Therefore, the physical birth of the child is completed on the seventh day. The eighth day, the octave of birth, as it were, repeats the day of birth, but as a day of higher, spiritual birth for his Jewish mission and his Jewish destiny.
Rabbi Hirsch, Collected Writings III.
Rabbi Hirsch couldn't be more transparent nor correct: to be a Jew, in more than a ritual sense, one must be born-again. And that rebirth must occur from the blood of genital reproduction and not from the seed, or gall water . . . come, so to say, from that branch.
The statement of Rabbi Hirsch, quoted above, from his,
Collected Writings III. p. 111, is so important to this thread of thought that a similar statement from him should be quoted from his Chumash:
מילה [circumcision] is not a completion of, or supplement to, physical birth, but the beginning of a higher "octave." It marks the second, higher "birthday," man's entry into the Divine level of free and moral action. Physical birth belongs to the night . . . but מילה [circumcision], birth as a Jew, belongs to the daytime.
The Hirsch Chumash at Gen. 17:23.
How many times have Jews read Rabbi Hirsch speaking of a "second, higher, birthday," without thinking for a second of the idea of being "born-again"; you know,
a second, higher, birthday. Worsening the situation, Rabbi Hirsch says that this re-birth, this being born-again, is not even a completion of the first, physical birth, but rather, is like becoming a wholly new spiritual species (with apologies to St. Paul in 2 Corinthians 5:17).
And yet it gets even more problematic for Jewish theology, if that's possible. Rabbi Hirsch rubs salt into the wound he just opened by adding that the physical "conception" (the Hebrew word Rabbi Hirsch is quoting from the Talmud is "conception" not "birth") occurs at night, which is to say at the very time when the organ bled during the day-time conception is nakedly unfurled to conceive the physical person who, after the fleshly cocoon (the
orlah ערלה) is removed, on the eighth day, during the day, the day of the "second, higher, birthday," is found out to be not a genitile after all, but a Jew.
In another thread, a well-read Jewish person poo pooed the idea that a Jew, a real Jew, Rabbi Hirsch's Jew, is utterly incapable of performing phallic-sex to conceive or birth another real Jew, since not only was he himself not conceived as a Jew through phallic sex, on the first day, but, according to Rabbi Hirsch, he's conceived as a Jew in the broad daylight (a necessity according to Jewish law) precisely when the flesh made naked "at night" (when the fleshly genitile was conceived), is bled to death, in the light of day, at the very moment the Jew is being conceived from the blood of the flesh that conceived the flesh that the new, real, Jew, uses as merely its cocoon.
Perhaps part and parcel of all this is why, according to Jewish law, the male member adds nothing to the Jewishness of the child. It matters not a wink, according to Jewish law, whom the father is (Jew, Gentile, bohemian), since he has no part, the male member of the conception has no part, in the production of a Jew. At best the father helps the mother ---in the dead of night no less ----spin the physical cocoon the Jew will take so lightly he'll gladly ditch it when he approaches the spiritual mission his Jewish nature targets as its soul's destiny.
They are not all Israel which are of Israel. Neither, because they are the [physical] seed of Abraham are they all [God's] children. But in Isaac shall thy seed [singular] be called. That is, they which are the children of the flesh [phallus בשר], these are not the children of God: the the children of the promise[ed seed] are counted as the [plural] seed. . . Which [the latter] were born not of the dictates of the flesh, or the dictates of a man [in the dead of night], but of God [during the light of day].
Romans 9:6-7; John 1:13.
John