[Poll] Vegan vs Carnivore

[spiritual5142]

By carnivore I mean ketogenic carnivore diet in which mainly fatty animal meat is eaten without anything else such as grains vegetables etc.

In vegan diet anything sourced from animals are not eaten, everything else is allowed.

 

[Secret Chief]

That was efficient of me

 

[Spirit of Light]

By carnivore I mean ketogenic carnivore diet in which mainly fatty animal meat is eaten without anything else such as grains vegetables etc. It is a very very low carbohydrate diet.

In vegan diet anything sourced from animals are not eaten, everything else is allowed.

Of the two choices i would say vegan.

But in general I would say a heathy mix of vegetarian and meat based food are most healthy

 

[Viker]

Humans being omnivores that are close to herbivores...I would have to side with a vegan diet. Humans are most definitely not full on carnivores.

 

[MikeF]

By carnivore I mean ketogenic carnivore diet in which mainly fatty animal meat is eaten without anything else such as grains vegetables etc. It is a very very low carbohydrate diet.

In vegan diet anything sourced from animals are not eaten, everything else is allowed.

I suggest that results will vary among individuals. In either instance, one can be sedentary and consume too many calories which I assume would be largely unhealthy.

 

[Saint Frankenstein]

I think meat is healthier than no meat at all, but I think these fad diets are bs.

 

[stvdv]

By carnivore I mean ketogenic carnivore diet in which mainly fatty animal meat is eaten without anything else such as grains vegetables etc.

In vegan diet anything sourced from animals are not eaten, everything else is allowed.

For Spiritual life vegan is best
Soldiers better eat meat

 

[Estro Felino]

I wonder how vegans can give up milk or cheese.
So keto...better...

 

[Aupmanyav]

I am a non-vegetarian and in OK health at the age of 80. do not know about Keto carnivorism.

For Spiritual life vegan is best.

Spiritual life does not depend on vegetarianism or non-vegetarianism.

 

[Shadow Wolf]

Humans are omnivore by design, specifically a frugivore, so neither. And the keto thing is a fad, and potentially dangerous without medical supervision and usage by those it's not intended for (yet, the keto diet is a prescription diet for a few disorders). So that one definitely is not good.
Generally, anything that cuts out entire food groups isn't, though I'm not aware of any common issues or problems arising in those who are vegetarian.

 

[Shadow Wolf]

By carnivore I mean ketogenic carnivore diet in which mainly fatty animal meat is eaten without anything else such as grains vegetables etc.

That is definitely not healthy. A diet high and rich in fatty animals is almost certainly going to give you cholesterol problems, and that almost invariably leads to heart disease.
If you're goal is longevity then a diet rich in fruits and vegetables, moderate consumption of grains and alcohols, and animals are eating sparingly is what we typically find (a few, however, cut out meat and alcohol entirely).

 

[exchemist]

By carnivore I mean ketogenic carnivore diet in which mainly fatty animal meat is eaten without anything else such as grains vegetables etc.

In vegan diet anything sourced from animals are not eaten, everything else is allowed.

I don't think either of these extremes is a good idea, really. It seems to me a bit like asking which is better: fascism or communism? I prefer democracy, myself.

 

[The Hammer]

Neither. A balanced diet is healthiest.

 

[Eddi]

The thing is, you never see an overweight or obese vegan.......

 

[Wildswanderer]

By carnivore I mean ketogenic carnivore diet in which mainly fatty animal meat is eaten without anything else such as grains vegetables etc.

In vegan diet anything sourced from animals are not eaten, everything else is allowed.

Carnivore by a very long shot.

 

[Wildswanderer]

The thing is, you never see an overweight or obese vegan.......

Lots of weak, sickly looking ones though.

 

[Wildswanderer]

That is definitely not healthy. A diet high and rich in fatty animals is almost certainly going to give you cholesterol problems, and that almost invariably leads to heart disease

That's been proven incorrect.

 

[Eddi]

Lots of weak, sickly looking ones though.

I know several and they are all in good condition - good skin etc.

So your claim is inconsistent with my first-hand experience

 

[Wildswanderer]

I know several and they are all in good condition - good skin etc.

So your claim is inconsistent with my first-hand experience

Well I knew a vegetarian who was the only actual white person I ever saw... I mean white like a sheet of paper. Didn't look very healthy to me.

 

[Erebus]

I'm not aware of any common issues or problems arising in those who are vegetarian.

Mainly a crippling desire for bacon if I'm honest.