• Welcome to Religious Forums, a friendly forum to discuss all religions in a friendly surrounding.

    Your voice is missing! You will need to register to get access to the following site features:
    • Reply to discussions and create your own threads.
    • Our modern chat room. No add-ons or extensions required, just login and start chatting!
    • Access to private conversations with other members.

    We hope to see you as a part of our community soon!

Who or what is being mindful?

Rick O'Shez

Irishman bouncing off walls
I've been practising satipatthana for some years. There is a sustained intention involved in practising mindfulness which doesn't sit too comfortably with the anatta doctrine.

So what do you think? This thread is open to anyone with experience of mindfulness practice.
 

wizanda

One Accepts All Religious Texts
Premium Member
Mindfulness is to be conscious of all thought, both in meditation and in daily life....

Allowing both positive and negative thoughts to go to their full extent; so you can understand more about everything, and not fight thoughts by trying to control everything.

It is like catching buses, and looking at the journey; once you've tried all the bus routes, you can then sit in the station (state of awareness), and be conscious of all routes i.e. Mindfulness. :innocent:
 

Rick O'Shez

Irishman bouncing off walls
Allowing both positive and negative thoughts to go to their full extent; so you can understand more about everything, and not fight thoughts by trying to control everything.

Sure, but who or what is doing the allowing?
 

wizanda

One Accepts All Religious Texts
Premium Member

buddhist

Well-Known Member
I've been practising satipatthana for some years. There is a sustained intention involved in practising mindfulness which doesn't sit too comfortably with the anatta doctrine.

So what do you think? This thread is open to anyone with experience of mindfulness practice.
At its very root, the sankhara-khandha, the second nidana in paticcasamuppada, is that which produces mindfulness.
 

allfoak

Alchemist
When we were children we got scolded for being mindful when we should have been doing our homework.
We grew up and abandoned the idea of imagination because we had to many other things to be "mindful" of.
No wonder we don't know what it means to be mindful as adults.

Mindfulness is the proper use of imagination.
We often think of imagination as not being in control of our mind.
"We are just imagining things", we are told.
We imagine ourselves through life, unfortunately it is often not very constructive.
When it is controlled however, it becomes a very powerful tool that is called mindfulness.

I would say that our imagination is vital to the process of transformation.
It is through the imagination that new projects begin and grow.
I love this faculty of imagination, it allows me to be creative and constructive.
If i am not using my imagination properly then i am not mindful of the direction i am moving in or how it is that i am getting there.


Unfortunately mindfulness has become the idea of just observing things.
I propose it to be a tool of transformation like every other faculty we have.
 

allfoak

Alchemist
To better answer the question, "Who or What is Being Mindful?"

Our soul is ever mindful.
Our body consciousness is always mindful as well but often not in sync with the mindfulness of the soul.
Thus, the cause of discord in the mind and body.
 

Osal

Active Member
It depends where we're looking from; why i tried here to redefine where different aspects of the inner being come from.

To be in an enlightened state the soul allows everything; yet depending how much arguing internally, the ego and self can deny it, which is why i went into questioning what all the different aspects were, after reading a book on mindfulness. :innocent:
Sure, but who or what is doing the allowing?

Easy. If you're speaking of relative reality, it's you. If it's ultimate, there is no you.

Itellectually, it's pointless to take it any farther.
 

Aupmanyav

Be your own guru
Our soul is ever mindful.
Our body consciousness is always mindful as well but often not in sync with the mindfulness of the soul.
Thus, the cause of discord in the mind and body.
Being an atheist, don't know about soul, but nice idea.
 

atanu

Member
Premium Member
Unnecessary question.
'Being' is not a philosophical proposition.

Yes. But I say yes probably for the opposite reason. The self needs no third party validation. Self is self validated in the present.
 
Last edited:

atanu

Member
Premium Member
I've been practising satipatthana for some years. There is a sustained intention involved in practising mindfulness which doesn't sit too comfortably with the anatta doctrine.

So what do you think? This thread is open to anyone with experience of mindfulness practice.

Anything that one can be mindful about or anything that can be grasped physically or mentally, is anatta. When all such graspable objects are discarded as anatta, what further?
 

Aupmanyav

Be your own guru
Ha. That is true. But what then? The anatta comes to know about anitya?
Sometimes, not always. ;) It is a difficult broad jump, the chasm is wide. Some only touch the edge of the other side.
manipulate3.jpg

https://www.google.co.in/search?q=j...X&ved=0ahUKEwjdztbrxsnLAhUFkI4KHSy8Cg4QsAQIGg
One needs a 45 degree trajectory (or more effort). ;)
When all such graspable objects are discarded as anatta, what further?
IMHO, Understanding.
 
Last edited:

Papoon

Active Member
Anything that one can be mindful about or anything that can be grasped physically or mentally, is anatta. When all such graspable objects are discarded as anatta, what further?

Life is lived.
Pleasure is enjoyed.
Pain is accepted.
Skill is developed.
Compassion is free flowing.
Questioning ceases.
 
Top