• Welcome to Religious Forums, a friendly forum to discuss all religions in a friendly surrounding.

    Your voice is missing! You will need to register to get access to the following site features:
    • Reply to discussions and create your own threads.
    • Our modern chat room. No add-ons or extensions required, just login and start chatting!
    • Access to private conversations with other members.

    We hope to see you as a part of our community soon!

Republican Drift Into Fascism-- Why?

Revoltingest

Pragmatic Libertarian
Premium Member
There are some who do attack speech - so to that point, it does happen. Discrimination for some is redressing historical bigotry and discrimination for another.
Of course Democrats have reasons for discrimination.
There are always reasons. Nonetheless, it is what it is,
ie, discrimination (race & gender) by government,
& its requirement imposed upon the private sector.
Democrats like it. I don't.
 

Stevicus

Veteran Member
Staff member
Premium Member
See: MSNBC’s Mehdi Hasan calls out Republicans for supporting 'fascistic' future PM of Italy (yahoo.com)

We have seen much the same, such as with CPAC's cheering on Orban, who also is fascist leaning. Same with some other such leaders. And why won't Trump denounce Putin even when given the opportunity, such a just a short time ago when Hannity set him up? Why doesn't this seem to bother most of his followers?

As a student of the Holocaust, I find this trend very disturbing, and I don't understand how people who supposedly love democracy and who supposedly believe in Jesus can go along with this? It seems that some have a death wish, not only for democracy but also for Christianity itself.

I think a lot of it is driven by fear, which was also the case in Germany and Italy before fascism took over those countries.

One thing that seems to get missed is that these kinds of regimes and ideologies don't just pop up out of the blue, nor are they result of magical oratory suddenly transforming an otherwise normal group of humans into homicidal maniacs.

For example, in Germany, they started on the road to fascism the minute some numbskull suddenly decided it would be a great idea to raise the price of a loaf of bread to $3 billion. It's people who make decisions like that which lead countries towards fascism. It's not the speeches or the rallies or the propaganda or the powerful oratory or even the bullying by thugs. Bad management and greed (usually by those who don't intend or want fascism) do far more towards propelling a country in that direction than anything else.
 

Estro Felino

Believer in free will
Premium Member
It's not the speeches or the rallies or the propaganda or the powerful oratory or even the bullying by thugs. Bad management and greed (usually by those who don't intend or want fascism) do far more towards propelling a country in that direction than anything else.
Exactly. Standing ovation @Stevicus
 

Estro Felino

Believer in free will
Premium Member
If there were more compromise between Conservatives and Liberals in the United States, there would not be such a polarization.
 

PureX

Veteran Member
It's not the speeches or the rallies or the propaganda or the powerful oratory or even the bullying by thugs. Bad management and greed (usually by those who don't intend or want fascism) do far more towards propelling a country in that direction than anything else.
Greed is invisible in the U.S. It simply doesn't exist. It's been renamed "capitalism" and is now being praised as the savior of all mankind.
 

Brickjectivity

wind and rain touch not this brain
Staff member
Premium Member
In what way does anyone suggest that Christianity opposes Americanism? Then discuss that. Early American values are no taxation without representation and independence from England and equality of all humans. The bill of rights comes into existence at the insistence of Patrick Henry who gives rights a theological basis. Early American politics are based upon avoidance of the failures of politics previous.
 

Twilight Hue

Twilight, not bright nor dark, good nor bad.
I gleaned two things from this. One is that you have no real understanding of Republicans. The other is that this is further proof that the intellectual ammunition of the left is exhausted and they are getting desperate. When a group is reduced to ad hominem attacks it is telling. Baselessly calling Republicans and conservatives names is a losing strategy.
I get nothing but ad hominem attacks personally now almost all the time here. "0]

Anyways, there is something I want to know and ask that a fair number of Democrats are openly touting socialism in media and the public. They are not even hiding it.

So with that aspect well documented, where are all the Republicans openly touting in media they support facisism?

Your 100% correct, they are desperate, attacking people with ad hominems like crazy and haven't the least bit of understanding about Republicans nor facisism.
 

PureX

Veteran Member
Fascism is all about control.

The republican party has been pandering to several disgruntled and disenfranchised groups of Americans since doing it back in the 1990s worked to get "W" elected. Those groups are mainly fundamentalist type Christians and racial and ethnic bigots. Both of whom exist in significant numbers and have been angry for a long time about their being marginalized by a cultural shift toward liberalism that began back in the 1960s and that resulted in women, gays, blacks, and foreigners being afforded equal status with white, male, heterosexual, Christians in our society. Causing a lot of fear, anger, and resentment on the part of these newly marginalized groups.

And now they want their power back. They want to be in control again, and that's what the republican party has been promising them to get their votes. The republican party never actually intended to give them any control, as that was always reserved for the wealthy elites. The republican party was nothing if not the party of, by, and for the rich. But after they'd promised this for so long, and fired up this angry, resentful, disenfranchised base for so long, it basically exploded behind Donald Trump and he took over the party. So that now, more than ever, republicans are all about control. They want their white, male, heterosexual, Christian butts back in the driver's seat and to hell with democracy if democracy stands in their way! To hell with the law if the law stands in their way! To hell with YOU if you stand in the way! They are on a holy crusade, now. And that's basically fascism: control without opposition.
 
Last edited:

Brickjectivity

wind and rain touch not this brain
Staff member
Premium Member
Did it really? Seems to me the world stood by.
Most disbelieved the news about it, and remember that there was disinformation about it not merely information. If I had been alive I probably would have doubted that it was true. There was a war on, and so naturally I would have questioned then (as people did) whether such information should be believed. The very idea that someone would choose to eradicate a large segment of their own population?

A lot of people also would have found it difficult to understand why the Jews in Germany had not already fled in large groups. There were many opportunities to disbelieve the news. There were also famous people (such as Henry Ford) talking about how Jews could not be trusted or were problematic. I am sure that had I lived in USA at the time that I would have ignored tales of the holocaust and even questioned them in the face of data, instead choosing to believe that the Germans would have been sensible and that the Nazis would not have been insane enough to do such a strange thing as what they did.
 

metis

aged ecumenical anthropologist
I would like to tell this excellent British journalist that in Italy, a traditionally socialist country, it is rightful and holy to condemn financial speculators.
Because it is not operations that the law okays.

This is the Paradise of Freedom of Speech, ladies and gentlemen.
Fascism is basically the antithesis of democratic socialism. In the case of Meloni, we'll just have to wait and see how this plays out.

Socialism is a mindset that tries to more equalize the "playing field", whereas fascism tends to put the power and most of the wealth in the hands of a minority, such as what we see in Russia today. Fascists historically tried to pawn themselves off as being socialists, such as what the three fascist leaders in Europe did in the 20th century, but we saw how that went with people sorta taking a permanent "vacation", never to be seen again. Mussolini did this, but he had these "vacationers" sent to eastern Africa, and they must have loved it so much there that they never returned. :rolleyes:
 

Estro Felino

Believer in free will
Premium Member
It's better than other candidates for savior,
eg, Jesus, Muhammed, L Ron Hubbard,
socialism, communism, anarchy, AOC.
I think it is extremely laughable that what the British journalist tried to do was to depict the "financial speculators" as people victimized by Giorgia Meloni's speech.
I think there is an upheaval of the victim-perpetrator cycle.
Nobody sees them as victims.
 
Last edited:

Estro Felino

Believer in free will
Premium Member
Fascism is basically the antithesis of democratic socialism. In the case of Meloni, we'll just have to wait and see how this plays out.

Socialism is a mindset that tries to more equalize the "playing field", whereas fascism tends to put the power and most of the wealth in the hands of a minority, such as what we see in Russia today. Fascists historically tried to pawn themselves off as being socialists, such as what the three fascist leaders in Europe did in the 20th century, but we saw how that went with people sorta taking a permanent "vacation", never to be seen again. Mussolini did this, but he had these "vacationers" sent to eastern Africa, and they must have loved it so much there that they never returned. :rolleyes:
Did you actually watch Hasan's video?


He says the opposite. Meloni's speech victimizes financial speculators.
Maybe he fails to realize that siding with financial speculators doesn't make you win the elections.
 

metis

aged ecumenical anthropologist
I gleaned two things from this. One is that you have no real understanding of Republicans. The other is that this is further proof that the intellectual ammunition of the left is exhausted and they are getting desperate. When a group is reduced to ad hominem attacks it is telling. Baselessly calling Republicans and conservatives names is a losing strategy.
Keep telling yourself that while taking positions that simply do not recognize the dangers that we have today while you're forgetting the warnings of the Holocaust.

I was a Republican, taught a poli sci course for 25 years dealing with the Constitution, and I studied the Holocaust here, in Poland, and in Israel and taught a three-week unit on it. If you think that I don't know what I'm talking about, then it's on you, so go ahead and wear your MAGA cap while going around blind to what's happening all around you.
 
Last edited:

Estro Felino

Believer in free will
Premium Member
Keep telling yourself that, while taking positions that simply do not recognize the dangers that we have today while you're forgetting the warnings of the Holocaust.

I was a Republican, taught a poli sci course for 25 years dealing with the Constitution, and I studied the Holocaust here, in Poland, and in Israel and taught a three-week unit on it If you think that I don't know what I'm talking about, then it's on you, so go ahead and wear your MAGA cap while going around blind to what's happening all around you.
I fail to understand what Trump or Meloni or Pompeo have to do with the Holocaust.
 

metis

aged ecumenical anthropologist
Did you actually watch Hasan's video?


He says the opposite. Meloni's speech victimizes financial speculators.
Maybe he fails to realize that siding with financial speculators doesn't make you win the elections.
Please listen to it again, but maybe do so v-e-r-y s-l-o-w-l-y, as it goes 100% with what I posted in #34 even though I didn't mention that anti-Semitic aspect of it that's what also has been reflected in her party.
 

Revoltingest

Pragmatic Libertarian
Premium Member
I think it is extremely laughable that what the British journalist tried to do was to depict the "financial speculators" as people victimized by Giorgia Meloni's speech.
I think there is an upheaval of the victim-perpetrator cycle.
Nobody sees them as victims.
I'm not paying her or the Brits enuf
attention to be familiar with that drama.
 

metis

aged ecumenical anthropologist
I think a lot of it is driven by fear, which was also the case in Germany and Italy before fascism took over those countries.

One thing that seems to get missed is that these kinds of regimes and ideologies don't just pop up out of the blue, nor are they result of magical oratory suddenly transforming an otherwise normal group of humans into homicidal maniacs.

For example, in Germany, they started on the road to fascism the minute some numbskull suddenly decided it would be a great idea to raise the price of a loaf of bread to $3 billion. It's people who make decisions like that which lead countries towards fascism. It's not the speeches or the rallies or the propaganda or the powerful oratory or even the bullying by thugs. Bad management and greed (usually by those who don't intend or want fascism) do far more towards propelling a country in that direction than anything else.
In each case it was driven by reactions to the status quo that many, if not most found unacceptable, but in the process of doing that just remember what occurred next in each case. IOW, they talked-the-talk of democratic socialism but definitely didn't walk-the-walk, and consider how many millions of people "disappeared" one way or the other because of this. The proof of this is in the history books.

Consider reading "Strongmen" by NYU poli sci professor Ruth Ben-Ghiat, the daughter of Holocaust survivors.
 
Top