Twilight Hue
Twilight, not bright nor dark, good nor bad.
How does a prerequisite of free will (as per the Abrahamic definition) apply in context with the story of Adam and Eve given that the trees of life and the knowledge of Good and Evil had been forbidden in the first place?
Can Adam and Eve have free will if they didn't know firsthand any knowledge for what is good or evil, or any knowledge of the tree of life was all about without first knowing what death was?
What would Adam and Eve's disposition be called prior to the downfall?
According to the Book of Genesis, it appears that Adam and Eve did not have any free will because the Forbidden trees did not provide knowledge or life as it is described thus eliminating any real sense of free will for Adam and Eve.
I think the Garden of Eden never was a place for free will given the confines of the garden itself and the initial nature of Adam and Eve as it's described.
I have a feeling they never would have been allowed outside the garden and restricted to live out their lives for eternity (Depending upon your view), inside the garden itself, never to venture out or obtain any knowledge whatsoever.
So how can Abrahamic's say free Will initially applied with Adam and Eve in the Garden of Eden?
It just simply can't. I don't see how it's possible. Even with a talking serpent, I don't think they would have understood.
Additionally,
Does free will even apply to the Garden of Eden in the story of Adam and Eve?
Can Adam and Eve have free will if they didn't know firsthand any knowledge for what is good or evil, or any knowledge of the tree of life was all about without first knowing what death was?
What would Adam and Eve's disposition be called prior to the downfall?
According to the Book of Genesis, it appears that Adam and Eve did not have any free will because the Forbidden trees did not provide knowledge or life as it is described thus eliminating any real sense of free will for Adam and Eve.
I think the Garden of Eden never was a place for free will given the confines of the garden itself and the initial nature of Adam and Eve as it's described.
I have a feeling they never would have been allowed outside the garden and restricted to live out their lives for eternity (Depending upon your view), inside the garden itself, never to venture out or obtain any knowledge whatsoever.
So how can Abrahamic's say free Will initially applied with Adam and Eve in the Garden of Eden?
It just simply can't. I don't see how it's possible. Even with a talking serpent, I don't think they would have understood.
Additionally,
Does free will even apply to the Garden of Eden in the story of Adam and Eve?