• Welcome to Religious Forums, a friendly forum to discuss all religions in a friendly surrounding.

    Your voice is missing! You will need to register to get access to the following site features:
    • Reply to discussions and create your own threads.
    • Our modern chat room. No add-ons or extensions required, just login and start chatting!
    • Access to private conversations with other members.

    We hope to see you as a part of our community soon!

The Documentary Hypothesis of the Torah

Truthseeker

Non-debating member when I can help myself
I am taking a course on the Hebrew Bible at the Wilmette Institute, and the following is a post by another person there on the Documentary Hypothesis of the Torah.

The compilation of all these sources occurred from 10th to 6th century. The sources were woven together with great skill. Torah is a product of 5 centuries of religious and Literary activity.

This theory is named “Documentary Hypothesis “; it is also known as "source criticism" or "historical criticism". It is bases on analyzing terminology, style and motifs of the authors.

This theory is still disputed by conservative groups.

E Source (Elohist)
  • Supplement to J Source; difficult to isolate.
  • Less anthropomorphic.
  • No face-to-face revelation; God is more distant.
  • Emphasis in Prophets.
  • Style is more abstract; less picturesque.
  • Revelation/covenant is in Mt Horeb.
  • Concern with Northern tribes; likely composed 9th BCE on the North.
  • Israel Ancient Patriarchs, Moses and wandering in the desert.
  • Very fragmentary.
J Source (Jahwist)
  • Humans know God by Name (Javeh/Lord)
  • Begins with 2nd creation story (Gn 2:4)
  • Anthropomorphically descriptions of God.
  • Vivid and concrete earthly style.
  • Refers to Mt Sinai as place of revelation/covenant.
  • Date: granting/justification of a national land to Israelites (10 century BCE).
  • Reflects the interest of the South (Judah).
D Source (Deuteronomist)
  • Book of Deuteronomy.
  • It contains three speeches delivery by Moses.
  • Reflects interest of Agrarian life (not Nomads).
  • Insists in one central Sanctuary (not several altars);never says its Jerusalem.
  • All sacrifices should be offered in the central sanctuary.
  • Centralization of the Cult is a key aspect of religious reform of King Josiah (7th BCE).
  • But it seems to reflect Northern Tribes.
P Source (Priestly)
  • Leviticus and Numbers (non-narrative part).
  • Great concern with Religious institutions, Sacrificial rites, Sabbath. Passover,
  • It has some narrative.
  • God is transcendent and remote (more than J). His name is known only when He reveals Himself.
  • It focus in covenant, census, genealogies.
  • Functions as a bridge between stories.
  • Seems a final editing of other material and sources Bible.
  • Composed during/after the Exile (post 586 BCE)
What do you all think of this hypothesis?
 

paarsurrey

Veteran Member
The Documentary Hypothesis of the Torah
What do you all think of this hypothesis?

It is yet another effort to dig/find the truth in what has reached to us that is called "Torah". It must be appreciated on merit of reasons and arguments. Right, please?
Regards
 
Top