Which Commentary?

[Jayhawker Soule]

... whether or not it's historically true, it wouldn't be a far cry from reality.

That's an interesting formulation. (I'll leave it at that.)

 

[dybmh]

Out of curiosity, who here sees this as being in any way historically accurate?

I was kinda hoping for a picture of the sword in the newer Koren Talmud... But it was a stretch, I admit it.

 

[dybmh]

Very well. But whether or not it's historically true, it wouldn't be a far cry from reality.

What I'm looking for is the shortest path, with the least interference, to answer Rival's question. I'm looking for something plausible. And nothing mystical, that's per Rival in a previous thread... maybe 6 months ago...

 

[Rival]

What I'm looking for is the shortest path, with the least interference, to answer Rival's question. I'm looking for something plausible. And nothing mystical, that's per Rival in a previous thread... maybe 6 months ago...

Nothing mystical?? I don't recall drunk posting....but then I wouldn't

 

[dybmh]

Nothing mystical?? I don't recall drunk posting....but then I wouldn't

It was a while ago... i'll send you a PM...

Edit to add: May 2019...

 

[dybmh]

@Jayhawker Soule ,

The sword... I was hoping for a picture of the Ammonite sword...

But it is comical, I hope you enjoyed it.

 

[dybmh]

OK... nevermind... @Rival says mystical stuff is OK. ( Paraphrased )

 

[Harel13]

OK... nevermind... @Rival says mystical stuff is OK. ( Paraphrased )

Yes! Magic is on!