• Welcome to Religious Forums, a friendly forum to discuss all religions in a friendly surrounding.

    Your voice is missing! You will need to register to get access to the following site features:
    • Reply to discussions and create your own threads.
    • Our modern chat room. No add-ons or extensions required, just login and start chatting!
    • Access to private conversations with other members.

    We hope to see you as a part of our community soon!

In God We Trust’ signs going up at public schools all over South Dakota

SugarOcean

¡pɹᴉǝM ʎɐʇS
There's no conflict.
"Basis" & "influence" are different.
But I have a solution....
One could say that the influence of Christianity if one of the bases of the Constitution.
Christians persecution Christians no doubt steered things in a secular direction.
But as I pointed out the 1st Amendment flies in the face of several of the 10 Commandments.
It flies in the face of the first command.

I appreciate the offer, but I'll pass.
Too bad. That way you'd not make the same mistake as prior when you said, "If we examine the Constitution, it isn't based upon Christianity either....."
 

Revoltingest

Pragmatic Libertarian
Premium Member
It flies in the face of the first command.
Nah.
Think of influence as being part of a basis.
But to say Christianity is the basis for the Constitution would be to ignore the other influences.
And remember....I gave Christian persecution of Christians credit for inspiring the 1st Amendment.
Too bad. That way you'd not make the same mistake as prior when you said, "If we examine the Constitution, it isn't based upon Christianity either....."
Rather than read extensive linked tomes, I prefer
that posters put arguments in their own words.
 

metis

aged ecumenical anthropologist
The "Free Exercise Clause" found in the 1st Amendment of the Constitution prohibits the creation of a national religion, so we are legally not a "Christian country", thus our laws need to reflect what the Constitution actually says and implies. Therefore, a public school cannot endorse or reflect any religion since the separation of church & state is also mandated for the states, and it's the states that ultimately are responsible for public education, not the local communities.
 

tytlyf

Not Religious
I agree god does equal religion. God and creator appear a few times in the declaration of independence and god/the devine is mentioned in the constitution of every state.
That's not referring to the christian god though. "Creator" means something different to deists than it does to christians.
So IMO christianity has been in America since it became America and christianity in America is like apple pie and baseball.
No one is disputing that. I'm sure a denomination of christianity that most Americans aren't today. We're talking about the founding fathers and their crafting of the constitution. It didn't matter to them that the majority of the population followed christ.
The point is the FF's understood the problem with religion intertwining with the government and declared so in the founding documents. They didn't want god on the money, they didn't want god added to the pledge. If they did, it would have been done at the beginning.

Just because the population is majority christian (slowly declining), doesn't give you the right to start introducing biblically inspired legislation to subvert the secular constitution.

For far too many years elected officials have ignored this clearly un-constitutional act
 

SugarOcean

¡pɹᴉǝM ʎɐʇS
Nah.
Think of influence as being part of a basis.
But to say Christianity is the basis for the Constitution would be to ignore the other influences.
I'm just going by the statement you made earlier.
And remember....I gave Christian persecution of Christians credit for inspiring the 1st Amendment.
Remember, Moses is on the Frieze, of the U.S Supreme Court. Carvings categorized as, Fame, Authority, Light of Wisdom, and History.
https://www.supremecourt.gov/about/northandsouthwalls.pdf

Rather than read extensive linked tomes, I prefer
that posters put arguments in their own words.
I do. I also like to offer other evidence for educational purposes.
 

Neutral Name

Active Member
I've never read it.
I go only buy what Christians tell me.
It seems that even they cannot agree on what they believe.

I've heard heard preachers speak.
Never is it "a god" or "the god".
It's always "God", often followed by an exclamation point.
This has all the earmarks of a proper name.

?

I'm totally with you on this!
 

Neutral Name

Active Member
That is incorrect.

“The laws of nature are the laws of God, whose authority can be superseded by no power on earth.” George Mason
Read more: Was The American (US) Constitution Really Based on Biblical Principles?


"Christians and critics hotly debate how the Bible influenced the U.S. Constitution. Secularists argue that contrary to popular opinion, the Founding Fathers were "deists" at best and never intended any religious influence in matters of government. Many Christians counter that while there were certainly theological differences and variations in the level of Christian commitment between the men who framed the Constitution, the principles upon which it is founded reveal foundational assumptions of a Christian worldview, even though the document does not explicitly refer to God nor the Bible. A look at the words of the Constitutional Convention delegates themselves provides insight into how their thinking was influenced by the Bible and Christian principles when framing the laws of the new nation.


Founding Fathers' Worldview
The laws set forth in the U.S. Constitution did not emerge out of a moral vacuum unrelated to the writers' own beliefs, but rather are the product of the reasonings of those who created it. By their own words, the Founding Fathers were not neutral on the question of religion as the basis of government and society.

For example, in a letter to the Officers of the First Brigade of the Third Division of the Militia of Massachusetts, John Adams writes, "Our Constitution was made only for a moral and religious people. It is wholly inadequate to the government of any other." "
More/Source: How Did the Bible Influence the U.S. Constitution? Tamara Christine Van Hooser - Updated May 10, 2019

Can I just say that the United States was founded based on freedom of religion. That includes atheists and non-Christians. I know God and God tells me that I don't have to deal with you control freaks. I will ask Jesus to inform you of the correct rules wherein you are told to be loving, kind, meek, humble, all of those things you seem to lack. Are you sure that you are a Christian? I'm don't think that you really are.

P.S. I know about patriotism. I'm a veteran from a long lineage of veterans, people who actually swore allegiance to the Constitution instead of to a religion. Separation of church and state.
 

Neutral Name

Active Member
The IRS has a great deal of power...they can take one's money
without a trial. A trial, of course, has the presumption of innocence.
But IRS actions have a lesser standard to meet.

Unless you are a con artist televangelist or preacher.
Robert Tilton is such a fine example but there are so many more.
The IRS has next to no rules for them. I think I'll contact Congress and ask them all audited.
 

Neutral Name

Active Member
That's contrary to what you stated earlier: "If we examine the Constitution, it isn't based upon Christianity either....."



You should read the articles.

The Founding Fathers, Deism, and Christianity

Britannica, pretty reputable source. "But the widespread existence in 18th-century America of a school of religious thought called Deism complicates the actual beliefs of the Founders. Drawing from the scientific and philosophical work of such figures as Jean-Jacques Rousseau, Isaac Newton, and John Locke, Deists argued that human experience and rationality—rather than religious dogma and mystery—determine the validity of human beliefs. In his widely read The Age of Reason, Thomas Paine, the principal American exponent of Deism, called Christianity “a fable.” Paine, the protégé of Benjamin Franklin, denied “that the Almighty ever did communicate anything to man, by…speech,…language, or…vision.” Postulating a distant deity whom he called “Nature’s God” (a term also used in the Declaration of Independence), Paine declared in a “profession of faith”:" etc.

Please feel free to read that.
 

Neutral Name

Active Member
I agree religious freedom means everyone. However I think it's a baseless argument to suggest putting up something islamic in place of something christian in America.

Actually, I stated in another post that the Christians should put up their prayer plaques and all of that at the Christian schools not the public schools.
 

Neutral Name

Active Member
Most christians are agnostic, most atheists are agnostic.

Atheism = lack of belief in a god
Theism = belief in a god

Agnostic = lack of knowledge (evidence) of a god
Gnostic = has knowledge (evidence) of a god

So, I guess I qualify as a scientific theist.
 

Neutral Name

Active Member
Inflammatory falsehood to claim one religion in America dominates the other. The first amendment proves that claim false on its face. Bearing false witness isn't Godly.

But posting so as to draw conflict and hope to bring drama gains attention.

Actually, if the "Christians" are trying to force their beliefs onto public schools, they are trying to dominate. What don't you get in that?
 
Top