• Welcome to Religious Forums, a friendly forum to discuss all religions in a friendly surrounding.

    Your voice is missing! You will need to register to get access to the following site features:
    • Reply to discussions and create your own threads.
    • Our modern chat room. No add-ons or extensions required, just login and start chatting!
    • Access to private conversations with other members.

    We hope to see you as a part of our community soon!

Questions...

Jos

Well-Known Member
That might prove challenging. If He uncreates you upon your request, then you would have never existed to make that request.

Ciao

- viole
A different timeline of events where I never existed would have occurred... is that what you mean?
 

Jos

Well-Known Member
Except God already has it. If you already have something there's no wanting involved.

You want entertainment because you are not being entertained. If you are being entertain, there's no want or need for it. You don't want or need what you already have.
Right that's what I said but why does God want anything considering He has everything met within Himself? The Bible states that He wants relationship, glory, worship etc. why does He want any of that if He's perfectly fulfilled within Himself?
 

Jos

Well-Known Member
Once we define God as:

1. God exists.
2. God is omnipotent.
3. God is omniscient.
4. God is omnipresent.
5. God is omnibenevolent.

Then learning about God is just a matter of formal reasoning, like developing theorems and proofs in geometry or mathematics.

However, the fact in question, that no action can take place without a period of time in which it occurs, is really more a question of physics than of theology.
Exactly, how can God act if He's outside of space and time?
 

Jos

Well-Known Member
I don't follow your reasoning. God would need some sentient being outside of Himself in order to be perceived as God by something other than Himself, but that has nothing to do with His nature of being God itself.
Never mind, I made a mistake.
 

Deeje

Avid Bible Student
Premium Member
Don't other denominations with different interpretations say the same thing about you and your interpretation?

Yes, and I was raised with them.....I did the comparison and got blown away by how much of what was in the Bible got swept under the rug. When you let the Bible speak, it's message is loud and clear. And it's incredibly simple.

But we have to dismiss everything we were ever taught and start over. Why? Because God's enemy has an empire that he has built over thousands of years, promoting half truths and lies to win people over to his side and taking them away from God. (Matthew 7:13-14) The road to life is "cramped and narrow", not because God makes it so, but because God's adversary keeps planting land mines. He also has many temptations that are designed to lead us off that path. The easy way leads to death but most people choose it because they don't want to do it tough. It's our fallen human nature to choose the easier road.

As far as I see it, they only knew or became aware that what they did was wrong after they ate of the tree of the knowledge of good and evil which implies that they didn't know that eating of the tree of good and evil was wrong.

Not so. The tree of the knowledge of good and evil did not mean that they didn't know evil existed....they had just never experienced it. And if they had remained obedient, they would never have done so. The tree was a small test of their obedience and their appreciation of the fact that as a good parent, they had to trust their father to tell them what was good and what was evil. That made the tree about his sovereignty....his right to set appropriate limits, which in this case would not have impacted on them in any negative way.

So why does evil exist at all? In all of creation there are equal opposites. Good can't exist without its equal opposite. It was the only thing God was going to keep from his children.

But if God has everything already then why does He desire worship or love of all things especially given that were fallible unimportant mortals and given that He is the source of perfect love?

Take parents as an example. God presents himself as a father figure and treats his human children accordingly. In the animal kingdom we see many 'programmed' responses that we call instinct. Humans alone exercise their free will, rather than being fully programmed to perform their function. We respond naturally to any given situation but we have intellect that can keep our emotions in check. We choose to love based on our personal evaluation of a person, and our loyalty must be earned, likewise our respect. God never wanted robots who could not choose to express appropriate responses in any given situation. He wanted to earn that love by being the best father he could be. Look at the start he gave our first parents......yet someone suggested that it wasn't enough. Now it seems nothing ever is.

No I haven't but it'll be pretty surprising.

It's a very revealing exercise....just using scripture, not doctrine.

Are you up for an in depth evaluation?

I already have a long list of questions.

Fire away. But try doing it one topic at a time. You are more likely to remember things if you organise your questions into topics.

There are many points of view here. Consider them and see what you think.

Yeah but the peace I want also comes with no expectations, demands etc. God expects and demands worship, love etc and I don't think I can find peace in someone's nagging expectations and demands.

Go back to Genesis and read the demands that God made to his human children with regard to worship. What were his expectations of them? Where will you find nagging or anything unreasonable ever demanded? Start there and build a picture as a continuing story.

Yeah I guess

Not something you are passionate about eh? Sounds boring actually, especially when you have no ambition. I'm sure you have something you can be passionate about....you just haven't found it yet.

Yeah I guess but even then that's still not enough to make me want to continue existing.

Don't give up...it might be closer than you think.

Ready when you are. I am in Australia, so I might not be awake when you are....please consider the time zone difference. It's morning here now and I will be coming and going all day.
 

Jos

Well-Known Member
I am pointing out creationists are not faithfully representing anything: neither Science nor Christ
So evolution is true?
Your profile and OP indicates that you are agnostic, but I think what you actually seem like to me is a little of both agnostic and modern Christian owing to a very physical view of God.
Yeah you're probably right.
We disagree. Creationists believe God physically created the world and can be proven to exist through physical means
I don't blame them though since the Genesis account indicates that.
through miracles and through complex arguments about Bible verses starting with the arbitrary assumption of a perfect Bible straight from heaven favoring Christians over other people. One biblical author says "God is no respecter of persons," but a physical God is and also one that favors Christians.
You don't believe in miracles?
You don't believe the Bible to be the perfect, inspired Word of God? Why?
Why wouldn't God favor Christians? Aren't they His people?
They adore a God that is invisible and nonphysical and which exists in everyone. In addition the LORD is a covenant that is an expression of God much like the Bible is an expression of God or a person is an expression of God or the Holy Spirit is an expression of God
So God is in everyone and everything?
How does a person adore God if not by treating others mercifully, doing justly and walking humbly? They may sing to the LORD, but that singing must be a commitment to a life of peace and waiting upon the LORD. To these people who are oppressed and frequently overrun by enemies, their singing to the LORD is truly a sacrifice not just a game or a pleasant noise. Its not like the adoration of Krishna. Its a purposeful, intensive, creative act, a promise.
So they're wrong to stand up in church and sing and dance and clap and stuff?
My view in a nutshell is that God is the rejection of gods,
Huh? How can God be the rejection of gods?
 

Jos

Well-Known Member
*One* definition doesnt encompass the entire word, does it?

What if Jehovah ‘wanted to give’? Being called “a God of love”.... love moves one to share what one has. Aren’t you glad to be living?
But He was already sharing it within Himself through the Trinity
 

Nakosis

Non-Binary Physicalist
Premium Member
Right that's what I said but why does God want anything considering He has everything met within Himself? The Bible states that He wants relationship, glory, worship etc. why does He want any of that if He's perfectly fulfilled within Himself?

The Bible is from a human perspective. Humans trying to express the divine. Trying to communicate the divine in humans terms is awkward at best. Trying to describe something man is unfamiliar with in familiar terms creates a paradox sometimes.
 

Deeje

Avid Bible Student
Premium Member
But He was already sharing it within Himself through the Trinity

What if he is not a trinity? Did you know that only Christendom and paganism have trinities? The God of Israel, and therefore Jesus's God, was a single entity. (Deuteronomy 6:4) The trinity is a product of apostasy, making the son a substitute God, breaking the first Commandment. (Exodus 20:3) The trinity as church doctrine did not exist till the 4th century.
 

savagewind

Veteran Member
Premium Member
What if he is not a trinity? Did you know that only Christendom and paganism have trinities? The God of Israel, and therefore Jesus's God, was a single entity. (Deuteronomy 6:4) The trinity is a product of apostasy, making the son a substitute God, breaking the first Commandment. (Exodus 20:3) The trinity as church doctrine did not exist till the 4th century.
Wrong again! We know Jehovah God THROUGH chosen ones. Heads up! Each time God uses a person or a group of people God's not single. To the Earth, God has never been single.
 
Top