I am trying to get strong again.

Okay, I try to be strong in another sense. I accept that you do it you, but I still do differently
 

Altfish

Veteran Member
Outside of religion.

If sin is breaking or disobeying God's rules. Then it depends on what God you follow as different Gods have different rules for their followers. Whereas one action maybe a sin for the follower of one God. It may not be a sin for one who follows a different God.

One cannot "sin" if the action is not breaking the rules of the God they follow.

So to be sinless, free of sin, one must simply not follow any God.
"Sin" is not a term that I, as a non-believer, recognise.
Yes, I have done many 'wrong things' in my life but to describe them as 'sin' would not be right.
 

Suave

Simulated character
Outside of religion.

If sin is breaking or disobeying God's rules. Then it depends on what God you follow as different Gods have different rules for their followers. Whereas one action maybe a sin for the follower of one God. It may not be a sin for one who follows a different God.

One cannot "sin" if the action is not breaking the rules of the God they follow.

So to be sinless, free of sin, one must simply not follow any God.

"I like the notion of me having fun in sin city without guilt as our Lord and Savior J.C, has atoned for our sins and has redeemed us to be worthy of His Eternal Glory!"

Is RF unholy? If we are all sinners (drinkers, smokers, blasphemers)

 

Shadow Wolf

Certified People sTabber
Outside of religion.

If sin is breaking or disobeying God's rules. Then it depends on what God you follow as different Gods have different rules for their followers. Whereas one action maybe a sin for the follower of one God. It may not be a sin for one who follows a different God.

One cannot "sin" if the action is not breaking the rules of the God they follow.

So to be sinless, free of sin, one must simply not follow any God.
Sin tends to be very specific to Abrahamic faiths. Most deities do not care nearly as much as Abrahams god.
And you have to remember sin isnt just violating Yahweh's rules, they are acts that allegedly eternally damn us, acts of the flesh that if given over to ensures our own destruction.
 
Top