• Welcome to Religious Forums, a friendly forum to discuss all religions in a friendly surrounding.

    Your voice is missing! You will need to register to get access to the following site features:
    • Reply to discussions and create your own threads.
    • Our modern chat room. No add-ons or extensions required, just login and start chatting!
    • Access to private conversations with other members.

    We hope to see you as a part of our community soon!

are people supposed to be in monogamous relationships or polyamorous relationships?

Kangaroo Feathers

Yea, it is written in the Book of Cyril...
images-2.jpeg
 

Dell

Asteroid insurance?
im confused about which is supposed to be practiced.There are scriptures that seem to suggest polyamorous relationships are acceptable in the bible when you look at kings and other people.it looks like the original plan was for a monogamous relationship when you read genesis.can anyone explain..
Back in the day when the Male population was being reduced constantly by war, and infant mortality so high, small civilizations saw it as survival, and females chose to accept it or chance hardships and no children.. I've heard from grand parents that during WW2 that hardly any young men were to be seen in town unless injured, or older men or pre adult boys.
Today we are fortunate to strive more for love, relationship, and family than physical survival. Naturally when it comes to love and companionship there is jealousy... no body usually wants to share the one they love with another... we want it all.
Even if it were legal, our nature wouldn't make it a good life for all involved... Lord knows it's hard enough to please and relate to one wife...
 

Riders

Well-Known Member
im confused about which is supposed to be practiced.There are scriptures that seem to suggest polyamorous relationships are acceptable in the bible when you look at kings and other people.it looks like the original plan was for a monogamous relationship when you read genesis.can anyone explain..

Polygamy not Polyamory. I was in a polyamory relationship with a guy who went off dated other women had sex with others watched porn and i had sex with other guys and tried to be in another relationship.But it didn't work for me I got worn out I can't do it now because of my addiction however, its not he same thing.

Polygamists married different wives it was usually the man not the woman, in polyamory women like me can go out and have different relationships. In Polygamy they are married to different people not jsut going out and having sex with others like me and Robert did.

The FLDS folks LDS folks the ones on tv shows are polygamists.
 

stvdv

Veteran Member: I Share (not Debate) my POV
im confused about which is supposed to be practiced.There are scriptures that seem to suggest polyamorous relationships are acceptable in the bible when you look at kings and other people.it looks like the original plan was for a monogamous relationship when you read genesis.can anyone explain..

First/second Commandment "Love God above all" + "Love thy neighbor as thyself".
Many people take "Love" to mean "inluding having sex". The first Commandment PROVES (declaring the second is like unto the first) that this is not true

People confuse the word "Love" used in the Bible in this Commandment ... understandable ... "to like sex" is not same as "to like Love"
 

Etritonakin

Well-Known Member
While one man marrying one woman is what SHOULD ideally be done for the good of families and society....

God ALLOWS what should not be done for a purpose.

It might seem strange, but allowing things to get messed up is part of how God teaches us. Experience of evil is used to eventually completely eradicate evil.

A good example is that of clean and unclean foods.
In Eden, they were essentially vegetarians -if not Vegans.
Afterward pretty much anything was allowed.
After that only some things.
Later, not only will humans not eat animals, but animals will not eat each other.

It made more "food" more readily available -but had adverse physical effects -as well as a positive overall psychological effect (people eventually becoming averse to harming and consuming animals)

God "gave the creation over to futility in hope".
 

Muffled

Jesus in me
im confused about which is supposed to be practiced.There are scriptures that seem to suggest polyamorous relationships are acceptable in the bible when you look at kings and other people.it looks like the original plan was for a monogamous relationship when you read genesis.can anyone explain..

I believe people are sinners so they opt ought of monogamy settling for something less good but not necessarily evil. Do you want to live in poverty become a vegetarian, lock yourself away from women in a monastery. God will allow it but does want better for us.
 

Duke_Leto

Active Member
Also, since we share about 98% of our dna with chimps, and chimps are promiscuous, our sex unbridled sex drive tends to encourage promiscuity. However, since that is so disruptive to human society because of how long it takes children to mature, most societies abandoned it as a model or sharply restricted it, regardless of religion.

Obviously, Christianity teaches only monogamy, or as one of my former professors called it, "monotony".

We share roughly the same amount of DNA with bonobos, who are even more promiscuous than chimps!
 

IndigoChild5559

Loving God and my neighbor as myself.
im confused about which is supposed to be practiced.There are scriptures that seem to suggest polyamorous relationships are acceptable in the bible when you look at kings and other people.it looks like the original plan was for a monogamous relationship when you read genesis.can anyone explain..
Let me ask you the same question that the medieval Rabbis asked. Can you give to more than one wife all that she needs? Can you provide for her all the material necessities of life for her and all her children? And what is even more important, can you give to her all the time for listening, for cuddling, for fixing dinner together, for sitting on the porch, for watching TV together, for helping all her children with their homework and going to their ballgames and dance recitals? And if you have the time for even that one wife, do you also have time for the second? Because, quite honestly, most men find they don't have the time and money and heart enough for the first wife, let alone another.

In the ancient cultures of the past, it was NOT true that every man had more than one wife. Only a very few VERY rich men had multiple wives, because THEY had the wealth with which to support them. So even back then, monogamy was the norm, polygamy was the exception to the rule.
 

IndigoChild5559

Loving God and my neighbor as myself.
We share roughly the same amount of DNA with bonobos, who are even more promiscuous than chimps!
The difference is, we have enough of a conscience to know better than to cheat. Our sense of justice and empathy is more developed than that of other primates.
 

IndigoChild5559

Loving God and my neighbor as myself.
It's not cheating when you agree to have an open relationship with your partner.
Societal values are based on what is best for the group, not what works for the exception to the rule.

The West, especially those who lean to the left, emphasizes an extreme individualism. This is a cultural value that should not be imposed on other cultures. And I would say that the West needs to re-examine the extremeness of its own position, and the relative worth of the value of community. Those on the right tend to have a greater sense of the worth of community and their values underscore this sense. There is, I think, a healthy balance. Things get awful when a culture goes too far one way or the other.
 

Milton Platt

Well-Known Member
But no multiple wife situations were happy.

In rare cases women could inherit. Job gave his daughters an inheritance with his sons.
There was also the first legal challenge in the Bible where there were no sons and the daughters of Zelophehad went to Moses and God said they were right and they should get an inheritance to carry on their father's name, this was further qualified to say they had to marry in their tribe to keep the inheritance land in the tribe.

Just because there are no happy polygamous marriages in the bible does not mean that there were no happy polygamous marriages.
 
Top