Tumah
Veteran Member
In general, I consider "Christianity", as a "flock doomed to slaughter"(Ze 11:7), and sorely misled on all fronts, but among them you will find remnants of Joseph, and the children of Abraham.
Actually, Joseph saved all 11 tribes of Israel, including Judah, from starvation, by providing supplies of grain. The U.S. supplies would not be Joseph, but provided from his remnant, which according to Joel 3:2, "are scattered among the nations."[/quote]
The verse actually says "sheep of slaughter". The buyers, sellers and shepherds are the leaders of all the nations we've been exiled to.
The remnant of Joseph is Israel. Gen. 48:14-16 "And Israel sent his right hand... and he blessed Joseph, and he said '...bless the lads and call them by my name..." Also see the book of Hosea in numerous places from 4:16 onward.
Not sure how you're getting what you're getting out of Joel. It's Israel that's scattered among the nations. Joel 3(4 in Jewish version):2
"And I will gather all the nations... and I will be in judgement with them there about my nation and inheritance that [were] scattered in the nations..."
Judaism does not really on Scriptures alone. It is not a history book, it uses history to teach. But the parts that are not relevant to the lesson are left out. So we use other sources to fill them in. The story presented by our Tradition conveys a slightly different picture.
I don't see Joseph as being a king. He was not a king when he rescued Israel in Egypt, and I don't think he will be a king in the future with respect to Obadiah.
That's nice. See Gen. 41:40 onward. That's ruler-ship no matter how you slice it.
As for Obadiah 1:18, it reads Joseph who will be a "fire", and it does not mention Persia. How do you come up with your conclusion? Not that Persian can't destroy Esau by trying to destroy Israel, but I don't see your reference.
Sorry, those were meant to be two separate statements. I didn't mean for them to be connected. Joseph is not Persia. The Edom/Persia war statement was meant in response to your implication that the Israeli wars were related to the eschatological wars.
As for what kind of "fire", that would be answered in Ze 14:12.
That is a plague not a fire. The verse doesn't use any vocabulary related to fire. Joseph's fire and Esau's hay is metaphorical. It just means that Joseph is the most destructive of forces when against Esau. Zech 14:12 is G-d doing the work, not Joseph.
It relates to Zechariah 12:10, and Ze 14, and Ez 37:19, have not apparently been enacted with respect to Judah and the inhabitants of Jerusalem.
The only relation between these verses is that they are eschatological in content.
I never said that any of these verses happened yet, so I'm still not sure what you mean.
And what "spirit" is that? Will it be like the Spirit of Is 44:3, or like "My Spirit" poured out on the house of Israel, in Ez 39:29, or Joel 2:28? This year, the blood moon will supposedly happen on Passover, as supposedly happened in 1948,67, & 73, and Joel 2:31 is tied to Joel 2:28, "I pour out My Spirit in those days". Joel 2:31,"And the moon into blood".
No, all those times it says "My Spirit." Not every time the word "spirit" is used does it mean G-d's Spirit. I mean if it makes you feel better, you can look at it in the same way as Ex. 31:3 or Isa. 11:2, where the Spirit of G-d doesn't just represent G-d revealing Himself, but boosts certain attributes. In the case of Ex. it improves wisdom, understanding and knowledge. In Isa. also council, strength and fear of G-d. So here you can say the Spirit of G-d will rest on them and boost their grace in G-d's eyes an evoke their desire to supplicate Him. Either way, the result is the same.
Is the house of Judah, neither here nor there? Is the house of Judah limited to those who live in Judea, or will the 6.5 million in the U.S. be included? I was looking for something more definitive. I think there is more to the "house of David" than you have presented.
2 Samuel 5:7 NAS Nevertheless, David captured the stronghold of Zion, that is the city of David.
2 Kings 19:31 NAS 'For out of Jerusalem will go forth a remnant, and out of Mount Zion survivors. The zeal of the LORD will perform this.
Psalm 2:6 NAS"But as for Me, I have installed My King Upon Zion, My holy mountain."
Psalm 14:7 NAS Oh , that the salvation of Israel would come out of Zion ! When the LORD restores His captive people, Jacob will rejoice, Israel will be glad.
Is 56:6,"6 "Also the foreigners who join themselves to the LORD, To minister to Him, and to love the name of the LORD, To be His servants, every one who keeps from profaning the Sabbath And holds fast My covenant ; 7 Even those I will bring to My holy mountain
I am not trying to contradict or disregard those verses. I think the verse specifically refers to the House of David and the inhabitants of Jerusalem because that is where the war is holding at that point - at Jerusalem, just look at verse 9. I'm not really sure what you are disagreeing with me about the House of David.