Being the bookish sort, I resorted to reading books, especially the primary texts. haha, actually I wasn't looking for something that was a little more "me" as I was an atheist at the time.
But I think there's quite an advantage here, in that you can find real people who really practice their religion to talk too.
What kinds of things were you looking for in a religion? A sense of community? Some structure for your life? Connection with the divine or nature? What you end up with will depend on what's important in your life. I won't shade the truth, ZH, you will have a difficult time with most of the "major" religions, but you probably already know that anyway. :hug:
Ultimately, search until you find what it is that you believe to be true. You may not like everything about whatever religion you find (hey, I don't), but who ever gets everything their way? And be patient and persistent. It could take years, even a lifetime, but look under every rock you can find. What you need is out there.