Only Reason
Member
Refuting the incoherence of Hinduism's "Karma and Rebirth Cycle" can easily be done with pure reasoning alone:
"My dear heroic King, due to my past sincere service to the Lord, I could remember everything of my past life even while in the body of a deer. Because I am aware of the falldown in my past life, I always keep myself separate from the association of ordinary men. Being afraid of their bad, materialistic association, I wander alone unnoticed by others."
~ Srimad Bhagavatam 5.12.15
But before I begin, don't bring up the idea of caste system here as I get it, it's yet another big reason why all those hindus in India or third world countries are leaving hinduism in droves. And I wouldn't blame you on that notion alone. But it's for another topic altogether although it might correlate in that same "unfair" aspect of Hinduism in this topic also.
And yes, if you know the Soul Catching Net theory,. It's heavily derived from Hinduism and is almost exactly the same concept. Just with way more emphasis on the matrix and there's definitely no animal reincarnation due to bad karma dogma. Let's begin.
Their belief of "Karma" was a human construct invented with the purpose of explaining why people suffer more than others and in different ways on earth. So the hindu concept of Karma was invented. And it goes along the lines of this; Humans must be suffering more than others because they have acquired bad karma in a previous life which dictated what their negative consequences will be in their future reincarnations.
The funny thing is, it's pretty much like trying to win the lottery. You rack that lottery stick but you also insert these mythical "bad karma tokens" into the machine at the same time as well which will make you have a greater percentage chance of not having an easier going life in the next one and so the odds will stack up against you that much more.
Not only that but you literally need to reach perfection without a single bit of bad karma and only attaining good karma in your entire life in order to escape this cycle of constant rebirth. Any bit of bad karma will restart the rebirth cycle. Since we are all imperfect beings with our own natural flaws this is an impossibility as no one is perfect in this world.
It really is a prison cycle of rebirth in other words, and seems like a fate worse than the muslim and Christian concept of hell. Yeah, I am giving you guys accolades on that one. And when you really think about it, the whole belief makes no sense for a really good reason which I will explain… even with basic concepts of mathematics!
Humans have finite intelligence due to their brains and are still therefore limited in their memory and intelligence and will never be able to understand everything. No amount of finite numbers could reach infinity mathematically speaking. Therefore, it is an impossibility that you can infinitely remember everything with a finite brain let alone understand how everything works. These basic mathematical concepts undeniably contradict the Hindu "Srimad Bhagavatam scripture 5.12.15" that you can remember everything of your past lives in your future ones. Theoretically, it's actually an impossibility. And in all honesty, do you REALLY remember exactly where you were before you were born?
Hypothetically speaking, you can look at it like this; GOD = infinity and humans = finite. Since the soul is of god and is not of the body, then when the soul departs, it becomes infinitely boundless in every aspect including intelligence once again. But when it is confined to the finite brain of the human body again, it loses its ability to understand everything.
And so with all of that said and done we can now see how the karma and rebirth cycle is working 100% against the individual in EVERY new rebirth. And so this begs the question, how can anyone on this earth correct their bad karma in their new reincarnated state of being if you can never remember everything of your past life related to what good or bad things you did?
This shows us how unjust, despairing and highly cruel this vicious cycle really is. This belief system is dangerous because it counts on you NOT being able to figure out what bad things you did in the past since you are at all times FINITE while on the earth and not infinitely complex.
The matter only gets worse if you so happen to be reincarnated as an animal. Luckily, this is all just a myth. But a cruel one to say the least.
Thank you,
ED
"My dear heroic King, due to my past sincere service to the Lord, I could remember everything of my past life even while in the body of a deer. Because I am aware of the falldown in my past life, I always keep myself separate from the association of ordinary men. Being afraid of their bad, materialistic association, I wander alone unnoticed by others."
~ Srimad Bhagavatam 5.12.15
But before I begin, don't bring up the idea of caste system here as I get it, it's yet another big reason why all those hindus in India or third world countries are leaving hinduism in droves. And I wouldn't blame you on that notion alone. But it's for another topic altogether although it might correlate in that same "unfair" aspect of Hinduism in this topic also.
And yes, if you know the Soul Catching Net theory,. It's heavily derived from Hinduism and is almost exactly the same concept. Just with way more emphasis on the matrix and there's definitely no animal reincarnation due to bad karma dogma. Let's begin.
Their belief of "Karma" was a human construct invented with the purpose of explaining why people suffer more than others and in different ways on earth. So the hindu concept of Karma was invented. And it goes along the lines of this; Humans must be suffering more than others because they have acquired bad karma in a previous life which dictated what their negative consequences will be in their future reincarnations.
The funny thing is, it's pretty much like trying to win the lottery. You rack that lottery stick but you also insert these mythical "bad karma tokens" into the machine at the same time as well which will make you have a greater percentage chance of not having an easier going life in the next one and so the odds will stack up against you that much more.
Not only that but you literally need to reach perfection without a single bit of bad karma and only attaining good karma in your entire life in order to escape this cycle of constant rebirth. Any bit of bad karma will restart the rebirth cycle. Since we are all imperfect beings with our own natural flaws this is an impossibility as no one is perfect in this world.
It really is a prison cycle of rebirth in other words, and seems like a fate worse than the muslim and Christian concept of hell. Yeah, I am giving you guys accolades on that one. And when you really think about it, the whole belief makes no sense for a really good reason which I will explain… even with basic concepts of mathematics!
Humans have finite intelligence due to their brains and are still therefore limited in their memory and intelligence and will never be able to understand everything. No amount of finite numbers could reach infinity mathematically speaking. Therefore, it is an impossibility that you can infinitely remember everything with a finite brain let alone understand how everything works. These basic mathematical concepts undeniably contradict the Hindu "Srimad Bhagavatam scripture 5.12.15" that you can remember everything of your past lives in your future ones. Theoretically, it's actually an impossibility. And in all honesty, do you REALLY remember exactly where you were before you were born?
Hypothetically speaking, you can look at it like this; GOD = infinity and humans = finite. Since the soul is of god and is not of the body, then when the soul departs, it becomes infinitely boundless in every aspect including intelligence once again. But when it is confined to the finite brain of the human body again, it loses its ability to understand everything.
And so with all of that said and done we can now see how the karma and rebirth cycle is working 100% against the individual in EVERY new rebirth. And so this begs the question, how can anyone on this earth correct their bad karma in their new reincarnated state of being if you can never remember everything of your past life related to what good or bad things you did?
This shows us how unjust, despairing and highly cruel this vicious cycle really is. This belief system is dangerous because it counts on you NOT being able to figure out what bad things you did in the past since you are at all times FINITE while on the earth and not infinitely complex.
The matter only gets worse if you so happen to be reincarnated as an animal. Luckily, this is all just a myth. But a cruel one to say the least.
Thank you,
ED
