Koldo
Outstanding Member
Yes both sides can have good reasoning for their position. Life is not black and white it is usually pretty nuanced. There can be reasonable disagreement on both sides. Almost all supreme court decisions are congruent with the justices political leanings. That does not mean they do not have a good valid and sound reasons for their decisions. Please show they did not base their decision on what they wrote in the opinion.
It is impossible to consistently vote according to your political leanings if you are not aiming for that. Otherwise, that entails that their leanings were reached after throughly examination of the law (which we know is not the case) or that by chance they happen to agree with the legal arguments of the side they already happened to support.
Last edited: