maro
muslimah
The story begins with Adam....
The story of Adam can be found in different verses of the Qur'an:
Verse 30 begins the story of man. we will proceed slowly here line by line since this have a strong bearing to our questions.The ancient qur'anic commentators would endorse such an approach , for they used to speak of the ijaz of the scripture_its inimitable eloquence that combines both the most beautiful and yet the most economical expression. They would advice us not to rush hastily , but to allow every verse ,every word ,every sound to penetrate our heats and minds in order to reap its greatest possible benefit .otherwise ,we would deprive ourselves of essential keys to unlocking truths buried deep within us.
[2:30] Behold, thy Lord said to the angels: "I will create a vicegerent on earth." They said: "Wilt Thou place therein one who will make mischief therein and shed blood? Whilst we do celebrate Thy praise and glorify Thy holy (name)?" He said: "I know what ye know not."
The opening scene is heaven as god informs the angels that he is about to place man on earth. Adam, the first man , has not yet appeared. from the verses that follow ,it's clear at this point of the story Adam is free of any wrongdoing . Nevertheless , God plans to place him and his descendants on Earth (6:165 - 27:62 - 35:39) in the role of vicegerent or vicar ' khalifa ' . There is no insinuation here that earthly life is to serve as punishment . The word 'khalifa' means 'a vicar' 'a delegate ' ' a representative ', ' a pesron authorized to act for others ' .therefore it is appears that man is meant to represent and act on behalf of God in some sense. The angels' reply is both fascinating and disturbing .In essence ,it asks ' why create and place on earth one who has it within his nature to corrupt and commit terrible crimes ? Why create this being who will be the cause and recepient of great suffering? it's obvious that the angels here are refering to the very nature of mankind , since Adam , in the quran , turns out to be one of God's elect and not guilty of any major crime.The question is considered all the more signifiacant when we consider who and from where it comes.
When we think of angels , we imagine peaceful ,pure and holy creatures , in perfect and joyous submission to God. They represent the model to which we should aspire .In our daily speech ,we reserve the word angel to the noblest of our species . Mother Theresa is often called an ' angel of mercy ' by the press . Our image of an angel is of a perfect human being .This is what gives the angels' question such force . for it asks : why create this patently corrupt and flawed being when it's within your power to create us ? ,thus they say ' while we celebarate your praises and glorify your holiness? ' .Their question is given further amplification by the fact that it originates in heaven ,for what possible purpose could be served by placing man in an enviroment where he could freely excercise his worst criminal inclinations ? . All of this considerations culminate in the obvious objection : why not place man with a suitable nature in heaven from the start ? . We are not even one verse into the story of man and we have already confronted our (the atheists') main complaint ,and it's put in the mouths of angels.
The verse ends with not an explanation ,but a reminder of god's superior knowledge , and hence the implication that man's earthly life is part of a grand design .Many western scholars have remarked that the remark ' I know what you don't know ' merely dismisses the angels' question. However ,as the sequence of passages will show ,this is not the case at all.
Our initial encounter with the quran has been anything but pleasant ; it has been distressful and irritating .Either the author is unaware of possible philosophical problems and objections or he is deliberately provoking us with them ! we are a mere 37 verses into the quran and our anxiety and resentment has been aroused to a fever pitch. we ask : " why indeed sunject us to earthly suffering ? why not remove us to heaven or place us there from the first ? why must we struggle to survive ? why create us so vulnerable and self destructive ? why must we suffer broken hearts and broken dreams ,lost lovers and lost youth , crises and catastrophes ? why must we experience pains of birth and pains of death ? why? " we beg in our frustration ." why ? " we plead in all our sorrow and emptiness "why ? " we insist in our anguish " why ?" we scream out to the heavens ."why ?" we plead with the angels "if you are there ,and you hear us ,tell us ,why create man ? "
We move now to verse 31 where we find that the quran continues to explore the angels' question
(2:31) And He taught Adam the names – all of them. Then He showed them to the angels and said, "Inform Me of the names of these, if you are truthful."
Clearly ,the angels' question is being addresses in this verse. Adam's capacities for learning and acquiring knowledge ,his ability to be taught ,are the focus of this initial response . The next verse demonstarates the angels' inferiority in this repect. Special emphasis is placed on man's ability to name ,to represent by verbal symbols " all things" that enter his concious mind : his thoughts ,Fears and hopes ,in short , all that he can percieve or concieve. This allows man to communicate his experience and knowledge on a relatively high level ,compared to other creatures about him ,and gives all human learning a preeminent cumulative quality .In several places in the quran ,this gift to mankind is singled out as one of the greatest bounties bestowed on him by god
(2:32)They said, "Exalted are You; we have no knowledge except what You have taught us. Indeed, it is You who is the Knowing, the Wise."
In this verse the angels plead their inability to perform such a task ,for, as they plainly state ,it would demand knowledge and wisdom beyond their capacity .They maintain that its perfermance would ,of course ,be easy for god as his knowledge and wisdom is supreme ,but the same couldn't be expected from them .In the next verse we will discover that Adam posseses the level of intelligence nessecary to accomplich the task,and hence, his knowledge and wisdom are less than God's ,yet greater than the angels .
The story of Adam can be found in different verses of the Qur'an:
- Qur'an 2:30–39
- Qur'an 3:59
- Qur'an 4:1
- Qur'an 7:11–25
- Qur'an 7:189
- Qur'an 15:26–36
- Qur'an 17:61
- Qur'an 18:50
- Qur'an 20:115–126
Verse 30 begins the story of man. we will proceed slowly here line by line since this have a strong bearing to our questions.The ancient qur'anic commentators would endorse such an approach , for they used to speak of the ijaz of the scripture_its inimitable eloquence that combines both the most beautiful and yet the most economical expression. They would advice us not to rush hastily , but to allow every verse ,every word ,every sound to penetrate our heats and minds in order to reap its greatest possible benefit .otherwise ,we would deprive ourselves of essential keys to unlocking truths buried deep within us.
[2:30] Behold, thy Lord said to the angels: "I will create a vicegerent on earth." They said: "Wilt Thou place therein one who will make mischief therein and shed blood? Whilst we do celebrate Thy praise and glorify Thy holy (name)?" He said: "I know what ye know not."
The opening scene is heaven as god informs the angels that he is about to place man on earth. Adam, the first man , has not yet appeared. from the verses that follow ,it's clear at this point of the story Adam is free of any wrongdoing . Nevertheless , God plans to place him and his descendants on Earth (6:165 - 27:62 - 35:39) in the role of vicegerent or vicar ' khalifa ' . There is no insinuation here that earthly life is to serve as punishment . The word 'khalifa' means 'a vicar' 'a delegate ' ' a representative ', ' a pesron authorized to act for others ' .therefore it is appears that man is meant to represent and act on behalf of God in some sense. The angels' reply is both fascinating and disturbing .In essence ,it asks ' why create and place on earth one who has it within his nature to corrupt and commit terrible crimes ? Why create this being who will be the cause and recepient of great suffering? it's obvious that the angels here are refering to the very nature of mankind , since Adam , in the quran , turns out to be one of God's elect and not guilty of any major crime.The question is considered all the more signifiacant when we consider who and from where it comes.
When we think of angels , we imagine peaceful ,pure and holy creatures , in perfect and joyous submission to God. They represent the model to which we should aspire .In our daily speech ,we reserve the word angel to the noblest of our species . Mother Theresa is often called an ' angel of mercy ' by the press . Our image of an angel is of a perfect human being .This is what gives the angels' question such force . for it asks : why create this patently corrupt and flawed being when it's within your power to create us ? ,thus they say ' while we celebarate your praises and glorify your holiness? ' .Their question is given further amplification by the fact that it originates in heaven ,for what possible purpose could be served by placing man in an enviroment where he could freely excercise his worst criminal inclinations ? . All of this considerations culminate in the obvious objection : why not place man with a suitable nature in heaven from the start ? . We are not even one verse into the story of man and we have already confronted our (the atheists') main complaint ,and it's put in the mouths of angels.
The verse ends with not an explanation ,but a reminder of god's superior knowledge , and hence the implication that man's earthly life is part of a grand design .Many western scholars have remarked that the remark ' I know what you don't know ' merely dismisses the angels' question. However ,as the sequence of passages will show ,this is not the case at all.
Our initial encounter with the quran has been anything but pleasant ; it has been distressful and irritating .Either the author is unaware of possible philosophical problems and objections or he is deliberately provoking us with them ! we are a mere 37 verses into the quran and our anxiety and resentment has been aroused to a fever pitch. we ask : " why indeed sunject us to earthly suffering ? why not remove us to heaven or place us there from the first ? why must we struggle to survive ? why create us so vulnerable and self destructive ? why must we suffer broken hearts and broken dreams ,lost lovers and lost youth , crises and catastrophes ? why must we experience pains of birth and pains of death ? why? " we beg in our frustration ." why ? " we plead in all our sorrow and emptiness "why ? " we insist in our anguish " why ?" we scream out to the heavens ."why ?" we plead with the angels "if you are there ,and you hear us ,tell us ,why create man ? "
We move now to verse 31 where we find that the quran continues to explore the angels' question
(2:31) And He taught Adam the names – all of them. Then He showed them to the angels and said, "Inform Me of the names of these, if you are truthful."
Clearly ,the angels' question is being addresses in this verse. Adam's capacities for learning and acquiring knowledge ,his ability to be taught ,are the focus of this initial response . The next verse demonstarates the angels' inferiority in this repect. Special emphasis is placed on man's ability to name ,to represent by verbal symbols " all things" that enter his concious mind : his thoughts ,Fears and hopes ,in short , all that he can percieve or concieve. This allows man to communicate his experience and knowledge on a relatively high level ,compared to other creatures about him ,and gives all human learning a preeminent cumulative quality .In several places in the quran ,this gift to mankind is singled out as one of the greatest bounties bestowed on him by god
(2:32)They said, "Exalted are You; we have no knowledge except what You have taught us. Indeed, it is You who is the Knowing, the Wise."
In this verse the angels plead their inability to perform such a task ,for, as they plainly state ,it would demand knowledge and wisdom beyond their capacity .They maintain that its perfermance would ,of course ,be easy for god as his knowledge and wisdom is supreme ,but the same couldn't be expected from them .In the next verse we will discover that Adam posseses the level of intelligence nessecary to accomplich the task,and hence, his knowledge and wisdom are less than God's ,yet greater than the angels .
Last edited: