Ella S.
*temp banned*
One one hand, no, because the argument used in the OP is an example of magical thinking, regardless of whether the conclusions reached are true or false.
On the other hand, yes, because neither of us are in a position to diagnose them with anything. I'm merely pointing out the kind of argument that's been presented.
If you can't cease from turning everything I say into a Straw Man, then we have no business discussing this any further.