firedragon
Veteran Member
Theism and atheism are not religions. They are just terms used to say whether someone believes in a god or not.
Religion is the systematic practice of faith which is manifest through ritual and ceremonies. What rituals and ceremonies does one have to partake in to be an atheist?
The fourth point is incorrect because atheism says nothing about morality. What moral or ethical system does an atheist have to adhere to?
The fifth point is wrong as well. Neither theism nor atheism cause atrocities to happen. There has to be an extra set of religious or ideological beliefs that the person holds that leads to that.
I don't know why you are speaking just about the Bible here. Atheists also speak out about other faiths such as Islam, Judaism, Hinduism and numerous dangerous cults.
Your point that atheist speak out against religion therefore it is a religion makes no sense:
Does a person who speaks out against government have to be a part of a government?
Does a person need to be part of a secret society to speak out against a secret society?
Does someone who speaks out against a terrorist group have top be a terrorist themselves?
One doesn't have to be in the category of something to speak out against it. Atheists speak out against religion for various reasons even. A lot of atheists couldn't care less about religion and don't speak about it.
Who does this? 3 of those are dangerous cults and the second one is more complicated. Are you conflating Theism with Christianity as per that other thread?
So the concept of God made people explore nature. That doesn't mean that the concept is true. Science also cannot conclude that God definitely doesn't exist but just that certain concepts of God are false.
Circular reasoning here. You have to prove that everything was created in the first place before saying that people are observing a created object. Atheists who claim that there definitely is no God are committing the same fallacy that theists do, by jumping to conclusions on a matter that is unexaminable. Certainly the term God is used in the scientific community when contemplating various hypothesis for how the universe began such as Stephen Hawking does in a Brief History of Time. They should rather say that they do not know.
This is a tricky one. I think that all religions were necessary in the evolution of what society calls "morality" in that they established an order of morality that helped civilizations to stabilize and grow. This also begs the question as man has been religious for the majority of history. Religion is a natural step in man's social evolution so there wouldn't have been a time when man would have developed the moral code without religion. Judeo-Christian values certainly aren't necessary for a morality as we have had Confusionism, Jainism, Islam and many other religions that established a working morality. Humans are social creatures and all social creatures have a natural morality which makes them social in the first place and humans have genetic and psychological traits that govern certain actions that humans call moral and others that are provided through reason. But because of tribalism morality develops differently and this causes conflict.
you focus ion communism. What about Secular Humanism? You are also ignoring atheists who fight for peoples rights and would be against the atrocities of the USSR? Why are you cherry picking here?
Why are you so focused on Christianity here? Atheists also speak out against Islam and Hinduism and cults. In fact many atheists who are against Islam say that Christianity is OK and that we can live with it but that Islam is the main problem at its core. Also most of the atheist I have heard of who are against Christiainty are the ones in America where there are a lot of ignorant Christians who are bigots who want to take over government. In the Middle East most atheists are against Islam. In Russia, which was Russian Orthodox under the Tzar, atheists were against Christianity because it was the main religion. In India they are against Hinduism. It seems to be more about what religion is dominant in which region rather than attacking Christianity all over the world.
And again atheism is not a religion.
I dont agree with you on some points, but I agree with you on some other points. I mean in this same post. Yet, I honestly admire your manner of putting it and your thoughts no matter what.
I have a question for you. Do you think religion means "belief in a God"? Or in fact, let me put it this way. Do you think religion means "theism"?