• Welcome to Religious Forums, a friendly forum to discuss all religions in a friendly surrounding.

    Your voice is missing! You will need to register to get access to the following site features:
    • Reply to discussions and create your own threads.
    • Our modern chat room. No add-ons or extensions required, just login and start chatting!
    • Access to private conversations with other members.

    We hope to see you as a part of our community soon!

Why are British English and American English so different?

MNoBody

Well-Known Member
looking in through this door of perspective yields some interesting linguistic clues
Lord_Bacon_stamp.png
 

Jainarayan

ॐ नमो भगवते वासुदेवाय
Staff member
Premium Member
Sanskrit.


Funny clip, and I love modern references to it (in ‘Dr. Strange’ Wong says to Stephen, “How’s your Sanskrit?”) but actually it’s not dead. There’s a town in Kerala India that is reviving it as a spoken language. There are Sanskrit newspapers. And of course it’s alive and well in every Hindu temple in the world.
 

Stevicus

Veteran Member
Staff member
Premium Member
Funny clip, and I love modern references to it (in ‘Dr. Strange’ Wong says to Stephen, “How’s your Sanskrit?”) but actually it’s not dead. There’s a town in Kerala India that is reviving it as a spoken language. There are Sanskrit newspapers. And of course it’s alive and well in every Hindu temple in the world.

It was also funny that he couldn't find a term paper for Sanskrit, so he gave him "Latin, it's the best I can do."

I suppose Latin isn't really completely "dead" either, since it's still used in various fields, including religion. But I don't know of any place where it's spoken conversationally. My dad had to take Latin when he was in school, although it wasn't required (or even offered) by the time I got to school.
 

Tambourine

Well-Known Member
Grammar and phonology are inextricably linked. You would not be very hard pressed or hard pressed in any way for any such thing. There are grammars from the time that define pronunciation. Not to mention that Sanskrit was taught for millennia by direct oral transmission from guru to disciple without deviation. If you want to know why I’ll tell you. But we do know how it sounded. There are also Roman grammars that describe Latin pronunciation, Classical Greek as well.
You make an argument by analogy, but do not supply direct evidence for your original claim (that we know for a fact how ancient Sanskrit sounded). Do you have any?
 

Tambourine

Well-Known Member
Italian is an artificial language.
It was decided that Dante's language would become standard Italian.
After all...each region has its own dialect.
;)
If you read the Divine Comedy it is exactly the language we Italians speak today.
The Divine Comedy is a book, it doesn't speak on its own.
Do you have any kind of evidence that Dante spoke in the exact same manner as modern Italians?
 

Estro Felino

Believer in free will
Premium Member
So you've got an authentic recording of Dante's speech somewhere?

Not all languages behave the same.
German evolved restlessly across centuries if you compare the Nibelungenlied with the Lutherbibel.
But Italian evolution was pretty static.
 

Jainarayan

ॐ नमो भगवते वासुदेवाय
Staff member
Premium Member
You make an argument by analogy, but do not supply direct evidence for your original claim (that we know for a fact how ancient Sanskrit sounded). Do you have any?

Did you not read and understand that I said it’s been transmitted faithfully from teacher to student for millennia? That’s how we know how it sounded. That is a core concept of Hinduism. Moreover, it is not “ancient” as if no longer used. The name is “Classical Sanskrit”. To contradict any of that without your own evidence is to disparage Hinduism. So don’t put on airs.
 

Tambourine

Well-Known Member
Not all languages behave the same.
German evolved restlessly across centuries if you compare the Nibelungenlied with the Lutherbibel.
But Italian evolution was pretty static.
Again, what do you base this on, apart from the unsupported assumption that Dante sounded just like you?
 

Tambourine

Well-Known Member
Did you not read and understand that I said it’s been transmitted faithfully from teacher to student for millennia? That’s how we know how it sounded. That is a core concept of Hinduism. Moreover, it is not “ancient” as if no longer used. The name is “Classical Sanskrit”. To contradict any of that without your own evidence is to disparage Hinduism. So don’t put on airs.
Most people are only barely capable of describing other people's speech patterns, let alone mimicking them to such an extent that we would have an unbroken transmission from 2000 years until now.

If you find my incredulity offensive, then I suggest that you do not stake the legitimacy of your religious convictions on spurious and implausible claims.
 

Estro Felino

Believer in free will
Premium Member
Again, what do you base this on, apart from the unsupported assumption that Dante sounded just like you?

Because no linguist says otherwise.
But if you have evidence that the Tuscan of the XIII cent. was different than now, show it to me.
;)
 

Tambourine

Well-Known Member
Because no linguist says otherwise.
But if you have evidence that the Tuscan of the XIII cent. was different than now, show it to me.
;)
You have no evidence that it was the same, do you?

So any unsupported opinion of mine is as good as yours here. ;)
 

Estro Felino

Believer in free will
Premium Member
You have no evidence that it was the same, do you?

So any unsupported opinion of mine is as good as yours here. ;)
So...if I said that Luther probably used to read German differently than it is pronounced now, would I have a point?
 

Secret Chief

nirvana is samsara
I mean...they sound like two completely different language....so many differences as for phonology...how is that possible? I mean...only 3 centuries separate the English from the Pilgrim Fathers



Three centuries is a long time in language - use, spelling, meaning, accents, dialects...
I suspect (with no evidence whatsoever) our dearly beloved emigrants wanted to create as much "difference" as possible between the two.

American and British English Words List (A to Z)

It's a minor miracle Brits and Yanks can understand each other at all. But then no-one can understand a Glaswegian.

 
Last edited:

Jainarayan

ॐ नमो भगवते वासुदेवाय
Staff member
Premium Member
... let alone mimicking them to such an extent that we would have an unbroken transmission from 2000 years until now.

Thank you for showing that you have no understanding of the importance of preserving Sanskrit as the language of Hinduism and how seriously it’s taken, and how it’s done. Or anything about the language, really. Go find a Sanskrit class and learn.
 
Last edited:
Top