My answer is depend on whether or not if God wants to communicate directly to everyone. I'll separate the hypothetical question in 2 scenarios and answer your question.
Q: (If God exists and if he wants to communicate directly to everyone) Do you think God would communicate directly to everyone?
A: Yes. I think God would communicate directly to everyone, because God wants to communicate directly to everyone.
Q: (If God exists and if he doesn't want to communicate directly to everyone) Do you think God would communicate directly to everyone?
A: No. I think God wouldn't communicate directly to everyone, because God don't want to communicate directly to everyone.
So what you are basing your answer upon are
what God would want to do. God would only communicate to everyone if God wanted to but God would not communicate to everyone if God did not want to. That sounds reasonable since God is the one who is doing the communicating so God should choose the method. Also, if God is Omnipotent humans have nothing to say about what God chooses to do and if God is Omniscient God has to know the best way to communicate to humans, so if that way was direct communication to everyone, God would have chosen that method.
My answer is depend on whether or not it's a duty or commitment for God to communicate directly to everyone. I'll separate the hypothetical question in 2 scenarios and answer your question.
Q: (If God exists and if it's a duty for God to communicate directly to everyone) Do you think it is reasonable to expect God to communicate directly to everyone?
A: Yes. I think it is reasonable to expect God to communicate directly to everyone, because it's a duty for God to do so.
Q: (If God exists and if it's not a duty for God to communicate directly to everyone) Do you think it is reasonable to expect God to communicate directly to everyone?
A: No. I think it is not reasonable to expect God to communicate directly to everyone, because it's not a duty for God to do so.
So you are saying that it would only be reasonable for God to communicate directly to everyone if it was a
duty for God to communicate directly to everyone.
So my question to you is if you think it would be a
duty for God to communicate directly to everyone? If so why, and if not why not?
My answer is depend on whether or not it's a duty for God to communicate directly to everyone. I'll separate the hypothetical question in 2 scenarios and answer your question.
Q: (If God exists and if it's a duty for God to communicate directly to everyone) Do you think that rational people would expect God to communicate directly to everyone?
A: Yes. I think that rational people would expect God to communicate directly to everyone, because it's a duty for God to communicate directly to everyone.
Q: (If God exists and if it's not a duty for God to communicate directly to everyone) Do you think that rational people would expect God to communicate directly to everyone?
A: No. I think that rational people wouldn't expect God to communicate directly to everyone, because it's not a duty for God to communicate directly to everyone.
So you are saying that rational people would only expect God to communicate directly to everyone if it was God’s duty to communicate directly to everyone.
So my first question to you is who determines what God’s duties are, God or humans?
My second questions are as follows: If you think it is God’s duty, why would God have such a duty? If you do not think it is God’s duty, why don’t you think it would be God’s duty?
Currently, no any self-acclaimed-omnipotent God has communicate directly to everyone, it may because:
(i) God don't want to do so.
(ii) God have done so, but many people are spiritually blind and can't see/hear God?
(iii) Those Gods don't exist.
I agree that these are the three logical possibilities. It is not a logical possibility that (iv) If God exists God would communicate directly to everyone, because God has never communicated directly to everyone. I suppose that an omnipotent could suddenly have a change of mind and heart and decide to communicate directly to everyone in the world but since that has never happened since the dawn of human history, there is no reason to believe that God would do that. Don’t you think that if God had
wanted to do that He would have done it already?
*** Please note that what I mean by communicate is not just that God makes Himself known to everyone, because we could argue that God has done so (ii) and some people are spiritually blind so they just do not see. What I mean by communication is sending everyone a message, the equivalent of a revelation such as the Bible. Should every single person on earth get their own full book of scriptures whispered into their ear? Is that a reasonable thing for God to do? Could everyone understand God and write all that down? Then what would happen? Would that make the world a better place? Is there a good reason why they cannot just all refer to the scriptures that God has made available?