A lot of people who do that, but don't wish to know the teachings, are atheist arguers that are kind of being a bad caricature of their whole side, and of people within their group. So while I might be sitting there drinking tea and eating crumpets with the other people who are atheists, and agreeing to disagree, one or two particular atheists just have to remind you with shouts and yells of their disbelief and cognitive dissonance of religion.
I find that most people who cherry pick tend to be christians who also shout and yell and stomp their foot.
Im guessing in probably the same proportion as your atheist nemesis. Only problem is there are far more of the Christian foot stompers than atheist foot stompers.