• Welcome to Religious Forums, a friendly forum to discuss all religions in a friendly surrounding.

    Your voice is missing! You will need to register to get access to the following site features:
    • Reply to discussions and create your own threads.
    • Our modern chat room. No add-ons or extensions required, just login and start chatting!
    • Access to private conversations with other members.

    We hope to see you as a part of our community soon!

Why did christianity win out (from a secular / historical perspective)?

vijeno

Member
Christianity is the majority religion today, and has been for 1700 years (or so).

Something has to be special about it... or not?

From the christian perspective, the answer is easy - it was god's plan all along, so of course christianity is the winner.

If you don't believe in it, then there must be other explanations. What are they?
 

an anarchist

Your local anarchist.
I think perhaps Christianity offers a lot for something as ”cheap” as faith.

If you give the Christian deity your faith, He will forgive you all of your wrongs and you will spend an eternity in paradise. Oh yea, the complete inverse if you don’t have faith.

So, it offers an individual freedom from death without any skill. And the belief that you are free from death is a comforting one.

There are many reasons why Christianity came out on top. I just shared what I think is one factor.
 

Glaurung

Denizen of Niflheim
The promise of Christianity is universal. It posits that anyone who accepts Christ and strives to live a moral life will obtain a salvific relationship with God. We take such notions for granted these days but in the ancient world the notion that every person had value in the eyes of the divine was a radical claim.

Paganism usually made no such promises. Egyptian religion (for instance) could not even guarantee an afterlife, unless you were rich enough to afford mummification and all the necessary spells. (A Book of the Dead). Greek and Roman religion did not offer all that much either. Christianity offered everyone hope. It was not a religion tied to the privileges of birth and class.
 
Last edited:

Nimos

Well-Known Member
Christianity is the majority religion today, and has been for 1700 years (or so).

Something has to be special about it... or not?

From the christian perspective, the answer is easy - it was god's plan all along, so of course christianity is the winner.

If you don't believe in it, then there must be other explanations. What are they?
Because it offered the best explanation at the time. Science as we know it hadn't been invented. Also, religions have a lot of power built into them that can be exploited, which makes them very powerful, political.
 

Twilight Hue

Twilight, not bright nor dark, good nor bad.
Christianity is the majority religion today, and has been for 1700 years (or so).

Something has to be special about it... or not?

From the christian perspective, the answer is easy - it was god's plan all along, so of course christianity is the winner.

If you don't believe in it, then there must be other explanations. What are they?
Your joking.

Christianity isn't the majority religion.

They have the worlds largest group at 31%, but are not even close to being the world's dominant religion which comprises of 69% of the rest of the world's religious who are not Christian.

Plus since 2017, a pew report shows it's declining even further, so those dominant figures are apt to go down even further, particularly in Europe as people leave Christianity for other religions or just putting it down outright.



I don't think 31% is anything significant to brag about.
 
Last edited:

Twilight Hue

Twilight, not bright nor dark, good nor bad.
Because it offered the best explanation at the time. Science as we know it hadn't been invented. Also, religions have a lot of power built into them that can be exploited, which makes them very powerful, political.
With advances in technology and discovery explaining more and more as time goes on, I'm sure Christianity, as with many theistic religions , will eventually become a minority in terms of group size as people slowely but surely realize Christianity isn't exactly what it claims to be.
 

TagliatelliMonster

Veteran Member
Christianity is the majority religion today, and has been for 1700 years (or so).

Something has to be special about it... or not?

From the christian perspective, the answer is easy - it was god's plan all along, so of course christianity is the winner.

If you don't believe in it, then there must be other explanations. What are they?
My theory is that it "won" because it's a religion that appeals to the weak and poor coupled with it being fairly "easy" to achieve "salvation".
That made it "easy" to make the masses, who largely were poor and weak, follow it. It also provided a handy tool for the elite to keep the masses in line.
 

Twilight Hue

Twilight, not bright nor dark, good nor bad.
Because it offered the best explanation at the time. Science as we know it hadn't been invented. Also, religions have a lot of power built into them that can be exploited, which makes them very powerful, political.
With advances in technology and discovery explaining more and more as time goes on, I'm sure Christianity, as with many theistic religions , will eventually become a minority in terms of group size as people slowely but surely realize Christianity isn't exactly what it claims to be.
 

Nimos

Well-Known Member
With advances in technology and discovery explaining more and more as time goes on, I'm sure Christianity, as with many theistic religions , will eventually become a minority in terms of group size as people slowely but surely realize Christianity isn't exactly what it claims to be.
Maybe, I think it's difficult to say.

I do think that religion will change in nature as we have seen over many years already and maybe become more of a "spiritual" thing. Also, people might turn away from technology and modern societies and seek back to nature more, once we eventually become tired of AIs and robots :D
 

Kfox

Well-Known Member
Christianity is the majority religion today, and has been for 1700 years (or so).

Something has to be special about it... or not?

From the christian perspective, the answer is easy - it was god's plan all along, so of course christianity is the winner.

If you don't believe in it, then there must be other explanations. What are they?
Christians had the most wealth and the better technology and were able to use that wealth and technology to influence others.
 

Colt

Well-Known Member
Christianity is the majority religion today, and has been for 1700 years (or so).

Something has to be special about it... or not?

From the christian perspective, the answer is easy - it was god's plan all along, so of course christianity is the winner.

If you don't believe in it, then there must be other explanations. What are they?
Christianity promises salvation from sin, from self, sanctity.

"Christianity came into favor in Rome at a time when there was great contention between the vigorous teachings of the Stoics and the salvation promises of the mystery cults. Christianity came with refreshing comfort and liberating power to a spiritually hungry people whose language had no word for “unselfishness.”

That which gave greatest power to Christianity was the way its believers lived lives of service and even the way they died for their faith during the earlier times of drastic persecution.

The teaching regarding Christ’s love for children soon put an end to the widespread practice of exposing children to death when they were not wanted, particularly girl babies.

The early plan of Christian worship was largely taken over from the Jewish synagogue, modified by the Mithraic ritual; later on, much pagan pageantry was added. The backbone of the early Christian church consisted of Christianized Greek proselytes to Judaism.

The second century after Christ was the best time in all the world’s history for a good religion to make progress in the Western world. During the first century Christianity had prepared itself, by struggle and compromise, to take root and rapidly spread. Christianity adopted the emperor; later, he adopted Christianity. This was a great age for the spread of a new religion. There was religious liberty; travel was universal and thought was untrammeled." UB 1955
 

Saint Frankenstein

Wanderer From Afar
Premium Member
Because it teaches the equality of all before God, including stigmatized groups such as slaves and lepers, who were thought to be cursed. It provided hope and help to groups that were previously nobodies in society. They were the best at practicing charity, as well, which was viewed embarrassingly by the Pagan Roman authorities.
 

Saint Frankenstein

Wanderer From Afar
Premium Member
Strings attached charity of Christians prior to socialism which is slowly replacing Christianity in my view.
What are you talking about? Christians have been practicing charity for all, regardless of religion, since the early days of it. Even today, the most you might be expected to give is a few minutes of time for a prayer. I've gotten tons of help from churches and Christian groups over the years, and never had to do anything more than sit through a prayer before eating.
 

MikeF

Well-Known Member
Premium Member
Perhaps it is due to having a great marketing and sales team at a crucial point in history.
 
Top