Does God differentiate between "how I feel"
Example:
Person 1 Loves God through Jesus
Person 2 Loves God through Muhammad
Person 3 Loves God through Buddha
Person 4 Loves God through Humanity
Person 5 Loves God through living like Jesus (although he never heard of Jesus)
For example, I could imagine a scenario where someone rejects a revelation of truth and goodness
Just now, I am thinking about the First Commandment "Love God with all your heart". So all 5 "Love God" with all their heart, and additional, depending on the country/culture, they also Love a certain prophet and all the high values they put in practice (Love thy neighbor as thyself etc)
(When I was ca. 10 years old, I asked my mother a similar question. Certain thoughts are like a red line throughout my life)
However, I must leave all such judgements to God - there is absolutely no way I can know
I totally agree with that. I can never know, at least that is what I believe. The Universe is beyond my comprehension; God even more so.
I forgot the most important question when asking this type of questions:
What is your "picture" of God. No verses please, just your feeling when you are talking about God
(e.g.: When I talk about God ... I go blank, can't think of anything, no thoughts at all. Taking paper and pen I could write "The cause behind all This Mystery")