• Welcome to Religious Forums, a friendly forum to discuss all religions in a friendly surrounding.

    Your voice is missing! You will need to register to get access to the following site features:
    • Reply to discussions and create your own threads.
    • Our modern chat room. No add-ons or extensions required, just login and start chatting!
    • Access to private conversations with other members.

    We hope to see you as a part of our community soon!

Charlie Hebdo to attack Muslims again

TagliatelliMonster

Veteran Member
We was talking about Islam, right?
In Christianity, Jesus is seen as Gods son, nothing wrong with that to me
And god himself.

I thought you were pro blasphemy laws concerning all religions, so that nobody gets to be offended no matter the religion.

The christian position concerning Jesus is considered blasphemy in Islam.

So now, you have a decision to make.

Either you make christian belief illegal, or you allow blasphemy in context of islam.

What will it be?

hey, you dug yourself into this mess... time to crawl out.
 

Spirit of Light

Be who ever you want
What about buddhists stating that there is no god, or that ideas about god are delusional.
Do they get the chop ?

Weren’t you a Buddhist last year ?
Not from my girlfriend. And I don't see extremists as true Muslims, because they do not act calm from within
 

Howard Is

Lucky Mud
LOL, I was talking about the idea itself in how insulting may has a bad effect on you.

Of course we are all human. Well, I’m more than 97% human. :alien:
And that is the point.
One responsibility we have to one another is to develop perspective and patience , so that we don’t go ballistic if we feel offended.
 

Howard Is

Lucky Mud
Not from my girlfriend. And I don't see extremists as true Muslims, because they do not act calm from within

My question was about whether or not buddhism is blasphemy against Islam.
No god. No paradise. No holy laws.
Isn’t that blasphemous ?
 

Spirit of Light

Be who ever you want
And god himself.

I thought you were pro blasphemy laws concerning all religions, so that nobody gets to be offended no matter the religion.

The christian position concerning Jesus is considered blasphemy in Islam.

So now, you have a decision to make.

Either you make christian belief illegal, or you allow blasphemy in context of islam.

What will it be?

hey, you dug yourself into this mess... time to crawl out.
It is no problem for Christians to follow their teaching and no problem for Muslims to follow their teaching.
It is not blasphemy for a Christian to follow their teaching, not is it blasphemy to be an muslim and follow Islam.
I have not said Islam is the only right way, you already know my view is not that narrow.
 

Spirit of Light

Be who ever you want
My question was about whether or not buddhism is blasphemy against Islam.
No god. No paradise. No holy laws.
Isn’t that blasphemous ?
A Buddhist can follow Buddhism no problem. That should not worry an muslim at all.
In a discussion they would say they see it different, but no need to claim one view is better then the others, even I know that happens within the extremists parts of religions.
 

Spirit of Light

Be who ever you want
The definition of Islam
The root of the word Islam, silm, refers to "making peace, being in a mutually peaceful environment, greetings, rescue, safety, being secure, finding peace, reaching salvation and well being or being far from danger, attaining goodness, comfort and favor, keeping away from troubles and disasters, submitting the self and obeying, respect, being far from wrong." The "submitting the self and obeying" here means "submitting to justice and righteousness in order to reach peace and safety and being in a peaceful environment by one's free will." In fact, salaam and salaamat, mean "to reach salvation," and their rubai form (with four radical letters) aslama means "submitted, became Muslim, and made peace." "Islam" as either a noun or a verb with these meanings is mentioned in many verses in the Qur'an
 

TagliatelliMonster

Veteran Member
It is no problem for Christians to follow their teaching and no problem for Muslims to follow their teaching.
It is not blasphemy for a Christian to follow their teaching, not is it blasphemy to be an muslim and follow Islam.
I have not said Islam is the only right way, you already know my view is not that narrow.

But everything you say on the topic is all about trumping up islamic sensitivities while playing down non-islamic sensitivities.

Let's continue to pile on, shall we?

Yoga = considered blasphemous in islam
Expressing an atheist or secular point of view on anything = blasphemous in islam.

So I guess the western governments should therefor transform into islamic theocracies, to ensure that no secular viewpoints are expressed?
 

Spirit of Light

Be who ever you want
But everything you say on the topic is all about trumping up islamic sensitivities while playing down non-islamic sensitivities.

Let's continue to pile on, shall we?

Yoga = considered blasphemous in islam
Expressing an atheist or secular point of view on anything = blasphemous in islam.

So I guess the western governments should therefor transform into islamic theocracies, to ensure that no secular viewpoints are expressed?
I have not said such thing at all,
 

FearGod

Freedom Of Mind
Are the also insulting Macron in the quoted cover?


Cartoons don't insult. They make a point through satirical visualisation.
The action "to insult" and the effect of "feeling insulted" are not the same thing.

But there isn't a point in insulting religions through cartoons, it's just nonsense.
If people reject it then the magazine will find much more important subjects to talk about through cartons.
 

oldbadger

Skanky Old Mongrel!
Yes, France had a revolution for freedom, the uk is slowly removing human rights.
Ah.... just a second!
France was way behind us on that.
And the French have no more freedom than us, imo, unless they want to draw nasty pics! :D

As a young boy I watched a French Gendarme stopping a man outside a shop in ...... Carcasonne, I think (Cathedral with two different steeples?). Oh boy....... I never forgot that level of brutality. The man did nothing to protect himself, either with raised arm or hand, as that cop beat him senseless. French freedom......and French cops? You can keep 'em. :)
 

Howard Is

Lucky Mud
But there isn't a point in insulting religions through cartoons, it's just nonsense.
If people reject it then the magazine will find much more important subjects to talk about through cartons.

There was a point IMO.

The point was to insult fundamentalist Muslims, precisely to demonstrate that (1)they hold a view which is totally unacceptable to modern intellectual westerners, and (2) they feel entitled to enforce that view, even in non-Muslim countries.

I think the Charlie Hebdo action did clarify that situation.
 

ecco

Veteran Member
The easy way to be famous, they realized that many people hate Muslims and hence
presenting a work against Muslims will let them famous.

Why they don't offend Moses or Abraham the way they do with Muhammad?


Perhaps you should do some research before posting nonsense...

charliehebdo24.jpg

God doesn’t exist! “That turd! I had my doubts!”


And many others that would get me kicked out of RF if I posted them.



ETA: I see @TagliatelliMonster beat me by 6 hours.
 
Last edited:
Top