Welcome to Religious Forums, a friendly forum to discuss all religions in a friendly surrounding.
Your voice is missing! You will need to register to get access to the following site features:We hope to see you as a part of our community soon!
"Only these two"? That doesn't make much since because those "only these two" are "the books/official scripture" of Christianity and Islam.
If we are to learn about Christianity one must read the NT, just as if one is to learn about Islam then the Quran must be read.
If I can't critically read and examine what is there for myself then it's nothing but moving the goal posts to try to say it can't be done and must be done with "god's approved."The Quran itself doesn't say Quran is to be approached by itself. It talked about relying on God then in that context said therefore ask the family of the reminder if you do not know.
Have you given Ahlulbayt (a) a chance to clarify Quran?
Or did you go to other then those appointed by God to understand Quran?
You see, the flaw is in relying on other then those Awliya (masters) chosen by God. They are the light revealed in the Quran and hence you are only to rely on what God has revealed (Quran and Ahlulbayt), not other then that.
Also hadiths are a minefield... therefore you need to connect to Ahlulbayt (a) beyond just hadiths even though you need to use their hadiths as waypoints as well.
If I can't critically read and examine what is there for myself then it's nothing but moving the goal posts to try to say it can't be done and must be done with "god's approved."
Who is the God of Abraham to you? I've seen a couple of featured threads about the God of Abraham today but first we could ask who is He and can we define Him? So often when we discuss the God of Abraham we have vastly different concepts.
Is He a he, her or transcendent about human conception of gender. Is He knowable, unknowable and how can we know. Did He send Prophets, Messengers, Avatars or Manifestations? Do scriptures inform us of who He is? Which scriptures enlighten us and which lead us to confusion? Does He exist or not exist? What else should we know? Who is the God of Abraham to you?
Who is the God of Abraham to you? I've seen a couple of featured threads about the God of Abraham today but first we could ask who is He and can we define Him? So often when we discuss the God of Abraham we have vastly different concepts.
Is He a he, her or transcendent about human conception of gender. Is He knowable, unknowable and how can we know. Did He send Prophets, Messengers, Avatars or Manifestations? Do scriptures inform us of who He is? Which scriptures enlighten us and which lead us to confusion? Does He exist or not exist? What else should we know? Who is the God of Abraham to you?
... Who is the God of Abraham to you?
"Only these two"? That doesn't make much since because those "only these two" are "the books/official scripture" of Christianity and Islam.
If we are to learn about Christianity one must read the NT, just as if one is to learn about Islam then the Quran must be read.
Why should we love someone who would eternally damn someone over a short life of mistakes?
You can't rightfully or properly criticize something unless you know about it.Why do you have to learn about Christianity or Islam? Are they the criterion to decide about God?
Quran is mistranslated horribly. Just know that.
If I can't critically read and examine what is there for myself then it's nothing but moving the goal posts to try to say it can't be done and must be done with "god's approved."
You can't rightfully or properly criticize something unless you know about it.
And I was a Christian, born into it, so I did a lot of learning about it for the first 15 years of my life.
For me there is only 1 God, so God of Abraham = Brahman = Allah = ...Who is the God of Abraham to you?
Different than the christian god.Who is the God of Abraham to you?
The first time I did was during a crisis of faith. And looking upon it with my own eyes, searching for the guidance I needed but I only found evil to finished driving me away.Have you done this with The Gospels? Read them without prejudice, I mean?
I don't use "god" as a catch all. I am criticizing the God of Abraham.But why should any of this be you'r criterion to decide this God is so evil? Are you criticising God or Christianity with this 15 years of study?