Yes we still reproduce and have done so since the first man and woman were created and commanded to do so.
Ah, there's the difference between us ─ you believe in magic and I don't.
It's funny when you think about it ─ it was Greek civilization that provided the ideas on which Western civilization and the Renaissance and the Enlightenment and the modern West were built (and which gave Christianity so many of its ideas, like souls and postmortal judgment and heaven and hell, like the eucharist, and so on). Yet Greek philosophy begins 26 centuries ago, when the Milesians, starting, it's said, with Thales, began explaining the world in natural terms and left the gods to themselves. And the Dark Ages were the period when Christian thought dominated the West and the writings of the ancient Greeks and Romans were suppressed, and their texts deliberately destroyed in many cases.
The trouble with magic as an explanation is that it explains nothing. Genesis has God creating light by saying Let there be light! and creating life by similar commands and molding humans from dust. That's not an explanation unless and until we're told how magic works, and we can understand the process that occurred when the words 'Let there be light' were spoken, and resulted in the EM spectrum.
How do you mold a human from dust?
And why does the result look exactly as it would if humans were produced by evolution instead?
For that matter, why does the bible think the universe is only a few thousand years old? Why does it know nothing of a heliocentric solar system? Why does it say instead (and only) that the earth is immovably fixed at the center of creation? Why does it think the earth is flat, and the sky (firmament) is a hard dome you can walk on, and to which the stars are attached such that if they come loose they'll fall to earth? Why does it have no concept of orbits, or deep space, or the nature of stars? And the answer is obvious ─ that was the science of their day, and science has come a long way since then.
But how would we know if, for example, gestation periods were three months instead of nine months then? How would we know if evolving and adapting did not work somewhat differently then, allowing, for example adaptations to occur ultra fast? (possibly even to the living creature itself rather than just to offspring)
We know that gestation is a phenomenon of placental mammals. The first vivipars appear in the fossil record in the few million years following the Triassic-Jurassic extinction event 205 m years ago; and the first placental mammals are found between 160 and 100 million years ago. Primates start about 65 mya, hominids about 30 mya, genus Homo develops between 25 and 5 mya, and we get to the earliest versions of Homo sapiens maybe 2.5 mya. Modern humans are much more recent, starting around 250 thousand years ago.
The good news: everything above is evidence-based, reasoned, examinable, explicable, and like all of science, a work in progress.
And no magic is involved.