IsmailaGodHasHeard
Well-Known Member
This section should be under Judaism. Judaism has the same beliefs. The only difference is that some Jews accept Yehoshua (Jesus) as their Messiah.
Welcome to Religious Forums, a friendly forum to discuss all religions in a friendly surrounding.
Your voice is missing! You will need to register to get access to the following site features:We hope to see you as a part of our community soon!
This section should be under Judaism. Judaism has the same beliefs. The only difference is that some Jews accept Yehoshua (Jesus) as their Messiah.
It's just where it should be. There's a wide spectrum of belief that this DIR covers, to be anywhere else would exclude some. When I came here, it was under christianity.This section should be under Judaism. Judaism has the same beliefs. The only difference is that some Jews accept Yehoshua (Jesus) as their Messiah.
Yeah, that would result in the Jews taking their religious discussions off this forum.This section should be under Judaism. Judaism has the same beliefs. The only difference is that some Jews accept Yehoshua (Jesus) as their Messiah.
Do you mind if ask a question here? Since Messianics believe in Jesus why are they not in the Christian forum? They are Christians who just happen to be Jews. Their theology is Christian.
Do you mind if ask a question here?
Since Messianics believe in Jesus why are they not in the Christian forum?
Despite the above statement, there are indeed MJ who are Christians in every way, but still identify themselves as Jews. These are 'Hebrew Christians' and this DIR is for them, too....They are Christians who just happen to be Jews. Their theology is Christian.
It's just where it should be. There's a wide spectrum of belief that this DIR covers, to be anywhere else would exclude some. When I came here, it was under christianity.
Do you mind if ask a question here? Since Messianics believe in Jesus why are they not in the Christian forum? They are Christians who just happen to be Jews. Their theology is Christian.
Actually it depends upon the group of messianics as to whether their theology is Christian in the complete sense of the word. I would say that the Mainstream of "Messianic Judaism" is completely Christian.
There are two (at least) distinct groups of MJ. The ones who come from Xian backgrounds will of course be "completely Christian". I prefer to call such by the term (that they often use themselves) 'Hebrew Christian'. I think of them as Seventh Day Adventists with a bit of Jewish culture added.
The MJ from Jewish backgrounds have very much less to do with Xianity. I prefer to self-label as 'Ebionite' to further distance myself, as I feel I have very little in common with that first group.
hmm. I don't think background has much to do with it. Michael Brown for example is from a Jewish background but he is theologically Christian in every sense of the word. There are some who were raised Christian but now share very little with Christian theology and identify more with Jewish theology, in fact may attend Orthodox or Conservative synagogues to worship as opposed to going to any Messianic group.
Do you mind if ask a question here? Since Messianics believe in Jesus why are they not in the Christian forum? They are Christians who just happen to be Jews. Their theology is Christian.
This section should be under Judaism. Judaism has the same beliefs. The only difference is that some Jews accept Yehoshua (Jesus) as their Messiah.
This section should be under Judaism. Judaism has the same beliefs. The only difference is that some Jews accept Yehoshua (Jesus) as their Messiah.