I thought that this link was interesting:
This feels spot on. When you feel safe, you are more likely to want to share ("socialist") and embrace others (tolerance). When you feel threatened, you build walls, buy more guns, and try to keep people who don't look or speak like you, and those whom you feel intend to replace you, out of power and influence. Fear becomes anger.
Any thoughts about the validity of this way of framing this?
"Studies have consistently shown that turning liberals into conservatives (at least temporarily) is surprisingly easy. All you need to do is scare them.
"For example, one group of experimenters asked students to think about their own death before taking tests designed to assess their political beliefs. Over several experiments, the researchers, from the University of Central Arkansas, found that when the participants had been asked to think about their own death they became more conservative, and had attitudes in line with their conservative classmates on issues from capital punishment and abortion, to rights for gay employees.
"The theory goes that the liberal students became much more socially conservative than the control group (who thought about television) because thinking about their own death made them feel vulnerable."
“Moreover, defensive conservatism appears to be a general psychological response to vulnerability that is not necessarily strategically linked to the eliciting threats.”
"Now researchers have discovered an easy way to do the reverse – turn conservatives into liberals. Psychologist John Bargh has written about experiments his team conducted in which he managed to turn conservatives liberal through another thought experiment.
"It turns out the way to do this is to make them visualize themselves as Superman. Just as taking off Clark Kent's glasses turned him into Superman, picturing yourself as Superman turns conservatives into people who care about the poor.
"In John Bargh's book Before You Know It: The Unconscious Reasons We Do What We Do he writes that he and his team asked participants to picture themselves as Superman. They were asked to really picture what it would be like to be as invincible as Superman – Business Insider reports – where bullets, fire, and falling off a cliff wouldn't hurt them. The control group was asked to picture themselves merely having the ability to fly.
"The participants were then asked to rate statements to assess their political beliefs. This time the experimenters found that it was conservatives' beliefs that shifted. They became – albeit briefly – more socially liberal than they were, whilst liberals' attitudes remained unchanged by the thought experiment.
"The authors say that this is the first time experimental evidence has shown that making people feel safe can make them feel more liberal.
"For example, one group of experimenters asked students to think about their own death before taking tests designed to assess their political beliefs. Over several experiments, the researchers, from the University of Central Arkansas, found that when the participants had been asked to think about their own death they became more conservative, and had attitudes in line with their conservative classmates on issues from capital punishment and abortion, to rights for gay employees.
"The theory goes that the liberal students became much more socially conservative than the control group (who thought about television) because thinking about their own death made them feel vulnerable."
“Moreover, defensive conservatism appears to be a general psychological response to vulnerability that is not necessarily strategically linked to the eliciting threats.”
"Now researchers have discovered an easy way to do the reverse – turn conservatives into liberals. Psychologist John Bargh has written about experiments his team conducted in which he managed to turn conservatives liberal through another thought experiment.
"It turns out the way to do this is to make them visualize themselves as Superman. Just as taking off Clark Kent's glasses turned him into Superman, picturing yourself as Superman turns conservatives into people who care about the poor.
"In John Bargh's book Before You Know It: The Unconscious Reasons We Do What We Do he writes that he and his team asked participants to picture themselves as Superman. They were asked to really picture what it would be like to be as invincible as Superman – Business Insider reports – where bullets, fire, and falling off a cliff wouldn't hurt them. The control group was asked to picture themselves merely having the ability to fly.
"The participants were then asked to rate statements to assess their political beliefs. This time the experimenters found that it was conservatives' beliefs that shifted. They became – albeit briefly – more socially liberal than they were, whilst liberals' attitudes remained unchanged by the thought experiment.
"The authors say that this is the first time experimental evidence has shown that making people feel safe can make them feel more liberal.
This feels spot on. When you feel safe, you are more likely to want to share ("socialist") and embrace others (tolerance). When you feel threatened, you build walls, buy more guns, and try to keep people who don't look or speak like you, and those whom you feel intend to replace you, out of power and influence. Fear becomes anger.
Any thoughts about the validity of this way of framing this?
